Dismissal for Leaving Church: BAG Ruling Strengthens Rights of Church Employees

Kündigung wegen Kirchenaustritts: BAG-Urteil stärkt Rechte kirchlicher Arbeitnehmer – kuendigung-wegen-kirchenaustritt

A dismissal for leaving church is not automatically valid – the Federal Labor Court (BAG) decided this in a landmark ruling on March 17, 2026. Employees in church institutions can breathe easier: anyone who leaves the church does not necessarily lose their job, especially not if the employer also employs people who do not belong to any church. This article explains the case, the legal background, and how you can defend yourself if it happens to you.

Dismissal for leaving church: What the BAG ruling means for church employees

The Federal Labor Court clarified with its ruling of March 17, 2026 (Ref. 2 AZR 196/22) that a dismissal for leaving church can violate the General Equal Treatment Act (AGG). The case involved a social pedagogue working in pregnancy counseling for a Catholic women’s and professional association. She left the Catholic Church in October 2013 but continued working until 2019 – interrupted by maternity protection and parental leave. The employer learned of her departure in December 2013 but only tried to persuade her to rejoin in 2018 and 2019. When that failed, he gave her extraordinary dismissal without notice in June 2019, alternatively ordinary dismissal to year-end.

The woman fought back with an action for protection against dismissal and won before the labor courts. The BAG confirmed the invalidity of both dismissals. The decisive factor: at the time of dismissal, the employer employed two other women in pregnancy counseling who were not members of the Catholic Church. Therefore, the requirement to be a church member was not essential for performing the job.

The case: Pregnancy counseling, church exit, and dismissal after parental leave

The plaintiff had been employed by the defendant association since February 2006, a women’s and professional association within the Catholic Church dedicated to helping children, adolescents, women, and their families. Her duties included counseling pregnant women. From June 2013 through May 31, 2019, she was continuously on maternity protection or parental leave. During this period, she left the Catholic Church in October 2013 – a step she did not publicize but declared to the competent state authority. The employer learned of it in December 2013.

After parental leave ended, the association held talks with the plaintiff aimed at persuading her to rejoin the Church. These failed. The employer then dismissed her by letter of June 1, 2019, extraordinarily without notice, alternatively ordinarily to December 31, 2019. The plaintiff filed an action for protection against dismissal and also claimed compensation for the employer’s default in acceptance and damages for discrimination. The lower courts ruled in her favor – and the BAG confirmed the dismissals were invalid.

AGG and church basic order: Why the dismissal was invalid

The AGG prohibits discrimination on grounds of religion. The employer relied on the „Basic Order of Ecclesiastical Service in the Context of Church Employment Relationships“ from 2015 and considered the church exit a serious breach of loyalty. But the BAG made clear: discrimination occurred, and it was not justified. The employer’s requirement that employees be members of the Catholic Church is not essential for the work of a social pedagogue in pregnancy counseling. This follows already from the fact that the association assigned the same tasks to non-Catholic employees.

Moreover, the extraordinary dismissal without notice failed because of the deadline in § 626(2) BGB (German Civil Code). The employer had not observed the two-week deadline for giving notice of dismissal, since he had known about the church exit since December 2013. The summary dismissal was therefore invalid from the outset – regardless of the discrimination question.

ECJ ruling C-258/24: The decisive requirements for church employers

The BAG had referred the case to the European Court of Justice (ECJ) to clarify the interpretation of Directive 2000/78/EC (Equal Treatment Framework Directive). The ECJ answered with its ruling of March 17, 2026 (C-258/24). The core statement: church employers may require church membership from their employees only if this requirement is essential for the specific activity. If it is not – for example because non-members perform the same work – a dismissal for leaving church would be impermissible discrimination.

The BAG has now concretized these requirements. It is not enough for the employer to invoke its self-image. What matters is whether the professional requirement is objectively necessary. For a social pedagogue in pregnancy counseling, it is not, because counseling can take place independently of denomination. Church employers therefore face a significantly higher hurdle in future if they want to dismiss employees because of a church exit.

What the ruling means for employees in church institutions

The ruling strengthens the rights of employees in church institutions. A dismissal for leaving church is not automatically valid – it must withstand strict scrutiny. Anyone working in a church institution but no longer belonging to the church can invoke the AGG if the employer also employs other non-members in comparable positions. This applies particularly to social professions such as counseling, nursing, or education, where denominational affiliation is not strictly required.

Employees should know: even if the employer justifies a dismissal with the church exit, there is often a good chance of successfully defending against it. The action for protection against dismissal is the right way to have the invalidity established. Filing the lawsuit within three weeks of receiving the dismissal notice is crucial. Anyone who misses this deadline loses their protection against dismissal. In complex cases like this, it is advisable to consult a specialist lawyer for employment law.

Dismissal for leaving church: How to defend yourself with an action for protection against dismissal

If you receive a dismissal because you left the church, you should act quickly. The action for protection against dismissal must be filed with the labor court within three weeks. Only then can you have the invalidity of the dismissal judicially determined. Within the proceedings, you can also claim compensation for the employer’s default in acceptance if the employer does not continue to employ you although the dismissal is invalid. Additionally, you may claim damages under the AGG if discrimination occurred. Learn more about continued employment after dismissal in our guide.

The prospects of success depend heavily on the individual case. Decisive is whether the employer also employs non-members in comparable positions and whether church membership is actually essential for the activity. A specialist lawyer can assess the chances and prepare the lawsuit strategically. If you shy away from the financial risk of litigation, litigation funding can help – for example from RechtStark, which covers the costs of the lawsuit and receives a share in case of success. This allows you to enforce your rights without taking a financial risk.

Why a specialist lawyer for employment law matters in the church context

Church employment relationships are legally complex. Besides the AGG, church basic orders and the church’s right of self-determination play a role. A specialist lawyer for employment law knows the current case law and can assess whether a dismissal for leaving church will hold up in court. They advise you on the prospects of success, prepare the lawsuit, and represent you before the labor court.

The costs of a labor court proceeding can be daunting, especially if you are without income after dismissal. Litigation funding like that from RechtStark can provide relief. RechtStark examines your prospects of success and, with a positive assessment, assumes the costs of the proceedings – you bear no financial risk. This lets you focus on what matters: enforcing your rights.

The BAG ruling of March 17, 2026 is an important step for the rights of church employees. It shows that church employers are not above the law either. A dismissal for leaving church is not automatically valid – and those who fight back have good chances of keeping their job or obtaining a severance payment. Do not let yourself be intimidated and seek professional support.

Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.

This article is general information and does not replace individual legal advice. RechtStark is a litigation funder, not a law firm; you are represented by an independent lawyer.