Severance Pay Blocking Period: Court Rules Against Employment Agency

Abfindung allein keine Sperrzeit: Gericht widerspricht der Arbeitsagentur

A high severance pay does not automatically trigger a severance pay blocking period for unemployment benefits. A recent court ruling clarifies: severance pay alone does not justify a blocking period – the employment agency may not refuse benefits across the board. In this article, you will learn why the authority nevertheless often imposes a blocking period, what the ruling means, and how you can successfully fight back.

Why the Employment Agency Often Imposes a Blocking Period After a High Severance Pay

The employment agency investigates many cases in which employees apply for unemployment benefits after a resignation or a termination agreement. Its suspicion: Anyone who receives severance pay may have brought about their unemployment themselves in order to cash in a financial settlement. The authority therefore frequently imposes a blocking period – a period during which the entitlement to unemployment benefits is suspended. As a rule, this blocking period lasts twelve weeks; afterwards, the benefit period can also be shortened.

Particularly in the case of high severance payments, the suspicion seems obvious that the employee agreed to the termination of the employment relationship in order to collect the severance. Yet this conclusion is often wrong. Many employees are made redundant for operational reasons and receive severance pay from a social plan or a court settlement. They did not cause the dismissal; they merely agreed to the termination to avoid a legal dispute. It is precisely such constellations that the court has now assessed: The payment of severance pay alone does not justify a blocking period.

Severance Pay Blocking Period: What the Court Ruling Means

The ruling strengthens the rights of employees whom the employment agency denies unemployment benefits simply because they received severance pay. The judges made clear that severance pay is compensation for the loss of a job – not a sign that the employee voluntarily caused their unemployment. The authority must instead examine the specific circumstances of the individual case: Who initiated the termination? Was there good cause for a resignation? Had a redundancy dismissal already been announced?

This means for employees: A high severance pay is no reason to forgo unemployment benefits. If the employment agency nevertheless imposes a blocking period, you can fight back. The ruling makes clear that the authority must not decide by rote but must assess each case individually. Anyone who receives severance pay after a redundancy dismissal has good chances of avoiding a blocking period – provided the termination originated with the employer or good cause existed.

When a Blocking Period Still Applies: Rules for Resignation and Termination Agreement

A blocking period is imposed when the employee terminates the employment relationship without good cause – i.e. by resigning or signing a termination agreement. Anyone who provokes a dismissal by the employer through their own conduct must also expect a blocking period. However, there are exceptions: If good cause exists, the blocking period does not apply. Good cause includes, for example, unreasonable working conditions, bullying, serious breaches of contract by the employer, or a health hazard.

If the employer has already announced a redundancy dismissal and the employee agrees to a termination agreement to pre-empt the dismissal, there are strong arguments that no blocking period will be imposed. The decisive factor is that the initiative to terminate comes from the employer. The severance pay plays no role in this – on the contrary: A high severance pay can be an indication that the employer had a strong interest in the termination, which argues against a severance pay blocking period.

Anyone facing a resignation or a termination agreement should therefore inform themselves early on about the consequences for unemployment benefits. A specialist lawyer for employment law can assess whether a blocking period threatens and how it can be avoided. The Employment Agency also offers advice – but its interest is not always on the employee’s side. Document all circumstances that prove the termination was not based on your free will – such as the announcement of the dismissal, the course of negotiations, or internal correspondence.

Severance Pay and Unemployment Benefits: Is Severance Pay Offset Against Unemployment Benefits?

Many employees fear that a high severance pay will reduce their unemployment benefits. In principle, however: Severance pay is not an income replacement benefit and is not offset against unemployment benefits. It counts as compensation for the loss of the job and not as income. This also applies to high severance payments from social plans or court settlements.

It only becomes problematic if the severance pay is declared as continued salary payment – but that is rare. As a rule, the severance pay remains outside the calculation of unemployment benefits. If the employment agency nevertheless makes an offset, you should take action against it. The amount of unemployment benefits is not reduced by the severance pay either – it generally amounts to 60 percent of the flat-rate net earnings (67 percent with a child).

For an overview of all aspects surrounding severance pay after dismissal, we recommend our guide page. There you will find information on the amount of severance pay, negotiation, and tax treatment. Anyone who wants to avoid concrete mistakes should also read our article on Severance Pay Under Pressure – there we show typical pitfalls in rapid severance offers.

Your Rights: Objection and Lawsuit Against the Blocking Period Notice

If the employment agency imposes a blocking period, you will receive a written notice. You can file an objection against this within one month of service. The objection should be substantiated – ideally with reference to the ruling that clarified that severance pay alone does not justify a blocking period. It is best to have a specialist lawyer for social law or employment law support you in this.

If the employment agency rejects the objection, you have the option of filing a lawsuit before the social court. The period for filing a lawsuit is generally one month after notification of the objection decision. Legal assistance is urgently recommended here as well. RechtStark as a litigation funder can cover the costs of such proceedings if the prospects of success are sufficient. If you are also considering an unfair dismissal claim, note the three-week deadline for the unfair dismissal claim – swift action is required here.

If you receive a blocking period after severance pay, you therefore have several options: You can file an objection, bring a lawsuit, and consult a lawyer in parallel. An interim injunction may also be considered if you are urgently dependent on unemployment benefits. Do not let yourself be intimidated – the ruling shows that the courts take the interests of employees seriously and do not accept a high severance pay as a pretext for a blocking period.

Conclusion: How to Protect Yourself When Receiving Severance Pay and Losing Your Job

The fear of a blocking period after severance pay is understandable, but not always justified. If you apply for unemployment benefits after a dismissal with severance pay, you can improve your chances by:

  • documenting the reasons for the termination of the employment relationship – especially in the case of resignation or termination agreement,
  • waiting for the employer’s dismissal where possible, instead of resigning yourself,
  • stating clearly in the application that you did not voluntarily bring about the termination,
  • obtaining expert advice before signing a termination agreement,
  • filing an objection promptly in the event of a blocking period notice and, if necessary, bringing a lawsuit.

A high severance pay alone does not trigger a severance pay blocking period – that is the clear message of the court ruling. You have the right to take action against unjustified blocking periods. Do not be discouraged and fight back if the employment agency refuses unemployment benefits. If you need financial support for a legal dispute, RechtStark will assess whether litigation funding is an option – so that your rights do not fail for lack of money.

Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.

This article is general information and does not replace individual legal advice. RechtStark is a litigation funder, not a law firm; you are represented by an independent lawyer.