Sick Pay After Termination: Claim Stands Even If Medical Certificate Is Questioned

Entgeltfortzahlung bei Krankheit: Auch bei Zweifeln an der AU-Bescheinigung möglich – entgeltfortzahlung-bei-krankheit

When employees fall ill after a termination, the question quickly arises whether they are entitled to sick pay after termination. A ruling by the Higher Labor Court of Bremen dated September 22, 2026 (Ref. 1 SLa 28/26) shows: Even if the employer questions the certificate of incapacity for work, the claim can remain valid. The court dismissed the employer’s appeal and confirmed the continued remuneration for the plaintiff employee.

The Case: Termination and Sick Note – What Was It About?

The plaintiff was employed as a management assistant at a company from October 8, 2024, to December 28, 2024. His monthly gross salary amounted to 2,650 euros for a 40-hour week. On December 13, 2024, a Friday, he received a probationary termination notice effective December 28, 2024, at around 12:00 p.m. He continued working until approximately 5:30 p.m. that same day and then returned the company key.

Three days later, on December 16, 2024, the plaintiff reported sick and notified the employer that he would be on sick leave until December 31, 2024. The submitted certificate of incapacity for work (AU) came from a doctor in Osterholz-Scharmbeck and listed the diagnoses F43.9 G and Z56 G. The employer, however, doubted the incapacity for work and cited circumstances intended to undermine the evidentiary value of the certificate.

The plaintiff sued for continued remuneration for the period of his illness. The Labor Court of Bremen-Bremerhaven ruled in his favor, and the Higher Labor Court upheld this decision on appeal.

When Is the Evidentiary Value of a Certificate of Incapacity for Work Undermined?

A certificate of incapacity for work is a key piece of evidence in labor law. It initially establishes that the employee is ill and unable to perform their work. However, the employer can undermine this evidentiary value by presenting specific circumstances that raise doubts about the incapacity for work. This may be the case, for example, if the employee falls ill immediately after the termination, makes contradictory statements, or is seen at a private celebration while certified sick.

Important: A mere suspicion on the employer’s part is not sufficient. They must assert facts that give rise to serious doubts. Only once the evidentiary value is undermined must the employee prove the incapacity for work themselves — for instance, by having the treating physician testify as a witness.

Sick Pay After Termination: The LAG Bremen Decision

In the present case, the employer had attempted to undermine the evidentiary value of the certificate. The Higher Labor Court decided, however, that the plaintiff was entitled to sick pay after termination despite these doubts. The court assessed the overall circumstances and concluded that the incapacity for work actually existed. The employer’s appeal was dismissed, and leave to appeal to the Federal Labor Court was not granted.

This decision shows: Not every sick note following a termination is automatically „feigned.“ Courts examine each case carefully. If the employee can credibly demonstrate that they were genuinely ill, they are entitled to continued remuneration during illness.

What Does This Mean for Employees in Practice?

For employees who fall ill after a termination, this decision is good news. They need not fear that their claim to continued remuneration during illness will fail solely because of the temporal proximity to the termination. The prerequisite is that they properly notify the employer of their illness and submit a valid certificate of incapacity for work.

At the same time, employees should be aware that the employer may indeed question the certificate. In such a case, it is important to be able to prove the incapacity for work if necessary. This can be done by naming the treating physician as a witness or submitting further medical records. Anyone who is uncertain should consult an independent specialist lawyer for labor law in good time.

Typical Constellations: Termination Followed by Sick Notification

Employers often suspect that employees „call in sick“ after a termination to buy time or negotiate a severance package. Yet the law protects employees who are genuinely ill. Psychological stress caused by the termination can also constitute incapacity for work, giving rise to a claim for continued remuneration during illness. In the specific case, the certificate listed diagnosis F43.9 (reaction to severe stress) and Z56 (problems related to employment and unemployment) — recognized medical diagnoses.

Employees should, however, be aware that a sick note is only effective if they are actually unfit for work. A feigned illness can not only jeopardize the claim to continued remuneration but also lead to summary dismissal. In case of doubt, it is better to communicate honestly with the employer.

How You Should Act If the Employer Questions the Certificate

If the employer questions the certificate of incapacity for work, you should not panic. First, refer to the certificate in writing and ask the employer to specify their doubts. Often, clear communication alone can clear up misunderstandings.

If the employer maintains their doubts, you should secure evidence of your incapacity for work. This includes the certificate itself, but also a medical certificate detailing the course of the illness. You can also offer to release the treating physician from their duty of confidentiality so they can testify as a witness. It is important to observe all deadlines — for instance, the deadline for filing an action against unfair dismissal if you wish to challenge the termination.

Enforcing Your Rights: Independent Advice and Litigation Funding

If your employer refuses continued remuneration, you should actively enforce your rights. An action against unfair dismissal can also be worthwhile if the termination itself is valid — for example, to negotiate a severance package. In any case, consultation with an independent specialist lawyer for labor law is advisable. They can assess the prospects of success of your claim and represent you in court.

If you cannot afford the costs of court proceedings yourself, there is the option of litigation funding. A litigation funder like RechtStark examines your case and, if appropriate, assumes the costs — in the event of success you receive a portion of the amount awarded, and in the event of failure you remain exempt from costs. This enables employees with low incomes to enforce their rights as well.

For further information on the topic of illness after termination, we also recommend our article on waiting period termination and your rights, which highlights similar pitfalls.

The ruling of the LAG Bremen is an important signal: Employees need not fear that a sick note after a termination is automatically considered feigned. If the incapacity for work actually exists, they are entitled to sick pay after termination. Seek legal advice if in doubt and do not hesitate to enforce your rights in court.

Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.

This article is general information and does not replace individual legal advice. RechtStark is a litigation funder, not a law firm; you are represented by an independent lawyer.