bEM Protocol Dismissal: Why Forgery Claims Don’t Save Employers

A bEM protocol dismissal can decide between winning and losing — yet whoever forges it risks a great deal. The Higher Labor Court of Rhineland-Palatinate (LAG Rheinland-Pfalz) declared the extraordinary, alternatively ordinary dismissal of a store manager invalid in its judgment of July 29, 2026 (Ref. 6 SLa 262/25). The employer had accused the 51-year-old of forging a protocol of the operational reintegration management (bEM). The employer’s appeal was dismissed, and leave to appeal to the Federal Labor Court was not granted.
What Is Operational Reintegration Management (bEM)?
Operational reintegration management, abbreviated bEM, is a legally anchored procedure regulated in Section 167(2) of the German Social Code Book IX (SGB IX). It applies when an employee has been continuously or repeatedly unable to work due to illness for more than six weeks within twelve months. The employer is then obliged to offer a meeting to clarify, together with the affected person, how health impairments can be overcome and the job preserved. That sounds bureaucratic, but it has a serious background: many dismissals later fail because a bEM was not properly offered or documented.
The bEM protocol records who attended the meeting, what topics were discussed, and what measures were agreed. It is not a public document but is subject to confidentiality. This is precisely where the problem in the case began: the employer accused the store manager of forging such a protocol — and based an extraordinary dismissal on that allegation.
The idea behind bEM is that many dismissals due to illness would be avoidable if employer and employee discussed solutions early on. Typical measures include adjusted working hours, a different workplace, or technical aids. bEM is therefore not a mere formal exercise; at best it can save the job. At the same time, it is an area where employers make mistakes — for instance by offering bEM only after the dismissal has already been pronounced, or by documenting the meeting without the affected person’s participation.
The Case: Store Manager Dismissed Extraordinarily After Forgery Allegation
The plaintiff had been employed as a store manager at a building materials trading company that also operates a DIY store since May 1, 2019. He last earned 6,000 euros gross per month plus a performance bonus, is married, and father of three children, one of them a minor. By letter dated February 28, 2025, the employer pronounced the extraordinary dismissal, alternatively the ordinary dismissal. The allegation: the store manager had forged a bEM protocol.
The employment relationship was based on a written employment contract of March 25, 2019, and a supplementary agreement of June 5, 2023. The employer permanently employs more than ten employees; no works council had been elected. These details are relevant because they determine the applicability of the Protection Against Dismissal Act (Kündigungsschutzgesetz).
The plaintiff defended himself with an unfair dismissal claim, filed with the Mainz Labor Court on March 2, 2025. He objected both to the lack of grounds for dismissal and to non-compliance with the two-week deadline under Section 626(2) of the German Civil Code (BGB). The labor court ruled in his favor. The employer appealed — without success. The Higher Labor Court of Rhineland-Palatinate confirmed the decision and also dismissed the employer’s counterclaim for damages.
Remarkable is the scope of the dispute: the plaintiff extended his claim during the proceedings to include requests for a qualified employment reference, vacation compensation of 1,384.60 euros gross, and a performance bonus for 2024 of 12,500 euros. The employer, in turn, counterclaimed for the return of 2,516.39 euros. Such ancillary claims are typical in dismissal protection proceedings — they show that it is rarely only about the dismissal itself.
Why the Dismissal Was Invalid: The LAG’s Legal Assessment
Extraordinary dismissals are the most severe intervention in an employment relationship. They require that the employer cannot reasonably be expected to continue the employment relationship until the end of the notice period (Section 626(1) BGB). The employer bears the full burden of pleading and proof. The grounds for dismissal must be pleaded so concretely that the court can review them. Generalized allegations are not sufficient.
Added to this is the two-week deadline under Section 626(2) BGB: the dismissal must be pronounced within two weeks of becoming aware of the relevant facts. Anyone who hesitates too long loses the right to extraordinary dismissal — even if the allegation were true in substance. The plaintiff had raised exactly these points — and the court followed his assessment. This shows: anyone pronouncing an extraordinary dismissal must not only have a serious allegation but also observe the deadlines and pleading obligations. The alternatively pronounced ordinary dismissal also did not withstand scrutiny.
For employees, this is an important signal: an allegation alone does not make a dismissal valid. Anyone receiving a dismissal should not give up prematurely but have it examined whether the employer has actually fulfilled its burden of proof. This applies especially when the allegation rests on documents that the employer cannot conclusively produce.
bEM Protocol Dismissal: What Role Does It Play in Dismissal Protection?
In practice, the bEM protocol is often a double-edged sword. On the one hand, it can help the employee because it proves that the employer fulfilled its duty of care. On the other hand, it can become a bone of contention if the employer claims the document was manipulated. Anyone confronted with a bEM protocol dismissal should therefore have the document examined carefully — ideally by a specialist employment lawyer.
A proper bEM protocol should contain the date, participants, topics discussed, and agreed measures. If these details are missing or the document deviates from one’s own recollection, the affected person should note this in writing without delay. It is important that the protocol is not created unilaterally by the employer. In practice, it is advisable to take one’s own notes and obtain a copy of the protocol.
The decision of the Higher Labor Court of Rhineland-Palatinate shows that courts examine forgery allegations closely. Anyone raising such an allegation must be able to substantiate it. Mere suspicion is not enough for an extraordinary dismissal. This applies all the more when the employment relationship has remained unchallenged for years.
Anyone who feels the employer is using bEM not as support but as a means of pressure should also seek legal advice. A breach of the duty of care can also have consequences — more on this in our article on severance pay for breach of duty of care.
What the Judgment Means for Employees: Recommendations for Action
The judgment strengthens the position of employees confronted with an extraordinary dismissal. It shows that courts set high standards for the employer’s pleading. Anyone affected should observe the following points:
- Observe deadlines: The unfair dismissal claim must be filed with the labor court within three weeks of receipt of the dismissal. This applies even if the dismissal appears obviously invalid. An overview of the procedure is provided on our unfair dismissal claim page.
- Secure documents: Keep all documents — employment contract, dismissal letter, bEM protocols, emails, and notes. They can be decisive later.
- Take allegations seriously, but do not panic: An allegation such as alleged forgery is serious. But the burden of proof lies with the employer. Do not let yourself be pressured into premature statements.
- Seek legal advice: A specialist employment lawyer examines whether the dismissal is valid and what chances a lawsuit has. If you shy away from the cost risk, a litigation funder like RechtStark can examine the financing of the proceedings — but the decision on the legal strategy is always made by the lawyer.
A bEM protocol dismissal is not automatically a death sentence — what matters is how the employer handles it. Anyone unjustly accused should defend themselves actively. Anyone who receives a dismissal and later wants to negotiate a severance package should also know the legal framework. A settlement is often the pragmatic route — but only if negotiated on a solid basis. Anyone who gives in too early may forfeit claims. Also read our article unfair dismissal won — and dismissed again? — it shows how important a clean handling of one’s own pleading is.
Conclusion: Employees Have Rights Even in the Face of Serious Allegations
The decision of the Higher Labor Court of Rhineland-Palatinate is a good example that even serious allegations such as the alleged forgery of a bEM protocol do not automatically mean the employer wins. Courts examine closely whether the dismissal is based on sustainable facts and whether all deadlines were observed. Anyone who wants to fight a dismissal should act quickly, secure evidence, and obtain legal assistance. The costs of an unfair dismissal claim may seem daunting at first — but whoever wins often secures not only the job but also the basis for a proper severance package. An overview of the most important questions about severance pay can be found on our severance pay after dismissal page.
Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.


