Changing Works Agreement: Berlin Labor Court Ruling on Unionhilfswerk Case

Changing works agreement is only possible with the works council. The Berlin Labor Court has now clarified in a case involving the Unionhilfswerk that the employer cannot simply act unilaterally. The case shows how important works agreements are as protection for employees – and what limits are set for the employer.
What is a works agreement and why is it important?
A works agreement is a written agreement between the employer and the works council. It regulates certain working conditions, such as remuneration, working hours, vacation principles, or the use of company facilities. Works agreements have direct and binding effect: they apply directly to all employees in the establishment, regardless of whether they are works council members or not.
For employees, works agreements are an important protective instrument. They create binding rules that the employer cannot change unilaterally. Without the works council’s consent, a works agreement remains in force until it is properly terminated or replaced by a new agreement. This gives employees planning security and prevents the employer from unilaterally worsening working conditions.
The Unionhilfswerk case: what was it about?
At the Unionhilfswerk, a social welfare organization in Berlin, there is a works agreement on remuneration. The employer wanted to adjust this agreement and, among other things, introduce a new remuneration group „H Kita“. The works council, however, refused to participate in negotiations. It argued that the works council was not responsible for changing the works agreement as a whole – instead, it advocated for concluding a collective bargaining agreement on pay.
In response, the Unionhilfswerk attempted to remove the works council chairwoman and her deputy from office via interim injunction. The employer accused them of falsely reporting the outcome of legal advice to the workforce, thereby grossly violating their duty of trusting cooperation. Additionally, the company applied for the establishment of a conciliation board to enforce the planned changing works agreement.
The Berlin Labor Court dismissed both applications. The judges saw neither a sufficient basis for the provisional removal of the works council members nor a special urgency. And the conciliation board was not appointed either, because the works agreement remains unchanged and a conciliation board is not competent in this case.
Changing works agreement: why the unchanged agreement blocks changes
The central point in this case is the continuing validity of an unchanged works agreement. As long as a works agreement has not been terminated, it continues to apply without restriction. The employer cannot change it unilaterally or set it aside. The employer depends on the cooperation of the works council. If the works council withholds its consent, the old regulation remains in place.
The Berlin Labor Court clarified that a comprehensively regulating works agreement blocks the competence of a conciliation board on the same subject during its term. This means: as long as the agreement applies, the employer cannot simply call a conciliation board to enforce a change. The conciliation board would be obviously incompetent. This decision strengthens the position of the works council and thus also that of employees.
For employers, this means: anyone who wants to change a works agreement must convince the works council. If that fails, the status quo remains. Unilateral measures or attempts to sideline the works council are futile – at least as long as the agreement has not been terminated.
Conciliation board: when can it be appointed and when not?
The conciliation board is a mediation body that can make a binding decision in disputes between employer and works council. It is typically appointed when the parties cannot reach agreement on a matter subject to co-determination. The law provides that the employer or the works council can call the conciliation board when an agreement fails.
However, the conciliation board is only competent when it concerns a regulation subject to the works council’s co-determination and for which no final regulation yet exists. If a works agreement on the subject already exists, the conciliation board is blocked. It cannot simply replace or amend an existing agreement. The Berlin Labor Court has now expressly confirmed this.
In practice, this means: as long as the „Remuneration“ works agreement remains unchanged, changing works agreement via a conciliation board is impossible. The employer would first have to terminate the works agreement to clear the way for negotiations. Termination, however, is only possible under certain conditions and does not automatically lead to a new agreement.
What does this mean for employees? Your rights when pay changes
For employees, this decision is an important signal. It shows that works agreements cannot simply be changed to the detriment of the workforce. If the employer wants to change the works agreement, he must involve the works council. And if the works council does not consent, the previous regulation remains in force – at least until the agreement is terminated.
This protects employees from unilateral pay changes or other deteriorations in their working conditions. Especially in times of economic uncertainty, employers often try to cut costs by weakening existing agreements. But without the works council’s consent, that is legally impossible. Employees can therefore rely on their contractually agreed or works-agreement-based conditions remaining valid.
However, this does not mean that pay changes are never possible. If the works council consents, a new agreement can be concluded. Termination of the works agreement by the employer can also open the way for new negotiations. In practice, the attempt to change a works agreement often fails due to the lack of works council consent – and that is precisely the protective mechanism the law provides.
Employees are protected because changing works agreement requires works council consent. If you yourself are affected by a change to a works agreement, you should monitor developments closely. Should your employer attempt to change existing rules to your disadvantage, it may be wise to seek legal advice. A specialist lawyer for employment law can examine whether the measures are lawful and what options you have. A protection against dismissal action may also be relevant in certain situations, for example if a dismissal is connected to the dispute over the works agreement.
What to do if the employer wants to adjust the works agreement?
If you hear that your employer wants to change a works agreement, you should first stay calm. The employer cannot enforce this unilaterally. What matters is informing and supporting the works council. The works council is your contact for all co-determination matters. It will represent the workforce’s interests and negotiate.
If the works council does not act or refuses to negotiate with the employer, there may be various reasons. In some cases, the refusal is strategic, to force concessions from the employer. In others, the works council may be overwhelmed. As an employee, you can seek dialogue with the works council and make your expectations clear.
If the employer tries to bypass the works council or even remove works council members, as in the Unionhilfswerk case, it shows how far some employers will go. But the courts have set clear limits. Provisional removal of works council members is only possible in extreme cases of gross breach of duty – and even then only if special urgency exists. Mere refusal to negotiate over a works agreement is not sufficient.
If you yourself are threatened with dismissal because you advocate for the workforce’s rights, you should seek legal advice immediately. Dismissal received – what now? shows you the first steps. The costs of a protection against dismissal action can also be covered if you use a litigation funder like RechtStark. RechtStark examines whether it will finance the proceedings, so you bear no financial risk.
Conclusion: works agreements as a protective shield for employees
The Unionhilfswerk case makes clear how important works agreements are for protecting employees. They are binding rules that cannot be changed unilaterally. The Berlin Labor Court has confirmed that an unchanged works agreement blocks changes – both unilateral employer measures and the appointment of a conciliation board.
For employees, this means: you can rely on existing agreements. If your employer tries to change them, you and your works council have strong legal instruments. Should you nevertheless end up in a dispute, do not hesitate to consult a specialist lawyer for employment law. And when it comes to financing a possible proceeding, RechtStark can help as a litigation funder.
Works agreements are not a rigid corset, but a flexible instrument that serves both sides – as long as it is applied fairly. The Berlin Labor Court’s decision is an important building block for protecting employee rights in Germany.
Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.


