Bonus after resignation: What the Cologne Labor Court decided

Bonus nach Eigenkündigung: Was das Arbeitsgericht Köln entschieden hat – bonus-nach-eigenkuendigung

Many employees wonder whether they are entitled to a bonus after resignation when they terminate the employment relationship themselves. A ruling by the Cologne Labor Court dated October 1, 2026 (Ref. 4 Ca 5005/26) shows: It depends entirely on what has been agreed contractually – and with whom. An HR Business Partner sued for bonus payments for two years after his own resignation and lost. The case holds important lessons for anyone who relies on variable compensation.

The ruling in the HR Business Partner case: Claim dismissed

The plaintiff had been employed as an HR Business Partner since April 1, 2022, most recently at an annual base salary of €88,833.00 gross. The employment relationship ended through the plaintiff’s own resignation effective July 31, 2026. In his lawsuit, he demanded from his employer a bonus for 2025 in the amount of €10,214.63 gross plus a pro-rata bonus for 2026 in the amount of €6,140.70 gross – each plus interest at five percentage points above the base rate.

The labor court dismissed the claim. The plaintiff bears the costs of the proceedings; leave to appeal was not granted separately. The court set the value in dispute at €16,355.33 – exactly the sum of the two amounts claimed.

Why the bonus claim failed: No contractual basis in the employment contract

The central point of the case: The employment contract between the plaintiff and his employer contained no legal basis for a bonus payment. This is explicitly stated in the facts of the judgment. The bonus agreement on which the plaintiff relied had not been concluded with his employer, but with the parent company Dy Holdings Pte. Ltd – and only on April 10, 2025, after more than three years of employment.

For employees, this means: A bonus entitlement does not arise merely because a group offers a bonus program or the name appears in the HR system. What matters is who is contractually obligated to pay. If there is no valid agreement with the employer, there is usually no enforceable claim against them either.

The plaintiff had argued that the defendant had listed him in its compensation and HR system with a concrete bonus opportunity. A Workday extract also showed a planned assignment „Bonus – Dy Bonus“ valid from July 1, 2023. That alone was not sufficient to establish a payment claim against the employer.

Bonus agreement with the parent company: Who is the correct contractual partner?

The case illustrates a typical group structure problem: Agreements are not always concluded with the company that signed the employment contract. The plaintiff concluded the „Dy Discretionary Bonus“ agreement with Dy Holdings Pte. Ltd, i.e., the parent company. His lawsuit, however, was directed against the defendant employer, which belongs to the Dy Group.

This constellation frequently leads to problems. A contract fundamentally binds only the parties who concluded it. Anyone who agrees a bonus with the parent company must assert claims primarily against the parent company – not against their own employer. This applies at least where neither the employment contract nor the bonus agreement contains an express provision on who is obligated to pay.

The plaintiff had argued that the division of roles between Dy GmbH, Dy Holdings Pte. Ltd and the Remuneration Committee („RemCo“) should be examined, from which payment or damages consequences against the defendant might follow. The claim was dismissed – these arguments did not succeed. For employees, this is an important lesson: Group structures are no substitute for a legal basis. Anyone who does not know exactly who their contractual partner is should have the contractual relationships reviewed before filing a lawsuit.

Discretionary bonus: What does „voluntary“ payment mean legally?

The name „Dy Discretionary Bonus“ already reveals much about the legal classification. „Discretionary“ means, translated, „at the discretion of.“ With a discretionary bonus, the employer – or the competent body – decides at its own discretion whether and in what amount a bonus is paid.

This has consequences: Even if personal targets were met, this does not automatically entail a claim to a specific sum. The employer may reduce the bonus to zero within the scope of its discretion, provided the bonus conditions so provide. Judicial review is then only possible to a limited extent. The plaintiff had claimed that the reduction to zero was not free from discretionary error and did not comply with the rules of the Dy Discretionary Bonus. Yet the lack of a contractual basis against the defendant employer alone caused the claim to fail.

For employees, this means: A discretionary bonus is not a guaranteed additional compensation. Anyone who relies on a reliable payment should ensure that the bonus is clearly regulated contractually – ideally with concrete targets, a calculation formula, and a fixed payout rule.

Bonus after resignation: Key points to check beforehand

Anyone planning their own resignation should not rely solely on verbal assurances or entries in the HR system. The Cologne Labor Court case shows: The bonus after resignation depends crucially on what the contract states.

Before resigning, you should therefore clarify the following questions:

  • Does my employment contract contain a bonus provision? If so: What exactly has been agreed?
  • With whom did I conclude the bonus agreement – with my employer or with another group company?
  • Is there a written target agreement for the current year?
  • What happens to the bonus if I resign myself? Is there a provision for pro-rata payment?
  • Is it a discretionary bonus with a voluntariness reservation or a contractually guaranteed bonus?
  • What deadlines and conditions apply to the payout?

Anyone considering their own resignation should also know: An action for protection against dismissal is generally no longer an option, because the employee terminated the employment relationship themselves. An overview of deadlines and procedure is provided in a guide to action for protection against dismissal.

Anyone wishing to defend against an employer’s termination should also know the risks. Why an action for protection against dismissal can fail is shown in the article Why an action for protection against dismissal can fail.

The question of whether a bonus after resignation is paid is often a matter of contract design. Anyone unsure before a resignation should have the bonus agreement reviewed carefully – ideally by a specialist lawyer for employment law.

How to secure bonus claims contractually – Tips for the employment contract

The best protection is a clear contractual provision. Anyone who does not want to leave bonus entitlements to chance should pay attention to the following points during contract negotiations:

  • Include the bonus agreement in the employment contract or expressly refer to a bonus plan.
  • Clearly name the contractual partner: Who owes the bonus – the employer or a group company?
  • Formulate targets in writing and unambiguously, preferably with measurable criteria.
  • Fix a calculation formula or at least a range for the bonus amount.
  • Provision for the event of own resignation: Is the bonus paid pro-rata or does it lapse?
  • Examine voluntariness reservations carefully. A blanket reservation can nullify the claim.

Anyone who has already signed a bonus agreement should have it reviewed regularly. Especially in the event of group changes, restructurings, or new target agreements, the legal situation can change. A specialist lawyer for employment law can assess whether a clause is valid and what claims can be derived from it.

Conclusion: What you can take from the ruling for your next bonus

The Cologne Labor Court ruling is a clear reminder that bonus entitlements are not a matter of course. Anyone who wants to enforce bonus payments after their own resignation must know who their contractual partner is and which provisions actually apply. Entries in the HR system, verbal assurances, or group affiliations are no substitute for a contractual legal basis.

Review your bonus agreement before any resignation – and do so in writing. In case of doubt, consult a specialist lawyer for employment law before hoping for a payment that is not legally secured. Anyone uncertain whether judicial enforcement is worthwhile can also have it assessed whether a litigation funder would assume the cost risk of a lawsuit. This avoids losing not only the bonus but also the court costs in the end.

Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.

This article is general information and does not replace individual legal advice. RechtStark is a litigation funder, not a law firm; you are represented by an independent lawyer.