Vacation Pay Side Job: What the Thuringia Labor Court Decided

Urlaubsabgeltung und Nebentätigkeit: Was das Thüringer LAG entschieden hat – urlaubsabgeltung-und-nebentaetigkeit

A vacation pay side job dispute took center stage in a recent ruling by the Thuringia Higher Labor Court. The court had to decide a case in which an employee claimed both vacation pay for unused vacation days from 2013 and outstanding salary claims – while the employer offset a claim arising from a criminally relevant side job.

Vacation Pay Side Job: Case Overview

The plaintiff worked for a statutory accident insurance association, a public-law corporation that organizes rehabilitation after workplace accidents, among other tasks. Besides his main job, he performed a side job for another accident insurance institution. This side activity was later classified as acceptance of benefits. A regional court convicted the plaintiff accordingly and confiscated the remuneration received from the side job.

The employer then demanded that the plaintiff hand over the side job remuneration. It offset this against the plaintiff’s salary claims for August 2017 through January 2019 – up to the exempt amount. The plaintiff, in turn, claimed the remaining salary for that period. Additionally, the parties disputed vacation pay for 19 vacation days from 2013. The Erfurt Labor Court largely ruled in the plaintiff’s favor. The employer appealed.

The Thuringia Higher Labor Court dismissed the appeal with one modification: interest on part of the awarded amount (2,813.48 euros gross) is only due from March 3, 2022. Otherwise, the conviction stood. However, the court allowed an appeal on points of law regarding the remaining salary and the employer’s counterclaim. The vacation pay for ten vacation days from 2013, by contrast, is final and binding.

Vacation Pay: What Claims Do Employees Have After Employment Ends?

Vacation pay is a statutory claim governed by the Federal Vacation Act. The principle: if vacation can no longer be granted because the employment relationship has ended, it must be compensated. This means the employer must pay out the unused vacation days in cash. The amount is based on the average earnings during the last 13 weeks before termination.

Important to know: the claim for vacation pay does not automatically expire with the end of employment. However, collective bargaining or contractual exclusion periods can cause the claim to lapse much faster. Many employment contracts contain such periods, often only three months. Anyone who does not assert their claims in writing in time risks losing them. Read more in our article on exclusion periods in employment contracts.

In this case, the dispute concerned vacation from 2013. The fact that the court still ruled on the compensation years later shows: such claims can remain enforceable long after they arise if no valid exclusion period applies. Employees should nevertheless not wait too long, but assert their claims promptly and with proof.

Side Jobs and Acceptance of Benefits: When Must Remuneration Be Turned Over to the Employer?

In principle, employees in Germany may take on a side job. However, there are limits: the side job must not impair the work obligation and must not violate statutory or contractual prohibitions. It becomes particularly tricky when the side job is connected to the main employment and could harm the employer. In such cases, the employer may be entitled to demand that the side job remuneration be turned over.

In the Thuringia Higher Labor Court case, the side job was even criminally relevant: it was classified as acceptance of benefits. The employee had received money from a third party which, in the view of the criminal courts, he was not allowed to accept. The remuneration was confiscated by the criminal judgment. The employer argued that the plaintiff had to pay this remuneration to her in addition. The Higher Labor Court did not decide this question conclusively but allowed the appeal on points of law. The Federal Labor Court will therefore have to address it.

For employees, this means: a side job can have not only employment-law but also criminal-law consequences. Anyone unsure whether a side job is permitted should clarify beforehand whether the employer’s consent is required or whether conflicts of interest exist. In case of doubt, legal advice helps.

Offsetting Against Salary Claims: What the Court Says About the Limits

Employers can offset their own claims against an employee’s salary claims. However, there is an important limit: the exempt amount of the work income must not be undercut. This amount protects the employee’s subsistence minimum. Offsetting is therefore only possible to the extent that the salary exceeds the exempt amount.

In this case, the employer offset exactly up to the exempt amount. The plaintiff claimed the remaining salary for August 2017 through January 2019. Both the Labor Court and the Higher Labor Court awarded him this remaining salary. However, the Higher Labor Court allowed the appeal on points of law because the question of whether the employer can demand the side job remuneration has fundamental significance. Until the Federal Labor Court decides, this part of the judgment is not final and binding.

For employees, it is important to know: offsetting is not unlimited. If the employer offsets with counterclaims, it should be checked whether the claim actually exists and whether the statutory limits are observed. Here, too: assert claims in writing and observe deadlines.

The Higher Labor Court’s Decision: What Was Awarded and What Was Not

The Thuringia Higher Labor Court dismissed the employer’s appeal. Thus, the conviction to pay vacation pay for ten vacation days from 2013 stands. This decision is final and binding because the court did not allow an appeal on points of law on this point. Originally, vacation pay for 19 vacation days was in dispute; the Higher Labor Court confirmed the claim for ten days.

Additionally, the court confirmed the payment of 10,101.98 euros as remaining salary for the period August 2017 to January 2019. However, it allowed the appeal on points of law insofar as the employer contests this conviction and counterclaims payment of a further 23,918.02 euros. This means: the Federal Labor Court will likely decide on this part. The interest ruling was amended so that interest on the amount of 2,813.48 euros gross is only due from March 3, 2022.

The case shows how vacation pay and side jobs can converge in a single proceeding. For the plaintiff, it is a partial success: the vacation pay is secured, and the remaining salary was initially awarded. Whether the employer succeeds with its counterclaim remains to be seen.

Practical Tips for Employees: How to Secure Your Vacation and Salary Claims

Concrete recommendations can be derived from this judgment. Anyone faced with multiple outstanding claims from the employment relationship should examine their claims carefully and act in good time. Here are the most important tips:

  • Check your employment contract for exclusion periods. These periods can cause claims such as vacation pay or salary to lapse quickly. Assert your claims in writing and within the deadline against the employer.
  • Document your vacation days. Record how many vacation days you took in which year and how many are still open. This allows you to prove in a dispute that you are still entitled to vacation.
  • Be cautious with side jobs. Clarify beforehand whether your employer must consent and whether the activity conflicts with your main employment. In case of uncertainty, legal advice helps.
  • Do not let yourself be pressured by offsetting. The exempt amount protects your income. Check whether the employer’s claim actually exists.
  • Obtain legal support in good time. A specialist lawyer for employment law can assess your chances and initiate the right steps. If you cannot afford the costs yourself, a litigation funder like RechtStark will check whether it can finance the proceedings. Read about your options when funds are lacking in our article on legal costs in case of dismissal.

If you want to enforce multiple claims after a dismissal, you should also consider an unfair dismissal lawsuit. In these proceedings, vacation pay and salary claims can often be negotiated together.

Conclusion: What You Can Learn from This Judgment for Your Own Case

The combination of vacation pay and side job makes clear that employees should not give up their claims, even if the employer argues with counterclaims. The vacation pay for ten vacation days from 2013 is final and binding – a strong signal that even older claims can be enforceable.

At the same time, the case warns of the risks of side jobs that can border on acceptance of benefits. Anyone unsure should seek legal advice beforehand. And anyone who must defend against offsetting or salary reduction should know the statutory limits and not hesitate to enforce their rights.

Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.

This article is general information and does not replace individual legal advice. RechtStark is a litigation funder, not a law firm; you are represented by an independent lawyer.