Equal Treatment Clause Collective Agreement: What the LAG Ruling Means for Employees

Gleichstellungsabrede im Arbeitsvertrag: Was das LAG-Urteil für Arbeitnehmer bedeutet

The equal treatment clause collective agreement is a provision in an employment contract designed to ensure that non-unionized employees are treated the same as those covered by collective agreements. The Regional Labor Court (LAG) Schleswig-Holstein has now ruled that such a clause can also incorporate individual invalid collective agreement provisions. For employees hoping for collectively agreed wages or seeking back pay, this has far-reaching consequences.

What Is an Equal Treatment Clause Collective Agreement?

An equal treatment clause is a provision in an employment contract under which the employer and employee agree that the applicable collective agreements will apply to the employment relationship. The special feature: the clause is often „dynamic,“ meaning it refers not only to the collective agreement in its current version but also to all future amendments and new collective agreements. The aim is to equalize non-unionized employees with unionized ones, thereby achieving equal treatment.

Such clauses are frequently found in employment contracts, particularly in industries with strong unions and employer associations. They may refer to industry-wide collective agreements, company-level collective agreements, or only specific parts thereof. What matters is what was specifically agreed in the employment contract.

The Case: Team Leader Sues for Pay Difference

In the case decided by the LAG Schleswig-Holstein (Ref. 1 Sa 42/26), a team leader demanded further remuneration from her employer for the months of November 2024 through April 2025. She was a member of the Service Employees Union (GdS) and had been employed by the defendant since 2015. The equal treatment clause in her employment contract referred to the collective agreements applicable in the establishment.

The plaintiff had been classified in pay group 10, level 2 of the company remuneration collective agreement concluded between the defendant and the GdS until July 31, 2023, receiving a monthly salary of €3,979.00. Following a reorganization, hierarchy levels were merged and group leadership positions introduced. The plaintiff believed she was entitled to higher pay and sued for the difference.

The Labor Court Kiel initially upheld the claim. On the defendant’s appeal, however, the LAG Schleswig-Holstein amended the judgment and dismissed the claim. Leave to appeal was granted.

Why the LAG Dismissed the Claim

The LAG based its decision on the finding that the equal treatment clause in the plaintiff’s employment contract also incorporates collective agreement provisions that may be invalid. In the court’s view, the parties to an employment contract can use such a clause to individually agree on even individual invalid collective agreement provisions, making them binding under contract law. This means: even if a collective agreement or an individual collective agreement provision is invalid for formal reasons, it can become a contractual agreement through the reference in the employment contract.

In the specific case, the equal treatment clause meant that the higher remuneration claimed by the plaintiff was not due. The reference to the collective agreement was effective, and the previous contractual arrangements were superseded by the later equal treatment clause. Under the so-called temporal conflict rule, the later agreed provision applies unless contractual interpretation yields a different result.

Invalid Collective Agreement Provisions: How Do They Take Effect Individually?

A collective agreement is invalid if, for example, it was not properly concluded, violates higher-ranking law, or was concluded by an unauthorized body. In such cases, the collective agreement normally has no direct and mandatory effect on employment relationships. The LAG Schleswig-Holstein has now clarified: if the parties to an employment contract have agreed on an equal treatment clause, it can also refer to invalid collective agreement provisions. The collective agreement provision then applies not as collective agreement law but as an individual contractual agreement — as if the parties had agreed on it directly in the employment contract.

This has significant consequences. On the one hand, employees can benefit from collective agreement provisions that would have no validity without the reference. On the other hand, provisions disadvantageous to the employee can also become individually binding. What matters is always what the parties intended when concluding the contract and how the clause is to be interpreted.

The temporal conflict rule provides that where there are successive agreements, the later provision supersedes the earlier one unless contractual interpretation dictates otherwise. In the plaintiff’s case, this meant: the equal treatment clause from 2015 superseded earlier, potentially more favorable arrangements. The LAG thus clarified that employees do not automatically benefit from earlier higher pay if such a clause was agreed later.

What the Ruling Means for Employees with Reference Clauses

For employees who have an equal treatment clause in their employment contract, this ruling is highly significant. It shows that such clauses can have far-reaching effects — even when the referenced collective agreements or individual collective agreement provisions are legally contestable. Anyone hoping for higher pay because the collective agreement might be invalid could be mistaken: through the reference, the provision becomes part of the contract anyway.

At the same time, the ruling also creates opportunities. If a collective agreement or a collective agreement provision is favorable to the employee, they can rely on it even if the collective agreement did not come into force validly. The equal treatment clause turns the collective agreement provision into an individual contractual agreement that the employer must honor.

Employees with a dynamic equal treatment clause should be aware that invalid collective agreement norms can also apply. If you are demanding back pay or want to defend against a deterioration of your working conditions, you should have your reference clause reviewed carefully. An experienced specialist lawyer for employment law can assess whether the clause is dynamic or static, which collective agreements it refers to, and what the implications are in your specific case. The question of whether earlier, more favorable arrangements were superseded by the clause is often decisive. In this context, a look at the Cologne ruling on back pay after termination may also be helpful, which addresses similar questions (Salary Reimbursement After Termination: What the Cologne Ruling Means for Employees).

Tips: How to Check Your Own Reference Clause

If you want to know whether your reference clause protects or disadvantages you, you can check a few points yourself:

  • Wording: Does it expressly state „in the respectively applicable version“ or „respectively applicable collective agreements“? Then the clause is dynamic. If this addition is missing, it is often a static clause covering only the collective agreement in the version at the time of contract conclusion.
  • Reference to collective agreements: Which collective agreements are specifically named? Industry-wide collective agreement, company-level collective agreement, or only certain parts? The more precise the clause, the clearer the legal situation.
  • Equal treatment clause: Is the goal of equal treatment with collectively covered employees mentioned? Then it is an equal treatment clause that can also make invalid collective agreement norms individually binding.
  • Amendments: Was the clause amended during the employment? If so, which version applies? The last agreement is decisive.
  • Employer’s collective agreement coverage: Is the employer itself bound by a collective agreement? If not, the clause can still apply if it is structured as an equal treatment clause.

If you are unsure, have your clause reviewed by a specialist lawyer for employment law. They can also assess whether an invalid collective agreement norm applies individually through the reference and whether this gives rise to claims for you. The LAG ruling on higher classification during substitution shows how important a precise analysis of the contractual basis is (Higher Classification During Substitution: What the LAG Cologne Ruled on Differential Pay).

Conclusion: What to Consider for Back Pay Claims

The ruling of the LAG Schleswig-Holstein makes clear that equal treatment clauses have a strong effect. They can integrate invalid collective agreement provisions into the employment contract and supersede earlier, more favorable arrangements. For employees, this means: anyone who has such a clause in their contract should not prematurely hope for back pay if the collective agreement is to be challenged. Rather, the clause itself is the decisive lever.

If you wish to assert claims for pay differences or other benefits from collective agreements, you should seek legal advice. A specialist lawyer for employment law can review your reference clause, assess the prospects of success, and represent you in the proceedings. The costs of such proceedings can, under certain circumstances, be covered by litigation funding — RechtStark will gladly check whether funding is an option. This allows you to enforce your rights without financial risk.

Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.

This article is general information and does not replace individual legal advice. RechtStark is a litigation funder, not a law firm; you are represented by an independent lawyer.