Pay Grade Upgrade for Substitution: LAG Cologne Ruling on Differential Pay

Höhergruppierung bei Vertretung: Was das LAG Köln zur Differenzvergütung entschieden hat

A pay grade upgrade for substitution is a common point of contention in the public sector. Many employees temporarily take on higher-level duties and expect a corresponding increase in pay. However, the legal situation is complex, as a recent ruling by the Higher Labour Court (LAG) of Cologne demonstrates. A deputy museum director sought the pay difference for a substitution of the museum management that lasted more than a year—and failed in court.

Ruling of the LAG Cologne from 02.10.2026: Appeal Rejected, Federal Appeal Admitted

In its ruling of 02.10.2026 (Case No. 10 SLa 564/24), the Higher Labour Court of Cologne dismissed the plaintiff’s appeal against the judgment of the Labour Court of Cologne. The plaintiff had sued for the back payment of differential pay based on §§ 13, 14 TVöD-VKA or § 612 BGB (German Civil Code). The court upheld the first-instance decision, which had dismissed the claim as unfounded. However, the appeal on points of law to the Federal Labour Court was admitted—an indication that the legal question could be of fundamental importance.

For the plaintiff, the ruling is initially a defeat. She must not only bear the costs of the appeal proceedings but also continue to make do with the lower remuneration. Whether the Federal Labour Court will view the matter differently remains to be seen. For public sector employees, the ruling is nevertheless important because it highlights the limits of claims for higher classification during substitutions.

The Case: Deputy Museum Director Demands Differential Pay under TVöD-VKA

The plaintiff had been employed as the deputy director of a city museum by the defendant city since 01.05.2020. Her employment contract referred to the Collective Agreement for the Public Service (TVöD) in the version applicable to municipal employers (VKA). She was classified in pay grade 15, level 4—a classification that is quite common for a deputy management position.

Between 14.06.2021 and 21.06.2022, the plaintiff filled in for the museum management due to illness-related absence. This was followed by another substitution from 22.06.2022 to 15.10.2023, as the position of museum director was to be newly filled. In total, the plaintiff performed the duties of the museum director for more than two years—at least according to her own account, fully and not just partially.

For this period, the plaintiff demanded the difference between her remuneration according to pay grade 15, level 4 (€6,258.28 gross) and the remuneration of the museum director according to AT-A 16, level 4 (€7,145.22 gross). She relied on § 13 Para. 1 Sentence 2 TVöD-VKA in conjunction with § 14 Para. 1 TVöD-VKA. In her view, she had performed a higher-value activity not just temporarily—specifically for longer than six months—and was therefore entitled to a higher classification or at least an allowance equal to the difference.

Classification under TVöD-VKA: What Does Pay Grade 15 Level 4 Mean in This Case?

To understand the case, it helps to look at the system of classification in the public sector. The TVöD-VKA divides activities into pay grades, ranging from simple tasks (e.g., pay grade 2) to demanding management duties (e.g., pay grade 15 or non-tariff areas). Classification is based on the activity to be performed, not on the person. The decisive factor is whether the activity possesses the characteristics of the respective pay grade.

Within a pay grade, there are levels that primarily take into account professional experience and length of service. Level 4 is generally reached after several years of relevant professional experience. The plaintiff was therefore not a beginner but an experienced manager—yet her activity as deputy director had been evaluated and classified accordingly.

In contrast, the duties of the museum director were higher in value and classified in the non-tariff remuneration group AT-A 16. „Non-tariff“ means that the pay is no longer determined by the TVöD remuneration regulations, but by individual agreements or special regulations. The difference between the two salaries was approximately €887 gross per month—over 16 months, this adds up to a significant amount.

Pay grade upgrade for substitution: When are you entitled to higher pay?

The central legal question in this case was: Does a long-term substitution automatically lead to a higher classification? The plaintiff argued that a substitution could not last indefinitely. Only temporary substitutions—such as for vacation or illness—were covered by the duties of a deputy. A substitution of more than six months, she argued, was no longer „temporary“ but permanent, thus creating a claim for a higher classification.

The LAG Cologne did not follow this line of reasoning. According to the case law of the Federal Labour Court and collective bargaining practice, a substitution does not lead to a higher classification simply because it lasts a long time. Rather, the decisive factor is whether the substitution is designed as such—meaning, whether the substitute’s position continues to encompass the original activity and the higher-value activity is only performed temporarily. As long as the substitution is recognizably limited in time—for example, until the position is newly filled—the original classification remains.

This perspective may be unsatisfying for employees, as it means someone can perform the work of a higher-value position for months or even years without being paid accordingly. From the court’s point of view, however, this is covered by collective bargaining law: classification follows the activity to be performed, and in a substitution, the activity to be performed is that of the substitute—not that of the person being substituted. The higher-value activity is only performed temporarily and does not permanently define the position.

Differential Pay or Allowance: Which Claims are Possible for Long-Term Substitution?

The plaintiff had requested not only a higher classification but also, in the alternative, an allowance equal to the difference between her pay grade and that of the activity actually performed. The court also denied this claim. The TVöD-VKA does not generally provide for such an allowance in substitution cases. While there are allowances for certain hardships or special achievements, there is no general „substitution allowance“ that is automatically paid during longer substitutions.

This means: Those in the public sector who perform a higher-value activity on a substitution basis generally have no claim to the remuneration of the higher position—even if the substitution lasts several months or even over a year. A claim can only arise from special circumstances, such as if the employer explicitly promised an allowance or if the substitution actually leads to a permanent transfer of the higher-value activity.

One possible recourse is § 612 BGB, which provides for appropriate remuneration if an activity is assigned that is usually paid more. However, this claim also generally fails if the activity is performed only as a substitution and the employer clarifies that it is a temporary measure. The LAG Cologne apparently saw no room for such a derivation in its ruling.

What Public Sector Employees Can Learn from the Ruling

For public sector employees who take on a substitution, this ruling provides important guidance. First: a substitution does not automatically lead to a higher classification, even if it lasts a long time. Second: anyone performing a higher-value activity as a substitute should clarify early on whether the employer will grant an allowance—preferably in writing. Third: the duration of the substitution alone is not a sufficient argument for a higher classification as long as the substitute’s position remains unchanged. The ruling shows that claims for a pay grade upgrade are not a given.

Anyone who still wishes to enforce a higher classification or differential pay should realistically assess their chances. Case law is rather employer-friendly here, as this case shows. A lawsuit is associated with significant costs and risks—especially if one loses and must bear the procedural costs. This is exactly where litigation funding can help by taking over the cost risk. As a litigation funder, RechtStark reviews whether funding is an option and bears the costs in the event of success—an independent specialist lawyer for labor law handles the legal representation.

Before suing, one should also check whether an out-of-court settlement is possible. Many public sector employers are open to settlement discussions if the legal situation is not crystal clear. A well-prepared negotiation that addresses the specific circumstances of the individual case can sometimes achieve more than a lengthy legal dispute. Further information on the prospects of success and the costs of a dismissal protection lawsuit can be found in our guide to dismissal protection lawsuits as well as in the article on the costs of a dismissal protection lawsuit.

Legal Steps and Litigation Funding: How to Check Your Options

If you are affected by a similar situation—meaning you perform a higher-value activity as a substitute and are not paid accordingly—you should first check your employment contract documents and the applicable collective agreements. Clarify whether your contract contains an explicit regulation regarding substitution and whether the employer has promised you an allowance. Additionally, collect evidence of the activities you actually perform—such as job descriptions, work instructions, or emails.

A conversation with the employer is often the first step. Inquire in writing about how your substitution is remunerated and whether an allowance is considered. Do not settle for vague statements; insist on a clear answer. If the employer refuses, you can seek independent legal advice from a specialist lawyer for labor law. They can assess your prospects of success and, if necessary, prepare a lawsuit. Anyone wishing to secure a pay grade upgrade should assess their chances realistically and seek legal advice early on.

The costs of such a lawsuit should not be underestimated: attorney and court fees can quickly amount to several thousand euros depending on the amount in dispute. If you do not have legal expenses insurance or if it does not cover the case, litigation funding can be the solution. As a litigation funder, RechtStark reviews whether your case offers the prospects of success required for funding. If so, RechtStark covers the costs of the proceedings—and in the event of success, you keep the majority of the recovered differential pay.

The ruling of the LAG Cologne shows that claims for higher classification during substitutions are difficult to enforce. Nevertheless, every case must be viewed individually. The admitted appeal on points of law offers the chance for the Federal Labour Court to fundamentally clarify the legal question. Until then, public sector employees should know their rights and not hesitate to seek professional support—because even if the path is rocky, the effort can pay off if the individual circumstances support a claim.

Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.

This article is general information and does not replace individual legal advice. RechtStark is a litigation funder, not a law firm; you are represented by an independent lawyer.