Enforce Employment Reference: What the Hessian Labor Court Decided

Arbeitszeugnis einklagen: Was das Hessische LAG entschieden hat – arbeitszeugnis-einklagen

You can only enforce an employment reference if the wording in the settlement is sufficiently specific – a recent ruling by the Hessian Labor Court (LAG) from October 19, 2026 (Az. 10 Ta 207/26) shows what matters. The court addressed the question of how a court-ordered employment reference can be enforced when the employer refuses to issue the agreed version. The case involved an employee who, after an unfair dismissal dispute, had concluded a court settlement in which the employer undertook to issue a qualified reference based on a draft provided by the employee.

Enforce Employment Reference: Why a Settlement Is Often the Solution

Many unfair dismissal proceedings end in a settlement. There are practical reasons for this: both sides save time and costs, and the terms can be negotiated individually – including the content of the employment reference. In the present case, the parties had agreed in the settlement that the employer would issue a benevolently worded, qualified employment reference as of the termination date, using a draft submitted by the employee as a basis. The employer could only deviate from this draft for good cause. This clause sounds clear at first but raises considerable practical questions – as the LAG ruling shows. If you are pursuing an unfair dismissal claim, you can also regulate the reference in a settlement. An overview of the procedure and the possibilities of a claim can be found in our guide to unfair dismissal claims. A severance payment is also frequently part of the settlement – we have a detailed article on severance pay after dismissal.

However, the employer does not always abide by the agreement. If they fail to issue the reference or do not issue it in the agreed form, the employee must initiate enforcement proceedings. This is precisely what the Hessian LAG decided on.

The Decisive Wording: „Based on a Draft“

The LAG declared the settlement clause requiring the employer to issue the reference „based on a draft“ by the employee to be sufficiently specific. This means: the employer cannot argue that the clause is too vague to serve as an enforceable title. They must use the employee’s draft as a basis and may only deviate under narrowly defined conditions. For employees, this provides clarity about the content owed.

What does this mean in concrete terms? The employer must issue the reference as provided for in the draft, unless good cause justifies a deviation. Good cause exists, for example, if the draft is factually incorrect or violates the principle of reference truthfulness. In practice, such objections play a major role – also in the case the LAG had to decide.

When Deviating for Good Cause Is Permissible

The most important reason for deviating from a draft is reference truthfulness. Employment references must be true and must not assert false facts – this follows from Section 109 of the Trade Regulation Act (Gewerbeordnung). If the employee’s draft describes performance or behavior that does not correspond to reality, the employer must not simply adopt it. They must then deviate from the draft to create a truthful reference. Other good causes may include the draft misrepresenting the duties performed or claiming skills the employee does not possess. The decisive factor is that the employer substantiates and, in case of dispute, proves their reasons.

Deviating for good cause is therefore not an arbitrary decision. Rather, the employer must specifically identify which points of the draft they consider incorrect and why. Without such justification, the draft remains authoritative and enforceable.

The Objection of Reference Truthfulness: What Happens Then

This is exactly where the LAG’s decision comes in. The employer had submitted a different reference and argued that the employee’s draft violated reference truthfulness. The court ruled: if the employer raises such an objection, the „correct“ content of the reference must generally be clarified in new proceedings. The employee cannot simply force the employer to issue the reference in the desired form by means of a coercive fine. Instead, a new lawsuit must determine whether the draft is actually accurate. This applies even if the objections relate only to individual points, because a reference forms a unity – you cannot have an isolated sentence changed without affecting the overall impression.

For employees, this means: anyone who wants to enforce an employment reference must reckon with the employer blocking enforcement by raising the objection of reference truthfulness. It is therefore important to formulate the draft carefully and truthfully from the outset. Even if such an objection is annoying – it may be justified, and then the dispute must be decided in court.

Applying for a Coercive Fine: How Enforcement Works

To compel the issuance of a reference, the creditor can apply for a coercive fine at the labor court. This is a means of enforcement under Section 888 of the Code of Civil Procedure (ZPO). The court imposes a coercive fine on the debtor if they fail to perform the owed act. In the present case, the employee had filed this application. The Darmstadt Labor Court initially granted it, but the Hessian LAG overturned the decision and dismissed the application. The reason: because the employer had raised the objection of reference truthfulness, the title was not enforceable without further ado – the content of the reference first had to be clarified. A coercive fine is only available for an unambiguous title. This means: to enforce an employment reference via a coercive fine is only possible if the requested version is undisputed.

This shows how important careful wording in the settlement is. If the employer substantially disputes that the draft is truthful, you must take the detour via new proceedings. This costs time and money – a reason to seek legal advice early on and to structure the reference draft so that it offers little ground for attack.

Employer Insolvency: No Cause for Concern?

In addition, the LAG clarified an important procedural question: if insolvency proceedings are opened over the employer’s assets, this does not lead to a suspension of proceedings under Section 240 ZPO for reference claims. In many other legal disputes, ongoing proceedings are suspended by insolvency and can only be continued after certain steps. The situation is different for the issuance of references and other work documents: employees can continue to pursue their claims even during insolvency proceedings. Insolvency alone is therefore no obstacle to demanding the reference.

Nevertheless, you should realistically assess whether a coercive fine is enforceable if the company is insolvent. In insolvency, severance payments and other claims also play a role – more on this in our article severance pay in protective shield proceedings.

What Employees Should Bear in Mind Now

The LAG’s decision shows that enforcing an employment reference can be complex. Practical pointers:

  • Draft the settlement carefully: Do not agree to vague clauses. Ensure that the draft and the conditions for deviation are clearly defined.
  • Have the draft legally reviewed: Before agreeing to a settlement, have the reference draft reviewed by a specialist lawyer for employment law. A well-drafted draft minimizes the risk of later objections.
  • Demand justification for any deviation: If the employer deviates from the draft, demand a written justification. Only then can you assess whether the objection is justified.
  • Take reference truthfulness seriously: If the employer claims the draft is untrue, you must have it clarified in new proceedings what is correct. This can be elaborate.
  • Prepare enforcement: Only with an enforceable title can you apply for a coercive fine. Consider carefully whether this route makes sense.

If you are affected, you should seek legal advice early on. A specialist lawyer for employment law can assess your prospects of success and initiate the right steps. Financing the proceedings can also be an issue – as a litigation funder, RechtStark reviews whether funding may be an option for your case.

Obtaining a correct employment reference is an important step for your professional future. The Hessian LAG ruling shows that you should proceed carefully when formulating and enforcing your claim. With the right preparation and legal support, the chances are good of obtaining an effective reference.

Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.

This article is general information and does not replace individual legal advice. RechtStark is a litigation funder, not a law firm; you are represented by an independent lawyer.