Executive Employee Dismissal Protection: BAG Ruling 7 ABR 9/25 Explained

Whether you qualify as an executive employee determines your executive employee dismissal protection in Germany. Because executive employees fall outside the Protection Against Dismissal Act, they can be dismissed more easily. A recent ruling by the Federal Labor Court (Bundesarbeitsgericht, 7 ABR 9/25) shows when independent hiring and firing authority is not enough to establish this status. The ruling is also relevant for many other managers in retail and beyond.
The term „executive employee“ is defined in the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG, § 5 para. 3). Under this definition, a person is an executive employee if, according to their employment contract and position in the company or establishment, they are authorized to independently hire and dismiss employees. This personnel authority is the most important criterion, but not the only one. Other characteristics such as holding a general commercial power of attorney (Prokura) or general entrepreneurial decision-making authority can also play a role.
Executive employees perform employer functions and are therefore not integrated into the works council. They are also not covered by general dismissal protection. This means: a dismissal does not need to be socially justified, unless special protective provisions apply, such as the General Equal Treatment Act or protection against discrimination.
For many employees, executive status is therefore a disadvantage when it comes to keeping their job. It is all the more important to know when this status actually applies.
Executive Employee: Definition and Delimitation in Labor Law
The definition in the Works Constitution Act sounds clear at first, but in practice there are many gray areas. What matters is not only what the employment contract says, but also which powers are actually exercised. A branch manager who formally has hiring and firing authority may still not be an executive employee if this authority is only of subordinate significance. The Federal Labor Court clarified this in its recent decision.
The delimitation is important because it decides whether general dismissal protection applies. Anyone who does not qualify as an executive employee can challenge a dismissal with a protection against dismissal lawsuit. Further information on the process can be found in our guide to protection against dismissal lawsuits.
The Case: Branch Director with 91 Employees in Retail
In the case decided by the BAG, it concerned a branch director of a retail company with around 3,500 employees across approximately 70 branches. The director was deployed in a branch employing 97 people. She had 91 of these employees reporting to her and was, according to the employer, authorized to independently hire and dismiss. The HR department at headquarters only provided administrative support.
The works council of this branch sought a judicial determination that the branch director is not an executive employee. It argued that the personnel authority covers only 2.6 percent of the total workforce and is therefore of subordinate significance. Moreover, other managers were also authorized to hire and dismiss, which further relativizes the significance of the individual authority.
The labor court initially ruled in favor of the works council, and the higher labor court confirmed this. The employer then filed a legal complaint with the Federal Labor Court.
BAG Ruling 7 ABR 9/25: Independent Personnel Authority Is Not Sufficient
The Federal Labor Court overturned the higher labor court’s decision and referred the case back. In its ruling, it clarified: independent hiring and firing authorization does not establish executive status if it is only of subordinate significance for the establishment and thus for the company. The decisive factor is not merely the existence of the authority, but its actual significance.
The court emphasized that personnel authority is not of subordinate significance if it relates to (virtually) all employees of an establishment. In the specific case, the branch director’s authority covered 91 of 97 employees — virtually all. The personnel authority would therefore regularly be classified as significant.
However, the BAG criticized that the higher labor court had not sufficiently justified its decision. It had apparently placed too much weight on the ratio of employee numbers between the branch and the total company. This ratio, in the BAG’s view, is not decisive.
Subordinate Significance: When Is Personnel Authority Insignificant?
The crucial question is: when is personnel authority so insignificant that it does not justify executive status? The BAG clarified that the significance for the establishment matters, not the ratio to the total company.
Subordinate significance typically exists when the authority only covers a small part of the workforce. Example: a department head may only hire and dismiss for their department of five employees, while the establishment has 200 employees total. Here the personnel authority would be quantitatively minor and could be considered subordinate.
The situation differs when the authority covers virtually all employees of an establishment — as in the case of the branch director. Then it is not subordinate, even if the establishment is small compared to the company. The BAG expressly ruled that the ratio between the number of employees covered by the personnel authority in the establishment and the total number of employees in the company is regularly not decisive.
Qualitative aspects can also play a role. The key question is whether the personnel decisions have genuine entrepreneurial significance. Someone who may only hire assistants carries less weight than someone who decides on skilled workers or management positions.
Employee Numbers: Why the Ratio to the Company Does Not Count
Many employers argue that personnel authority is insignificant if the affected establishment represents only a small part of the total workforce. The BAG has now clearly rejected this view. The establishment is the reference point for the assessment, not the company.
This means: if an establishment has only 20 employees and a supervisor may hire and dismiss all 20, they are classified as an executive employee — even if the company employs 10,000 people in total. The personnel authority is of great significance for this establishment because it affects all employees.
This clarification is important for many branch-based businesses in retail, hospitality, or the service sector. These often have small establishments with a few dozen employees but a large total workforce. The BAG’s decision creates more legal certainty here.
However, the higher labor court must now re-examine in the specific case whether the branch director actually had sole decision-making authority or whether headquarters was more involved. The employer had claimed the HR department only acted in a supporting role, while the works council saw it differently. The higher labor court must now decide these factual questions.
Dismissal Protection for Executive Employees: What Employees Must Know
Classification as an executive employee has significant effects on dismissal protection. Anyone classified as an executive employee is not subject to the general Protection Against Dismissal Act. This means: the employer can terminate the employment relationship without stating a social reason, provided no other protective provisions apply.
Executive employees can often negotiate higher severance payments because they usually have better contractual terms. Severance clauses or non-compete agreements are frequently agreed upon. Notice periods are also often longer than for regular employees. If you are seeking a severance payment, you can find useful information in our guide to severance payments.
For employees unsure whether they qualify as executive employees, it is important to clarify this early on. This classification determines whether a protection against dismissal lawsuit has prospects of success. If you are wrongly treated as an executive employee when you are not, you can challenge a dismissal. Further tips on avoiding dismissal mistakes and securing your severance can be found in our article on avoiding dismissal mistakes.
Conversely, it may happen that the employer wrongly treats you as a regular employee when you are actually an executive. Then you have more dismissal protection but potentially other disadvantages, for example regarding the works council. Clarification is advisable here as well.
How to Clarify Your Status: Engage a Specialist Lawyer for Labor Law
If you are uncertain whether you belong to the executive employees, do not leave it unresolved. A wrong classification can become expensive in the event of a dismissal. The status can often be determined based on the employment contract and the actually performed activity.
A specialist lawyer for labor law can review your contract and assess whether you are classified as an executive employee. This is particularly important if a dismissal threatens or you want to negotiate a severance payment. The status also plays a role in the question of whether you are eligible for the works council.
RechtStark as a litigation funder can cover the costs of a protection against dismissal lawsuit if you qualify as a regular employee and wish to file suit. We review your case and finance attorney and court costs. This allows you to enforce your rights without financial risk. Further information on litigation funding can be found on our website.
The BAG ruling shows that case law is increasingly specifying the criteria for executive employees. For employees, this is an opportunity to question their own status more precisely and not rely prematurely on the employer’s assertions. If you are affected, seek advice early — it can make the decisive difference.
Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.


