Job Application Disclosure Obligation: BAG Ruling 5 AZR 37/25 Strengthens Employee Rights

The job application disclosure obligation after dismissal is often a point of contention when employees claim acceptance delay compensation. Some employers demand information about all job applications in return. The Federal Labor Court has now ruled: there is no general disclosure obligation. The ruling 5 AZR 37/25 from August 26, 2026 strengthens employee rights in dismissal protection proceedings and provides clarity for anyone demanding wages after an invalid dismissal.
Acceptance Delay Compensation: What Employees Need to Know After Dismissal
If your employer dismisses you and you file a dismissal protection lawsuit, the question often arises whether you continue to receive compensation until the proceedings are finally concluded. This is where acceptance delay compensation comes in: if the dismissal is invalid, the employer is in acceptance delay as soon as you offer your work performance – even if they do not actually employ you. They must then continue to pay wages even though you could not perform any work.
This statutory provision in Section 615 BGB and Section 11 KSchG aims to prevent the employer from being released from their wage payment obligation through a formally valid but materially invalid dismissal. For employees, this is an important lever, because during a dismissal protection proceeding – which often takes months – their financial existence remains secured. However, you must register as unemployed after the dismissal and actively seek a new position. Otherwise, you face the argument of bad faith failure to earn other income.
The Case: Dismissal, Acknowledgment Judgment, and the Employer’s Counterclaim for Disclosure
The Federal Labor Court had to decide a case that illustrates typical proceedings in dismissal protection cases. An employee working for an online furniture shop received a dismissal for operational reasons in February 2023, effective February 28, 2023. He sued against the dismissal, and in October 2023 an acknowledgment judgment was issued – the employer acknowledged the invalidity of the dismissal. From October 16, 2023, the employee was employed again.
For the months of March through October 2023, the employee demanded compensation by way of acceptance delay. The employer refused to pay, arguing that the employee had failed in bad faith to earn other income. In addition, the employer filed a counterclaim demanding disclosure: Which placement proposals did the Federal Employment Agency make? Which positions did you apply for? Which application documents were submitted? How did the applications turn out? The employer wanted to know in detail how active the employee had been in their job search.
Job Application Disclosure Obligation: What the BAG Ruling 5 AZR 37/25 Means
The Federal Labor Court clarified in its ruling: an employer has no independently enforceable claim requiring the employee to disclose whether, how, and with what result they applied for positions that were conveyed to them by the Federal Employment Agency or the Jobcenter. The guiding principle of the ruling states: „The employer has no independently enforceable claim against the employee demanding acceptance delay compensation for disclosure of whether, how, and with what result the employee applied for positions conveyed by the public employment placement authorities.“
This means for you: if you claim acceptance delay compensation, the employer cannot control all your job application efforts in advance. They cannot simply file a disclosure lawsuit just to monitor your efforts to find work. This decision on the job application disclosure obligation significantly strengthens the employee’s position, because it prevents the employer from building pressure and dragging out the proceedings through disclosure demands.
The job application disclosure obligation therefore exists only within narrow limits – and these limits have now been specified by the Federal Labor Court. The employer cannot demand all documents across the board but must substantiate in the specific proceedings why they doubt your willingness to work. Only then must you respond.
Why the Employer May Still Examine Job Application Efforts
The ruling does not mean, however, that the employer must completely ignore your job application efforts. In the proceedings, they can still argue that you failed in bad faith to earn other income. This argument is governed by Section 11 sentence 1 KSchG: the employer need not pay compensation if the employee fails in bad faith to accept reasonable alternative employment. Bad faith occurs when someone, despite knowing of the possibility of reasonable employment, does not make efforts to obtain it – for example, because they write no applications at all or consciously ignore job offers.
The difference: the employer cannot sue for disclosure as an independent claim but must introduce the assertion of bad faith failure to earn other income into the proceedings. You as the employee then bear the burden of pleading and proof for your efforts. You must therefore specifically plead in the proceedings which positions you applied for and how the applications turned out. But the employer cannot force this in advance – they must first substantiate the corresponding doubts.
In practice, this means: if your employer accuses you of not having made sufficient efforts, you must present your job application activities. These include cover letters, invitations to interviews, or rejections. You should therefore keep all documents carefully – but only disclose them when the employer specifically raises the accusation. A general demand for disclosure without concrete indications need not be fulfilled.
Bad Faith Failure to Earn Other Income: When It Becomes Truly Relevant
The term „bad faith“ is interpreted narrowly by the courts. It is not enough that you only made half-hearted efforts or that some applications were unsuccessful. Bad faith requires that you consciously and intentionally failed to accept reasonable employment. Reasonable is work that corresponds to your qualifications and previous salary and that you can perform health-wise. A position significantly below your level or unreasonably far away need not be accepted.
In the case decided by the Federal Labor Court, the employee had applied for four placement proposals from the Federal Employment Agency, three were unsuccessful, one led to an interview that did not take place due to the resumption of work. Additionally, he applied on his own initiative to another company and sought a training measure. The Federal Labor Court saw this as sufficient effort – the employer had not pleaded any concrete indications of bad faith. This shows: anyone actively seeking work and able to prove they wrote applications generally need not worry.
It is important that you register as a job seeker immediately after the dismissal and inform the Federal Employment Agency that you are looking for a new position. Only then can you later prove that you complied with your obligation to seek work. The Agency can make placement proposals – you should pursue these seriously as well. But even if you do not respond to a proposal, that is not automatically bad faith. It always depends on the overall circumstances.
Practical Tips: How to Respond Correctly to Disclosure Demands
If your employer asks you to disclose all your applications after a dismissal, you should know how to behave. Here are concrete recommendations for action:
- Check whether a concrete accusation exists: If the employer demands disclosure across the board without citing concrete indications of bad faith, you can refuse the disclosure. You are not obliged to respond to a general demand for disclosure.
- Keep your application documents: Even if you do not have to hand everything over immediately, you should collect cover letters, emails, responses, and invitations. You will need these documents if the employer raises the accusation of bad faith failure to earn other income in the proceedings.
- Register as a job seeker: Go to the Federal Employment Agency immediately after receiving the dismissal and register as a job seeker. Have the placement proposals confirmed in writing and keep them.
- Respond appropriately in the proceedings: If the employer raises the defense of bad faith failure to earn other income, you must present your efforts. Do so completely and comprehensibly – but only within the framework of the proceedings, not in advance in response to an out-of-court disclosure demand.
- Obtain legal support: The question of whether you must provide disclosure and how to present your job application efforts is complex. A specialist lawyer for labor law can advise you individually and represent your interests in the proceedings. If you have financial concerns, litigation funding can help minimize the cost risk.
These tips help you protect your rights and avoid being put under unnecessary pressure. The key point is: you do not have to disclose every application just because the employer demands it. The BAG ruling makes clear that your privacy remains protected as long as no concrete indications of bad faith exist.
Conclusion: Your Rights Regarding Acceptance Delay and Dismissal Protection Lawsuit
The Federal Labor Court’s ruling 5 AZR 37/25 is an important success for employees. It prevents employers from building pressure and delaying proceedings through blanket disclosure demands. At the same time, the argument of bad faith failure to earn other income remains – but only becomes relevant if the employer can cite concrete indications. For you, this means: you can claim acceptance delay compensation without having to disclose your entire job application strategy. As long as you actively seek a new position and can prove this in the event of a dispute, you are well protected.
If you are affected by a dismissal and wish to claim acceptance delay compensation, a dismissal protection lawsuit is often the first step. Further information on the legal foundations can also be found in our article on acceptance delay compensation after dismissal as well as on the special aspects of job search during the proceedings. Consult a specialist lawyer for labor law if in doubt – and check whether litigation funding makes sense for you to limit the financial risk.
Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.


