Part-Time Overtime Pay: Hamburg Labor Court Confirms 35-Hour Threshold in Collective Agreement

The topic of part-time overtime pay concerns many employees who work part-time yet still put in overtime hours. The Hamburg Higher Labor Court (Landesarbeitsgericht) decided on September 4, 2026, in a closely watched ruling (Ref. 7 SLa 12/26) that collective agreement provisions making overtime premiums available only once the collectively agreed weekly working time of 35 hours is exceeded can also apply to part-time employees. This means that part-time staff who work more than their contractual hours but less than 35 hours per week may, under certain circumstances, have no entitlement to overtime premiums. The ruling has far-reaching consequences for the compensation of part-time workers and raises questions about equal treatment.
Part-Time Overtime Pay: The Hamburg Higher Labor Court Ruling at a Glance
In the underlying case, an employee was employed with a weekly working time of 28 hours. His employment contract referred to the collective agreements of the metal and electrical industry for Hamburg and the surrounding area. The applicable framework collective agreement (MTV) defines overtime as the exceeding of the individual regular daily working time required up to the start of work on the following day. For part-time employees, however, a special rule applies: premium-eligible overtime exists only when the collectively agreed weekly working time of 35 hours is exceeded. The plaintiff had demanded overtime premiums for hours worked beyond his individual 28-hour week but below the 35-hour threshold. The Hamburg Labor Court initially ruled in his favor, but the Hamburg Higher Labor Court overturned that judgment and dismissed the action.
The Higher Labor Court clarified that such a collective agreement provision does not violate the Part-Time and Fixed-Term Employment Act (TzBfG). Under Section 4(1) TzBfG, a part-time employee may not be treated less favorably than a comparable full-time employee because of their part-time status, unless objective reasons justify the unequal treatment. The court found such objective reasons to exist and emphasized that judicial review is limited to an arbitrariness check. This means: as long as the collective bargaining parties do not act in a manifestly unreasonable manner with their rule, the courts will accept their decision.
Collective Agreement Rules: Why Only from 35 Hours Onward?
Collective agreements are negotiated by trade unions and employer associations. They enjoy a wide margin of discretion to regulate working conditions for an entire industry. The 35-hour threshold for overtime premiums was deliberately chosen in the metal and electrical sector. It is intended to establish normal full-time employment as the benchmark for evaluating overtime. When a part-time employee works more than contractually agreed but does not exceed the collectively agreed full-time threshold, this additional working time is not regarded as overtime in the collective agreement sense. Instead, it counts as „normal“ working time compensated only at the regular hourly rate.
From the perspective of the collective bargaining parties, this rule offers several advantages: it creates clear and simple boundaries, avoids burdensome case-by-case assessments, and promotes employee flexibility. It also prevents part-time employees from being financially better off than full-time employees working the same number of hours, thanks to high premiums. The Hamburg Higher Labor Court classified these considerations as objectively comprehensible and thereby strengthened collective bargaining autonomy. The decision shows that courts generally respect collective agreement generalizations and typifications as long as they do not appear arbitrary. Similar to the equal pay claim, the issue here is when different pay rules are permissible.
What the Ruling Means for Part-Time Employees
For part-time employees working in a collectively bound company, the ruling has immediate effects. Part-time overtime pay is due only when the collectively agreed weekly working time is exceeded. Someone hired for 20 hours per week who regularly works 30 hours, for example, receives no overtime premium for the additional 10 hours as long as the collectively agreed 35-hour week is not surpassed. This can lead to noticeable financial losses, especially if overtime accumulates over a longer period. Many part-time workers assume that merely exceeding their individual working time triggers a premium — an assumption that does not hold under this case law.
However, the ruling applies only to collective agreement provisions. If your employment contract or an applicable collective agreement contains a different definition of overtime, other rules may apply. Moreover, an appeal to the Federal Labor Court (Bundesarbeitsgericht) has been admitted. It remains to be seen whether the highest instance will confirm the Hamburg Higher Labor Court’s view. Until the BAG decides otherwise, employers can rely on the current line. For part-time employees this means: check carefully which collective agreement provisions apply to your employment relationship and how your individual working time relates to the collectively agreed full-time threshold.
Objective Reasons and Arbitrariness Review: The Legal Reasoning
The legal core of the ruling lies in the interpretation of Section 4(1) TzBfG. This provision prohibits the disadvantaging of part-time employees compared to full-time employees but permits exceptions for objective reasons. The Hamburg Higher Labor Court held that the collective agreement rule making overtime premiums available only from 35 hours onward is justified by objective reasons. It stressed collective bargaining autonomy: the bargaining parties have a wide margin of discretion, and courts must not substitute their own idea of „correct“ working-time policy for the collectively agreed rule.
The review is therefore confined to an arbitrariness check. The court asks only whether the rule is manifestly unreasonable, i.e., arbitrary. In the specific case, no arbitrariness could be found. The distinction between part-time and full-time employees in overtime compensation is based on comprehensible considerations: it ties to the collectively agreed normal working time that applies to all employees in the sector and avoids unequal treatment within the group of part-time employees. This reasoning is likely to withstand scrutiny before the Federal Labor Court as well, even though a final decision is still pending.
Action Steps: How to Verify Your Entitlements
If you want to check whether you are entitled to part-time overtime pay, you should proceed systematically. First, determine which collective agreement applies to your employment relationship. Check your employment contract for a collective agreement reference or ask your employer whether they are collectively bound. Then read the relevant provisions on working time and overtime. Pay attention to definitions that refer either to the individual or to the collectively agreed working time. Only if your individual working time forms the benchmark do you have a premium entitlement from the first overtime hour.
Also establish whether your actual hours worked exceed the collectively agreed weekly working time. If you have a contractual 28 hours but regularly work 36 hours, collective-agreement overtime exists — for the hours beyond 35. For the hours between 28 and 35, however, you receive no premium. Collect your working time records and document all ordered overtime. Only with an accurate overview can you concretize your claims. If you are unsure whether your case is affected by the current case law, you should seek advice from a specialist lawyer for labor law. Also bear in mind the costs of an unfair dismissal action if you are considering legal steps.
Engage a Specialist Lawyer: Your Next Steps
The Hamburg Higher Labor Court’s decision shows how complex the legal situation regarding overtime premiums can be. If you wish to enforce concrete claims, engaging a specialist lawyer for labor law is advisable. An experienced attorney can examine whether your employment contract or the applicable collective agreement contains a more favorable rule for you and realistically assess the prospects of success of a lawsuit. They can also prevent you from missing important deadlines through incorrect argumentation.
Note that labor law claims are often subject to short deadlines. If you want to claim overtime premiums, you should not wait too long. A specialist lawyer can also assess whether a claim before the labor court makes sense or whether an out-of-court settlement with the employer is worth considering. If you have financial concerns, litigation funding options exist that can mitigate the cost risk. A lawyer can advise you on this — regardless of whether you ultimately litigate or negotiate.
Conclusion: Key Takeaways from the Ruling
The Hamburg Higher Labor Court’s ruling is an important clarification on the topic of part-time overtime pay. It confirms that collective agreements may independently define overtime compensation and link it to the collectively agreed full-time threshold. For affected employees this means: not every additional working hour is automatically premium-eligible. What matters is how the collective agreement defines overtime. If you work part-time and perform overtime, you should examine your individual situation carefully and seek legal advice. The appeal to the Federal Labor Court has been admitted — it remains to be seen whether the highest instance confirms the Hamburg Higher Labor Court’s line. Until then: inform yourself, document your working hours, and obtain professional guidance where anything is unclear.
Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.


