Works Council Equipment Rights: No Individual Claim for Members

Sachmittelanspruch des Betriebsrats: Kein individueller Anspruch für einzelne Mitglieder – sachmittelanspruch-des-betriebsrats

The works council equipment rights are a central topic in works constitution law – but who can actually assert them? The Federal Labor Court (BAG) provided a clear answer with its ruling of June 25, 2026 (Ref. 7 ABR 27/25): An individual works council member has no individual claim to equipment with material resources such as a personalized email address. Only the works council as a collective body can demand such resources. We explain what this means for practice.

What are the works council equipment rights?

The works council equipment rights are among the most important rights of the works council. They derive from Section 40 (2) BetrVG (Works Constitution Act). According to this, the employer must provide the works council with the necessary material resources. These include, for example, office space, writing materials, telephones, computers, and email addresses. Without this equipment, the works council could not properly perform its statutory duties.

The claim is directed exclusively at the employer. The works council must request the required resources and may use them independently. The employer bears the costs. The decisive factor is that this is a collective right – not a claim of individual members. The BAG has now clarified this once again.

In practice, the question often arises as to which material resources are „necessary.“ This depends on the specific circumstances, such as the size of the works council, the nature of its tasks, and technological developments. Digital work tools such as email addresses, video conferencing tools, or cloud services play a major role today.

The Case: A Works Council Member Demands a Personalized Email Address

In the case decided by the BAG, a company operated several hundred supermarkets nationwide. Due to a collective agreement under Section 3 (1) No. 1 Letter b BetrVG, multiple works council districts had been formed. The applicant was a member of the works council in District 5. The employer provided the works council with a shared email address under the domain „n-online.de,“ accessible to all members. For certain persons, such as released works council members, personalized addresses existed – some even with the ability to communicate via external domains.

The applicant did not have such a personalized address. He requested the employer to set one up for him, enabling him to send and receive emails to addresses outside the company’s own domain. When the employer refused, he went to the labor court – without a prior works council resolution.

His argument: The claim to equipment belongs not only to the collective body but also to each individual member. No resolution was needed because, as minority protection, he had his own right. He needed the address to communicate confidentially with employees.

The BAG’s Decision on Equipment Rights

The BAG rejected the works council member’s legal view. The Senate ruled that the claim to equipment with material resources belongs to the works council as a collective body. An individual works council member has no individual, body-independent claim. The decision of the Higher Labor Court of Lower Saxony, which had ruled in favor of the applicant, was thus overturned.

The judges clarified that the works council equipment rights are a collective right. They serve the functioning of the works council as an organ of works constitution. The equipment is provided for the body as a whole – not for individual persons. If a works council member needs certain work tools, this must be asserted through the works council as a collective body.

This means: Only if the works council passes a corresponding resolution can it demand the setup of a personalized email address from the employer. A single member cannot enforce claims on their own. This decision has far-reaching consequences for practice – not only for email addresses but for all material resources.

Why the Claim Belongs Only to the Collective Body – the Court’s Reasoning

The BAG based its decision on the nature of the works council as a collegial body. The works council acts not through individual members but through resolutions. Only the body as a whole can bindingly determine which material resources are necessary for its work. An individual enforcement right of individual members would undermine this collective structure.

Additionally, the court emphasized that this collective claim is not tailored to a specific group of persons. The employer must provide the works council with the resources it needs as a whole. Whether individual members require additional equipment is decided by the works council – not by the individual member.

The Senate also addressed the aspect of minority protection. The applicant had argued that minorities in the works council particularly depend on their own material resources. The court clarified, however, that minority protection is ensured through internal procedures – for example, through the right to convene a meeting or request a resolution. An individual claim against the employer is not required for this.

Moreover: A personalized email address can certainly be a legitimate need, especially for released works council members who communicate extensively externally. But even then, the works council as a collective body must decide whether to request this equipment. A single member cannot directly hold the employer liable.

What This Means for Works Council Members in Practice

For works council members, the decision provides a clear instruction: On all questions of material equipment, they must address the works council as a collective body. They cannot assert claims against the employer on their own authority. This applies particularly to digital work devices, software licenses, but also to organizational measures such as setting up additional email mailboxes.

If an individual member believes certain resources are lacking, they should raise the topic in a works council meeting. The works council can then pass a resolution and request the equipment from the employer. If the employer does not comply, the works council can call the labor court – not the individual member. The collective body is also responsible for other equipment questions, such as the use of company cars – as a ruling by the Higher Labor Court on company cars for works councils shows.

The aspect of confidentiality is also important: Especially in communication with employees, data protection requirements play a role. The works council must ensure that sensitive information is protected. A shared address may suffice for this; in some cases, personalized addresses are useful. But such decisions are always made by the collective body.

In practice, works councils should therefore establish clear rules on material equipment from the outset. A works agreement can specify which devices and digital services are provided and under what conditions individual members may access them. This creates legal certainty for both sides.

Tips for Works Councils: How to Request Material Resources Correctly

To avoid disputes with the employer, works councils should proceed systematically when requesting material resources. First, the need should be concretely determined. Which work tools are required for current work? These include not only classic office materials but also modern technology such as laptops, company phones, and software solutions.

Subsequently, the works council should pass a formal resolution. The resolution must clearly specify which material resources are needed in what scope. Only then can the employer know exactly what to procure. A blanket request is often insufficient and can lead to rejections.

The request should be addressed to the employer in writing. It should set out the legal basis (Section 40 (2) BetrVG) and the concrete need. For larger purchases, it may be useful to obtain a quote and ask the employer for approval. If the employer fails to fulfill its obligation, the works council can pass a resolution to initiate a resolution procedure.

Even if individual members have special wishes – such as their own email address – these should always go through the collective body. The works council should examine whether the requested equipment is actually necessary and in an appropriate proportion to the costs. This avoids unnecessary conflicts and ensures that the rights of the collective body are preserved.

If a works council member is unsure whether a specific material resource request is permissible, they can consult an independent specialist lawyer for labor law. They can assess the prospects of success and assist in drafting the applications. The responsible trade union legal protection also offers support.

Conclusion: Clarify Equipment Questions Through the Works Council

The BAG’s decision brings clarity: The works council equipment rights belong exclusively to the collective body. Individual members cannot assert their own claims – neither to an email address nor to other work tools. For works councils, this means they must always bring their concerns to the employer through formal resolutions.

This legal situation makes sense because it strengthens the collective capacity of the works council to act and prevents individual persons from enforcing special rights. If a works council member wants better equipment, they should raise the topic in the body. This keeps the cooperation between employer and works council on a solid legal basis.

If you need support with labor law questions as an employee or works council member, an independent specialist lawyer for labor law can help. RechtStark assesses whether the financing of a possible proceeding – such as an unfair dismissal action – can be covered. Further information on options in dismissal protection can be found in our guide to unfair dismissal actions.

Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.

This article is general information and does not replace individual legal advice. RechtStark is a litigation funder, not a law firm; you are represented by an independent lawyer.