Collective Bargaining Conflict: What the BAG Ruling on Deutsche Bahn Means

Tarifkollision: Was das BAG-Urteil zur Deutschen Bahn bedeutet

A collective bargaining conflict is a complex issue affecting many employees when multiple unions have concluded competing collective agreements. A recent ruling by the Federal Labor Court (BAG) on August 12, 2026 (Ref. 4 AZR 104/25) shows how such conflicts are resolved and what consequences they have for claims like long-term accounts.

The case involved an employee of a Deutsche Bahn AG company who is a member of the Railway and Transport Union (EVG). His employer is a member of the Employers‘ and Business Association of Mobility and Transport Service Providers (AGV MOVE), which has concluded collective agreements with both the EVG and the German Train Drivers‘ Union (GDL). The employee had a so-called long-term account into which he could pay overtime and residual leave as value credits. However, since October 2022, the employer has applied only the GDL collective agreements in his operation – with the result that the employee can no longer add further credits to his long-term account.

The employee sued for a declaration that the EVG collective agreements continue to apply to his employment relationship. The Ulm Labor Court dismissed the action, the Baden-Württemberg Regional Labor Court partially upheld it. The BAG overturned the appellate ruling and dismissed the action in full.

The Case: Long-Term Account Dispute at Deutsche Bahn

The plaintiff works in a separate bargaining unit of the defendant, a company of the DB Group. He is a member of the EVG. The defendant is a member of AGV MOVE, which has concluded collective agreements with both the EVG and the GDL. Initially, the defendant applied the collective agreements of both unions side by side, including the „Collective Agreement on the Management of Long-Term Accounts for Employees of Various Companies of the DB Group“ (Lzk-TV) from 2020. On this basis, a long-term account was maintained for the plaintiff, into which he could pay overtime remuneration and residual leave entitlements.

Since October 2022, the defendant has applied only the GDL collective agreements in the separate bargaining unit. The credits already accumulated continue to earn interest and can be used for leave periods, but no new credits are added. The plaintiff unsuccessfully demanded the continuation of his long-term account and filed suit.

During the proceedings, the Lzk-TV 2020 was replaced by a new Lzk-TV 2023, also concluded with the EVG. The plaintiff requested a declaration that both the Lzk-TV 2020 and the Lzk-TV 2023 apply to his employment relationship. As an alternative, he requested that the defendant be ordered to continue making credits to his long-term account.

Collective Bargaining Conflict: EVG vs. GDL – Which Rules Apply?

When two unions have concluded competing collective agreements for the same operation, this is referred to as a collective bargaining conflict. The Collective Agreement Act (TVG) regulates in Section 4a which collective agreement applies in such a case. As a rule, the decisive factor is the collective agreement of the union that has the most organized employees in the operation. This rule is intended to ensure that the will of the majority of employees is respected.

In the present case, the parties agreed that more GDL members than EVG members are employed in the separate bargaining unit. Consequently, the GDL collective agreement displaces the EVG collective agreements pursuant to Section 4a (2) sentence 2 TVG. The plaintiff argued that the EVG collective agreements concern long-term claims such as long-term accounts, which deserve special protection and must not simply be displaced. The BAG did not follow this argument.

The collective bargaining conflict thus leads to the collective agreement of the majority union taking precedence. For employees, this means: even if they are members of another union, the provisions of the collective agreement that is decisive for the operation apply to them. Exceptions exist only in narrow limits, for example if the displaced collective agreement would violate mandatory statutory provisions or fundamental rights.

Long-Term Accounts Simply Explained: Overtime and Residual Leave as Value Credits

Long-term accounts are an instrument of working time organization. Employees can pay parts of their remuneration, overtime, or residual leave into a value credit that is accumulated in an account. This credit can later be used for longer leave periods, sabbaticals, or earlier retirement. The credit usually earns interest and is protected against insolvency.

In the dispute, the question was whether the employee can continue to pay credits into his long-term account. The employer had refused this with reference to the collective bargaining conflict. The BAG confirmed that the employer is not obliged to make further credits if the EVG collective agreement is displaced by that of the GDL.

Important: Already accumulated credits remain in place. They continue to earn interest and can be used for leave periods. It is merely a matter of no new credits being added. The ruling therefore does not affect existing claims, only future accumulation.

The BAG Decision: What the Ruling Means

The Federal Labor Court, by judgment of August 12, 2026 (Ref. 4 AZR 104/25), partially upheld the defendant’s appeal and set aside the judgment of the Baden-Württemberg Regional Labor Court insofar as it had declared the applicability of the Lzk-TV 2023. The plaintiff’s appeal against the judgment of the Ulm Labor Court was dismissed in full. This means: the plaintiff has no claim that the EVG collective agreements be applied to his employment relationship. The GDL collective agreements are decisive.

The ruling confirms the case law on collective bargaining conflict. Employees must expect that the collective agreements applicable to them can change if the majority ratios of unions in the operation shift. This also applies to long-term claims such as long-term accounts. An exception exists only if the displaced collective agreement would violate mandatory statutory provisions or fundamental rights – which was not the case here.

For practice, this means: employees who are members of a union whose collective agreement is displaced by that of another union cannot rely on their own collective agreement. They must accept the rules of the majority union, even if they are not its members. If you fear financial disadvantages, however, you should check whether you have statutory claims such as severance pay after dismissal – these can exist independently of the collective agreement.

What Affected Employees Should Do Now

If you are affected by a collective bargaining conflict, you should first check which union has the most members in your operation. You can inquire about this through the works council or the unions. The decisive factor is whether your employer continues to apply your union’s collective agreement or has switched to the other union’s collective agreement.

If your employer refuses to apply your collective agreement, you have several options. First, you can request application of the collective agreement in writing and demand a justification for the refusal. If your employer does not respond, you can initiate labor law proceedings. A lawsuit before the labor court can, however, involve costs and risks. An unfair dismissal claim can serve as orientation, even if your case does not involve a dismissal – the basic procedures are similar.

It is advisable to consult a specialist employment lawyer before filing suit. A lawyer can assess the prospects of success and initiate the correct steps. Note that labor law claims are subject to deadlines – in the case of a dismissal, this is three weeks; for other disputes, other deadlines may apply. If you are concerned about the costs of proceedings, litigation funding may be an option – check whether a provider like RechtStark can support your case.

Conclusion: Your Rights in Collective Agreement Conflicts

The BAG ruling on collective bargaining conflict makes clear: collective agreements can change when the majority ratios of unions in the operation shift. Employees must expect that their previous collective agreement may no longer apply, even if they are members of the union concerned. Existing claims such as already accumulated long-term accounts remain intact, however.

If you are affected by a collective bargaining conflict, you should know your rights and have it checked whether you can assert claims. The collective bargaining conflict is complex, but with expert advice your chances can be realistically assessed. Do not be discouraged – even though the ruling turned out negatively for the plaintiff, there are cases in which employees can successfully take action against the displacement of their collective agreement.

Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.

This article is general information and does not replace individual legal advice. RechtStark is a litigation funder, not a law firm; you are represented by an independent lawyer.