Takeover Demand After Apprenticeship: What the Baden-Württemberg Labor Court Decided

Übernahmeverlangen nach Ausbildung: Was das LAG Baden-Württemberg entschieden hat

The takeover demand after apprenticeship is a critical step for trainees in the Youth and Trainee Representatives (JAV). A recent ruling by the Baden-Württemberg Higher Labor Court (Landesarbeitsgericht) shows how easily one can fall into a trap. The case involved an industrial mechanic trainee who was the deputy chair of the JAV – and yet lost in court. We explain the background and give practical tips.

What Was the Ruling About? The Case of the JAV Member from Baden-Württemberg

The plaintiff began an apprenticeship as an industrial mechanic at a company in Baden-Württemberg in September 2022. The training period was set at 42 months. In February 2025, a Youth and Trainee Representatives (JAV) was elected for the first time – the plaintiff became deputy chair.

Even before his final examination, he informally asked the HR department several times whether he would be taken on. However, he did not indicate that he was a JAV member. The responses remained vague: the inquiry would be forwarded, and an employment contract could only be presented after successful completion of the apprenticeship.

On July 2, 2025, the plaintiff passed the IHK technical discussion as the final part of his final examination. He received a certificate confirming the passed examination result on the same day. Yet no employment contract materialized. The plaintiff sued for the establishment of a permanent employment relationship – without success. The Heilbronn Labor Court (Arbeitsgericht) dismissed the action, and the Baden-Württemberg Higher Labor Court (Landesarbeitsgericht) confirmed this with its judgment of September 10, 2026 (Ref. 3 Sa 3/26).

When Does the Vocational Training Relationship End? The Legal Situation Under Section 21 BBiG

The central point of dispute was the question of when the vocational training relationship ends. Under Section 21(2) of the Vocational Training Act (BBiG), the training relationship ends upon expiry of the training period – but if the final examination is passed, it ends already upon notification of the examination result by the examination board.

The Higher Labor Court has now clarified: the notification of the examination result is the decisive moment – not, for example, the end of the day on which the notification occurs. This means: anyone who passes their examination on July 2 and receives the result on the same day sees their training relationship end on July 2 – not only on July 3 at midnight.

This nuance may seem pedantic at first glance, but it has significant practical consequences – especially for the deadlines of the takeover demand after apprenticeship.

Takeover Demand After Apprenticeship: Requirements and Deadlines

Training relationships of JAV members enjoy special protection. Under Section 78a(1) of the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG), the employer is obliged to take on a trainee who is a member of the Youth and Trainee Representatives into a permanent employment relationship after successful completion of the vocational training – but only if the trainee expressly demands this.

This demand must be made in writing no later than three months before the end of the vocational training relationship under Section 78a(2) sentence 1 BetrVG. The deadline is not a mere formality but a real cut-off period: anyone who misses it loses their claim to takeover.

This is exactly where the problem lay in the decided case. The plaintiff had informally asked about a takeover before the examination, but had not made a formal takeover demand under Section 78a BetrVG – and certainly not in writing and with reference to his JAV membership. The court therefore only had to clarify when the deadline began to run.

Why the Timing of the Examination Result Notification Is So Important

Had the court assumed that the training relationship ends only at the end of the day of notification, the deadline for the takeover demand would have expired one day later. That may sound minor, but in individual cases it can decide between victory and defeat.

The Higher Labor Court opted for the stricter interpretation: the notification of the examination result by the examination board already ends the training relationship. For calculating the three-month period, this means: the takeover demand must have been made in writing three months before the day of notification – i.e., typically on the day of the oral examination or the handing over of the certificate. Anyone who receives their result on July 2 would have had to submit their demand in writing by April 2.

In the specific case, the plaintiff had not submitted his demand in time – nor in the required form. The appeal was therefore dismissed. However, the court allowed an appeal to the Federal Labor Court (Bundesarbeitsgericht), as the question has fundamental significance.

What Does the Ruling Mean for Trainees in the JAV?

For all trainees who are members of the Youth and Trainee Representatives, this ruling is an important signal: the special protection against dismissal under Section 78a BetrVG only applies if you actively and timely submit the takeover demand. It is not enough to hope for a takeover or only ask orally.

The three-month deadline before the end of the training relationship is non-negotiable. You should therefore familiarize yourself with the formalities early on – ideally at the beginning of the final training year. If you are unsure, you should consult a specialist lawyer for labor law in good time. Should a legal dispute arise, a litigation funder like RechtStark can cover the costs – RechtStark itself is not a law firm and does not provide representation in court.

If the employer rejects or ignores the takeover demand, an action for protection against dismissal may be the right solution. You can find the basics on our overview page.

Practical Tips: How to Secure Your Rights After Passing the Examination

To prevent the same thing happening to you as the plaintiff from Baden-Württemberg, you should observe the following points:

  • Submit your takeover demand in writing – no later than three months before the expected end of your apprenticeship. The safest approach is to formulate the demand at the beginning of the final training year.
  • Expressly refer to your JAV membership. Only then does the special protection of Section 78a BetrVG apply. A general „I would like to be taken on“ is not sufficient.
  • Document the timing of your examination result notification. Keep the IHK or examination board certificate carefully – it is the decisive evidence for the start of the deadline.
  • React immediately if the employer does not respond. Do not let yourself be put off with vague statements. Insist on a written declaration.
  • Obtain legal advice early. The costs for a lawyer can sometimes be reimbursed – for example through legal expenses insurance or legal aid. A litigation funder can also step in.

A takeover demand after apprenticeship is not a formality but a real declaration of intent. Anyone who does not submit it in time and in the correct form loses their statutory claim – the present case illustrates this impressively.

Conclusion: The Core Statement of the LAG Baden-Württemberg at a Glance

The Baden-Württemberg Higher Labor Court made an important clarification with its judgment of September 10, 2026: a vocational training relationship ends with the notification of the examination result – not only at the end of the day. For JAV members, this means that their takeover demand after apprenticeship must be declared in writing no later than three months before this point in time.

Anyone who misses this deadline has no claim to takeover – not even with the argument that they had asked orally. The case shows how important it is to inform yourself about your rights early on and to seek professional support in case of doubt. A specialist lawyer for labor law can help initiate the right steps – and a litigation funder like RechtStark can cushion the financial hurdle of a lawsuit.

Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.

This article is general information and does not replace individual legal advice. RechtStark is a litigation funder, not a law firm; you are represented by an independent lawyer.