Company Pension Back Payment: What the LAG Hamm Ruling Means for You

If you are seeking a company pension back payment, you should know the ruling of the Higher Labor Court (LAG) Hamm. It shows how a former chief legal counsel of a savings bank enforced a back payment of over €8,500. The court ordered the employer not only to pay arrears but also to permanently increase the monthly pension. The ruling is an important signal for anyone drawing a company pension or preparing for retirement.
What Happened: LAG Hamm Strengthens Pensioners‘ Rights
The plaintiff worked as chief legal counsel for a savings bank from May 1997 to July 2021. His service contract, last amended in June 2019, governed not only his salary but also his future company pension. After retirement, however, the savings bank paid less pension than the plaintiff considered correct. He filed suit at the Labor Court Münster and later appealed to the Higher Labor Court Hamm.
The LAG Hamm largely ruled in the plaintiff’s favor. It ordered the savings bank to pay arrears of €8,558.20 gross — for the period from March 2024 to August 2026. In addition, the employer must pay €295.89 more per month from September 2026 than before. This raises the ongoing pension from €15,099.14 to €15,394.03 gross per month. The court also clarified how future adjustments are to be calculated.
The Background: How the Pensionable Reference Amount Is Calculated
The dispute centered on how the „pensionable reference income“ is determined. In many service contracts, especially for executives, the company pension is linked to salary. If the salary changes, the pension should adjust accordingly. In this case, the contract provided that the base amount would be adjusted in line with linear changes in the remuneration of the savings bank’s employees.
The plaintiff argued that the adjustment had to follow a specific method described in Section 6(2)(2) of the service contract. The savings bank, by contrast, wanted to apply a different calculation method that resulted in a lower pension. The LAG Hamm held that the contractually agreed method is decisive. It ruled that the change in the pensionable reference amount for future linear changes in the remuneration of savings bank employees follows the method described in Section 6(2)(2).
The Decision in Detail: Back Payment and Ongoing Increase
The ruling contains several elements: First, the court awarded the plaintiff a back payment of €8,558.20 gross. This consists of monthly differences accrued between March 2024 and August 2026. The monthly amounts increased over time: initially €279.45, then €287.83, and finally €295.89. In addition, the savings bank must pay interest on the respective amounts — 5 percentage points above the base rate.
From September 2026, the employer must pay €295.89 more per month than before. The court also clarified how future adjustments are to be calculated. This gives the plaintiff planning certainty. Leave to appeal was not granted, so the ruling is final.
Why the Ruling Matters for You: Enforcing Your Company Pension Back Payment
Many employees trust that their employer calculates the company pension correctly. Yet as this case shows, even large institutions can make mistakes. The company pension is a key pillar of retirement provision — especially for executives who often depend on a substantial portion of their income. The ruling makes clear: it pays to review your company pension regularly. Particularly if your employment contract or a pension scheme contains complex calculation formulas, you should check the statements carefully. Adjustments are often not made correctly, for example because the employer applies a different calculation method than contractually agreed. Especially for executives with high incomes, a gap can quickly amount to several thousand euros — similar to the severance pay gap that affects many top earners.
If you suspect your company pension is too low, you should act. First, you can request a detailed breakdown from your employer. If they do not respond, a lawsuit before the labor court may be necessary. The chances of success are often good when the contract is clear — as the LAG Hamm ruling demonstrates.
Typical Errors in Company Pension Calculations
In practice, errors in company pension calculations occur repeatedly. These include:
- Incorrect application of adjustment clauses: Many contracts provide that the pension changes with salary. Often a different reference figure is used than agreed.
- Failure to account for collective bargaining increases: If the contract refers to tariff changes, these must actually be factored in.
- Errors in calculating the pensionable income: Not all salary components are correctly included.
- Limitation periods: Claims to company pension can become time-barred. It is important to act in time.
If you suspect such an error, do not hesitate to seek expert advice. A specialist lawyer for labor law can review your documents and assess whether a lawsuit is worthwhile. The costs of an unfair dismissal lawsuit are often lower than the potential back payment. Similar disputes can also arise with special payments subject to repayment clauses — a ruling by the LAG Bremen shows what to watch for. More in our article special payment with repayment clause.
Company Pension Back Payment: How to Proceed
If you find that your company pension is too low, you should proceed systematically:
- Gather all relevant documents: your employment contract, pension schemes, payslips, and pension statements.
- Compare the calculation with the contractual provisions. Check in particular whether adjustments were made correctly.
- Request a detailed breakdown of the calculation from your employer. This often clarifies whether an error exists.
- If the employer does not respond or rejects the claim, seek legal assistance. A specialist lawyer for labor law can assess the prospects of success.
- Observe limitation periods. Claims can become time-barred if you wait too long.
A lawsuit before the labor court is often the last resort, but as the LAG Hamm ruling shows, it can be worthwhile. The costs of such proceedings can be discussed with a lawyer in advance. In some cases, legal expenses insurance covers the costs, or you can apply for legal aid. Current labor law reforms may also affect your claims — it pays to stay informed.
The question often arises: Must the employer pay back the company pension? The answer depends on the contractual agreements. If the contract specifies a clear calculation method, you have good chances of enforcing it.
Conclusion: What Employees Can Take from the Ruling
The ruling of the Higher Labor Court Hamm is good news for everyone drawing a company pension. It shows that employers cannot simply change the calculation method when the contract provides otherwise. Those who know their rights and take action can often enforce back payments and higher ongoing benefits. If you are pursuing a company pension back payment, do not hesitate to have your claims reviewed.
At the same time, the case illustrates how complex company pension calculations can be. Especially for executives with individual contracts, a thorough review is worthwhile. If you are unsure whether your company pension is calculated correctly, seek professional support. A specialist lawyer for labor law can help you enforce your claims — and the ruling shows the effort can pay off.
Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.


