Special Payment with Repayment Clause: What the LAG Bremen Decided

Sonderzahlung mit Rückzahlungsklausel: Was das LAG Bremen entschieden hat – sonderzahlung-mit-rueckzahlungsklausel

A special payment with a repayment clause can turn out to be worthless if repayment is certain — that is what the Higher Labor Court of Bremen (LAG Bremen) decided in a recent ruling. The case involved a maintenance technician in temporary agency work whose employment relationship ended when the fixed term expired. He claimed the collectively agreed annual special payment but was met with an important limitation in court.

What the LAG Bremen Ruling Means

The Higher Labor Court of Bremen (Ref. 1 SLa 26/26) held that an employee cannot demand payment of an annual special payment if they would have to repay it immediately due to a valid repayment clause. At first glance this sounds contradictory, but it follows a long-standing legal principle: no one should be allowed to assert a claim if they would have to return what they received right away. The courts refer to this as the dolo agit defense, derived from the principle of good faith in Section 242 of the German Civil Code (BGB).

Concretely, this means: while a claim to a special payment exists in principle, if a repayment clause applies that obliges the employee to immediate repayment, the payment would be economically pointless. The employee could only keep the money briefly before having to transfer it back. In such a case, asserting the claim constitutes an abuse of rights. The court dismissed the plaintiff’s appeal and did not grant leave to appeal to the Federal Labor Court.

The Case: Maintenance Technician in Temporary Agency Work

The plaintiff was employed as a maintenance technician by a personnel service provider from March 7, 2024, to December 19, 2025. The company hires out its employees to client companies under the German Temporary Employment Act (AÜG). The employment relationship ended because the agreed fixed term expired. The plaintiff had been a member of the IG Metall trade union since September 1, 2024. The Collective Framework Agreement for Temporary Agency Work (MTV Zeitarbeit) applied, as both parties were bound by collective agreements.

Section 15 of this collective agreement provides that employees are entitled to annual special payments — specifically additional vacation pay and Christmas bonus — after six months of uninterrupted service. The Christmas bonus is paid with the November payroll. However, the collective agreement contains a repayment clause: anyone who leaves the company before March 31 of the following year must repay the Christmas bonus — unless they leave due to an employer-initiated termination for urgent operational reasons.

The plaintiff did not leave due to termination but because the fixed term expired. He would therefore have been obliged to repay. The Labor Court Bremen-Bremerhaven (Ref. 1 Ca 1013/26) and later the Higher Labor Court Bremen saw this as an obstacle to the payment claim. The plaintiff’s appeal was dismissed.

Special Payment with Repayment Clause: When Is It Valid?

Repayment clauses appear in many employment contracts and collective agreements, particularly for special payments such as Christmas bonuses or vacation pay. They are not automatically invalid. Case law requires them to be fairly structured. A repayment clause is generally valid if it is tied to a specific event — for example, leaving within a certain period — and if the retention period is reasonable.

For Christmas bonuses paid as an additional benefit, retention periods until March 31 of the following year are common and usually permissible. What matters is that the clause is clear and understandable. In the present case, the court apparently assumed a valid clause — otherwise it would not have let the claim fail on the dolo agit defense.

The Role of the Collective Agreement: What Does the MTV Zeitarbeit Say?

The repayment clause here was not in the individual employment contract but in the Collective Framework Agreement for Temporary Agency Work (MTV Zeitarbeit). This collective agreement was concluded between the Federal Employers‘ Association of Personnel Service Providers (BAP) and the DGB trade unions, including IG Metall. Collective agreements have special effect: they apply directly and bindingly to members of the collective bargaining parties.

Since both the employee and the personnel service provider were bound by the collective agreement, the court had to interpret the MTV Zeitarbeit. It concluded that the expiry of a fixed term is not among the exceptions that prevent repayment of the Christmas bonus. The wording mentions only employer-initiated termination for urgent operational reasons. Anyone who leaves due to a fixed term therefore falls under the repayment obligation.

Why Employees Should Still Have Their Claims Reviewed

The ruling does not mean that special payments are automatically worthless just because a repayment clause exists. The outcome depends heavily on the individual case. A repayment clause can be invalid if it unreasonably disadvantages the employee. The dolo agit defense only applies if the repayment obligation is certain and immediate. If there are doubts about the clause’s validity, the claim may well be enforceable.

It is also worth examining how the employment relationship ended. Anyone who believes the fixed term was invalid can challenge it. In that case, the employment relationship might not have ended, and the repayment clause would not apply. An overview of the options is provided in our guide to unfair dismissal claims. Although this case did not involve a classic dismissal, the basics regarding deadlines and procedures are similar.

Even where a special payment with a repayment clause is at issue, exceptions may exist that make the claim enforceable. The rule remains: have your claims reviewed by a specialist lawyer for employment law before you waive them or file a lawsuit. Even though leave to appeal was not granted, the decision shows how courts currently handle such clauses.

Practical Tips: How to Protect Your Special Payments in Time

Not every special payment is the same. The decisive factors are the exact provisions in your employment contract and the applicable collective agreement. Keep these points in mind:

  • Check your employment contract and the applicable collective agreement for repayment clauses. Pay particular attention to deadlines such as March 31.
  • If you are asked to sign a termination agreement, clarify beforehand whether special payments are at risk. A possible severance payment also plays a role — our guide severance after dismissal explains the basics.
  • Document all agreements and payments. Keep pay slips and contract documents.
  • If you have received a special payment and later leave, check whether the repayment clause is actually valid. An unreasonable clause can be invalid.
  • Check whether a special payment repayment clause is regulated in your contract or collective agreement before you plan a job change or termination. Seek legal advice early.

Conclusion: What You Can Learn from the Ruling for Your Employment Contract

The LAG Bremen ruling shows: a special payment linked to a repayment clause is not automatically a voluntary bonus you are allowed to keep. If you leave before the deadline, the money can be reclaimed. And if repayment is certain, you cannot even sue for payment.

For employees, this means: read the contractual conditions carefully and plan your job change with care. If you are unsure whether a clause is valid or an exception applies, consult an employment law firm. The costs of proceedings can, under certain circumstances, be covered by a litigation funder like RechtStark — but the decision for or against a lawsuit is always made together with your lawyer.

Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.

This article is general information and does not replace individual legal advice. RechtStark is a litigation funder, not a law firm; you are represented by an independent lawyer.