Lost Variable Compensation After Project Removal: What the Hessian LAG Decided

Entgangene variable Vergütung bei Projektabzug: Was das LAG Hessen entschieden hat – entgangene-variable-verguetung

The Hessian Regional Labor Court (LAG Hessen) ruled that an employee has no claim for lost variable compensation when the employer removes them from a project but continues paying their base salary. This decision carries significant weight for many employees with bonus agreements, since project reassignments are routine across numerous industries.

In the underlying case, a consultant at a management consultancy earned a base salary of €5,000 gross per month plus an annual bonus of approximately €27,934 in 2024. After being pulled from a project where he could have earned additional bonus entitlements, he claimed the forgone pay as damages. The Frankfurt Labor Court initially awarded him partial relief, but the Regional Labor Court dismissed the claim in full.

The Hessian LAG Ruling: Project Removal Without Bonus Entitlement

The claimant worked as a consultant and later as a senior consultant. His employment contract provided for variable compensation tied to specific client projects. When the employer reassigned him to different tasks without releasing him from work duties, he sought the compensation he would have earned on the original project.

The Regional Labor Court clarified: as long as the employer pays the base salary and continues to employ the worker, no claim for lost variable compensation arises. The employer does not fall into acceptance delay by assigning different tasks, even if those tasks trigger no bonus entitlements. The decisive factor is that the employee offers their labor and the employer accepts it — just on a different project.

When Does a Claim for Lost Variable Compensation Arise?

A claim for lost variable compensation presupposes that the employer refuses the tendered labor and thereby falls into acceptance delay. This occurs, for example, when the employee is released from duties or the employer assigns no work at all. In such cases, the employer must continue paying the agreed compensation under § 615 BGB — but only the base salary, not automatically variable components tied to specific projects.

Variable compensation is typically linked to targets or projects. Whether a bonus remains due after a project reassignment depends on the contractual arrangement. If the employment contract contains no provision guaranteeing the bonus independently of the concrete project assignment, the employee bears the risk that a different task allocation yields no variable pay. The court emphasized that it did not matter whether the employer’s instruction met the requirements of § 106 of the German Trade Regulation Act.

Why the Court Found No Claim Under §§ 611a, 615 BGB: Acceptance Delay and Compensation Risk

Acceptance delay under § 615 BGB requires that the employee offers their labor and the employer refuses it. Here, the employer had not released the employee but merely assigned different tasks. The employer therefore accepted the labor — the employee was not forced into idleness. Consequently, no acceptance delay occurred, and no claim for lost variable compensation existed.

The compensation risk for variable components rests with the employee as long as the employer acts within their managerial authority. Only if the employer actually releases the employee or fails to pay the base salary can other claims arise. For more on acceptance delay in the context of dismissals, see our article Employment During Proceedings After Dismissal.

Procedural Pitfall: Cross-Appeal — What Employees Must Know When a Claim Is Decided Incorrectly

A particular stumbling block emerged in this case from an error by the Labor Court. That court had awarded acceptance-delay wages even though the claimant had sought damages for lost variable compensation. The Regional Labor Court noted that the claimant should have filed a cross-appeal to pursue his damages claim further. Because he did not, the court could not rule on the damages claim.

A cross-appeal is a procedural tool allowing an appellee to challenge the labor court’s judgment even if they did not file the main appeal. It must be lodged within the deadline for responding to the appeal. Missing this deadline risks leaving an erroneous judgment in place or having the entire claim dismissed.

If you intend to sue for lost variable compensation, you must ensure your claim petition precisely covers that demand — not merely acceptance-delay wages. Otherwise, the court may rule on a different claim and your actual entitlement may be lost. In such situations, consulting a specialist lawyer for employment law is strongly advised to avoid procedural mistakes.

Practical Tips: Safeguarding Your Bonus Entitlements After a Project Reassignment

Concrete recommendations follow from this ruling. If you receive variable compensation, first check whether your employment contract or a works agreement contains detailed rules on bonus prerequisites. Often these specify the conditions for payment — for instance, achieving certain targets or completing a project.

If you are pulled from a project, document the reassignment in writing. Ask your employer how the move affects your bonus entitlements. Obtain written confirmation, if possible, that the bonus will still be paid. Without such assurance, your position in a dispute is often weak.

Also check whether your contract includes a „project clause“ binding the bonus to specific projects. If so, seek legal advice early before waiving any bonus claim. A specialist lawyer for employment law can assess whether your claim is enforceable. Just as with negotiating a severance package, thorough preparation is decisive — tips are available in our article Preparing for Severance Negotiations.

If you decide to file suit, ensure you plead the correct claim. Demand the bonus explicitly as damages, not merely as acceptance-delay wages. Otherwise, you risk the court deciding on a different claim and your actual entitlement lapsing.

Limits of the Ruling: When a Claim for Forgone Compensation May Still Exist

The judgment does not mean employees lose out in every case. If the employer actually releases the employee — assigning no work at all — acceptance delay may arise. The employer must then continue paying the base salary, and variable components may also be due if they are contractually guaranteed.

Claims may also exist if the employer fails to pay the base salary or unlawfully prevents the employee from working. The decisive factor is always the specific contractual design. Anyone with a bonus agreement should examine whether the bonus is tied to particular projects or payable regardless of task assignment.

Moreover, a damages claim may arise if the employer acts intentionally or with gross negligence, for instance to circumvent the bonus. The court did not address this, but such scenarios are conceivable.

Conclusion: What Employees with Variable Compensation Should Take From This Ruling

The Hessian Regional Labor Court’s decision makes clear that employees with variable compensation bear substantial risk when removed from a project. As long as the employer pays the base salary and continues to employ the worker, there is generally no claim for the forgone variable pay. Anyone wishing to enforce such claims must secure them contractually. For an overview of possible severance entitlements after dismissal, we recommend our guide Severance After Dismissal.

If you are affected by a project reassignment, seek legal advice early. A specialist lawyer for employment law can review whether your bonus claim is contractually protected and what steps make sense. Litigation funding can also be an option to limit the cost risk of a lawsuit. RechtStark, as a litigation funder, assesses whether funding is possible — legal advice is always provided by an independent lawyer.

Ultimately, the ruling shows: without clear contractual provisions, employees often come up short when project reassignments affect lost variable compensation. Secure your bonus entitlements early and ensure professional representation in any dispute.

Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.

This article is general information and does not replace individual legal advice. RechtStark is a litigation funder, not a law firm; you are represented by an independent lawyer.