Termination for Economic Reasons: What the LAG Ruling Means for You

A termination for economic reasons comes as a shock to many employees – yet sometimes it is effective. The Higher Labor Court (LAG) of Rhineland-Palatinate has ruled in a recent decision that an extraordinary termination of a division head on purely economic grounds can be lawful. The case illustrates the standards courts apply when assessing proof of economic hardship and what executives can learn from it.
The plaintiff, born in 1986, married with three children, had been employed as a Business Unit Manager since January 2023. His compensation amounted to approximately €10,800 gross per month. The employment contract stipulated an extended notice period of six months to the end of the month – a typical arrangement for senior executives. In light of a significantly deteriorated order situation – instead of the planned €58.3 million in net revenue, less than €40 million was expected – the employer initiated restructuring measures. An agreement on reconciliation of interests and a social plan were concluded with the works council. The company then terminated the senior executive extraordinarily with a run-out period. The Labor Court of Ludwigshafen initially upheld the action for protection against dismissal, but the LAG reversed the judgment on the employer’s appeal and dismissed the action.
Termination for Economic Reasons: When Is There Good Cause?
Under Section 626(1) of the German Civil Code (BGB), an employment relationship may be terminated for good cause without observing a notice period if circumstances exist which, taking into account all the circumstances of the individual case and weighing the interests of both parties, make it unreasonable to continue the employment relationship until the expiry of the notice period. This extraordinary termination is commonly associated with employee misconduct, such as criminal offenses or gross breaches of duty. However, purely economic reasons can also constitute good cause.
Case law recognizes that an extraordinary termination for operational reasons may be permissible if the employer faces a serious economic hardship and continued employment of the employee until the end of the ordinary notice period is unreasonable. The employer must substantiate and prove this unreasonableness. A mere reference to a poor order situation is insufficient. Rather, concrete figures, a comprehensible forecast, and an explanation of the impact on operations are required.
In the present case, the company had documented the economic difficulties in detail: Net revenue for 2024 was projected to fall from the originally expected €58.3 million to under €40 million – a decline of around 20 percent compared to the previous year. These figures were presented to the works council in several meetings and substantiated by business records. The LAG considered this a sufficient basis for assuming economic hardship.
Operational Termination Without Observing the Notice Period? – The LAG’s Reasoning
The Higher Labor Court of Rhineland-Palatinate clarified in its decision that an extraordinary termination of a division head for economic reasons can be effective if the employer cannot reasonably be expected to continue the employment relationship until the end of the ordinary notice period. The decisive factor was that the company’s economic hardship was so severe that even the extended notice period of six months posed no obstacle. The court upheld the termination for economic reasons because the financial losses were so substantial that continued employment until the end of the period appeared unreasonable.
Remarkably, the court confirmed the extraordinary termination despite the long notice period. The extended period, which is actually intended to protect the employee, was not regarded as protection here. The LAG argued that the economic hardship was so serious that continued employment until the end of the period would have led to an unreasonable financial burden. This judgment is an important signal for executives who often rely on long notice periods – in economic crises, these periods can become ineffective.
However, the court emphasized that such a termination is only considered in exceptional cases. The employer must be able to substantiate and prove the hardship. In this case, the company had documented the revenue figures, the development of the order situation, and the resulting measures in detail and presented them to the works council. Without this evidence, the termination would most likely not have withstood judicial review.
Reconciliation of Interests and Social Plan: How They Secure the Termination
An important aspect in this case was the conclusion of a reconciliation of interests and a social plan with the works council in December 2024. These instruments under the Works Constitution Act (Sections 111 et seq. BetrVG) serve to make operational terminations socially acceptable and to mitigate the economic consequences for affected employees. The reconciliation of interests documents which operational measures are planned – such as the elimination of positions or the closure of departments. The social plan regulates financial compensation payments, such as severance packages or qualification measures.
In this case, the works council had acknowledged the company’s economic emergency and agreed to the measures. This significantly strengthened the employer’s position, as it demonstrated that the economic hardship was not merely claimed but confirmed by independent internal bodies. For employees, it is important to know: A reconciliation of interests and a social plan are no guarantee that a termination is lawful. They can, however, be a strong indication that the employer has seriously examined and documented the operational reasons. If such an agreement is missing, employers must prove the economic hardship by other means – which is often more difficult.
If you yourself are affected by an operational termination, you should check whether your employer has concluded a reconciliation of interests and a social plan with the works council. These documents can give you insight into whether the economic reasons actually exist or whether the termination is vulnerable. A severance package in case of operational termination is an important negotiation topic in this context – however, it is not a guaranteed entitlement but depends on the circumstances of the individual case.
What Does the Ruling Mean for Executives and Senior Employees?
For executives and senior employees, this ruling has particular significance. They often have longer notice periods than other employees – in this case, six months to the end of the month. These periods are intended to provide them with a degree of security, yet the LAG shows that they do not always protect in situations of economic hardship. If a company falls into serious economic distress, executives can also be affected by an extraordinary termination – even if their position is not directly eliminated, but the economic situation of the entire operation makes continued employment unreasonable.
Senior employees often enjoy a special status under works constitution law, but they are not automatically better protected against termination. The ruling shows that they should not rely solely on their contractual notice periods. Anyone working in an economically troubled company should review their options early – for example, by negotiating a severance package after termination or searching for a new position. A specialist lawyer for employment law can help realistically assess your own rights and evaluate the prospects of success of an action for protection against dismissal.
Executives often have particular negotiating leverage when it comes to severance packages. A severance payment is, however, not an automatic entitlement – it must be negotiated. The LAG ruling shows that employers in economic distress may be more willing to pay a severance package if it avoids protracted court proceedings. Nevertheless, you should not allow yourself to be pressured: Even in a difficult economic situation for the company, the termination must be formally correct and the economic hardship must actually exist.
Your Rights in an Extraordinary Termination: What You Should Do
If you receive a termination for economic reasons, swift action is required. The most important deadline is the three-week period for filing an action for protection against dismissal under Section 4 KSchG. If you miss this deadline, the termination is deemed effective from the outset – even if it was substantively unfounded. Also check whether the termination was issued in writing and contains a justification. In the case of an extraordinary termination, the employer must communicate the reasons upon request.
Such a termination is rare and subject to high hurdles. An experienced employment lawyer can assess whether the employer’s economic hardship is actually sufficient or whether the termination is vulnerable. If you are unsure whether you can afford litigation, RechtStark as a litigation funder will examine whether it can cover the costs – allowing you to limit your risk. Bear in mind: Even if the termination is effective, you can negotiate a severance package as part of a settlement. The amount depends on factors such as length of service, age, and the company’s economic situation – a severance package is, however, not a guaranteed entitlement but a matter of negotiation.
Do not rely on verbal assurances; insist on written documentation of all agreements. If the employer offers you a termination agreement, examine the terms carefully – you can often negotiate a higher severance package than initially offered. A specialist lawyer for employment law can support you in this and ensure that you do not miss any deadlines.
Conclusion: When Is a Summary Dismissal for Economic Reasons Permissible?
The ruling of the LAG Rhineland-Palatinate makes clear: A termination for economic reasons can also be effective as an extraordinary termination if the employer can prove a serious hardship. The requirements are high – the employer must present concrete figures and facts demonstrating that continued employment until the end of the notice period is unreasonable. A reconciliation of interests and a social plan can serve as strong evidence of the economic hardship.
For employees, especially executives, this means: Long notice periods are not absolute protection. Anyone working in an economically troubled company should inform themselves and seek advice early. At the same time: Even if an extraordinary termination for economic reasons can be effective, it must always be examined on a case-by-case basis – many terminations do not withstand judicial scrutiny because the employer cannot sufficiently substantiate the hardship. If you receive such a termination, act quickly: Secure the three-week deadline, request the justification in writing, and consult a specialist lawyer for employment law. Only then can you effectively enforce your rights – and, if applicable, negotiate a fair severance package.
Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.


