Company Pension Adjustment: What the LAG Düsseldorf Ruling Means for You

Betriebsrentenanpassung: Was das LAG Düsseldorf-Urteil für Sie bedeutet

The company pension adjustment is a mystery to many pensioners – until the monthly payment suddenly turns out differently than expected. A ruling by the Düsseldorf Higher Labour Court (LAG) dated 23 September 2026 (Ref. 12 SLa 391/26) now shows the conditions under which collective bargaining parties may change an existing adjustment rule in a collective bargaining pension scheme and when a company pension adjustment is permissible.

The plaintiff was a former employee of a state-independent supervisory authority for private broadcasting and telemedia. He received a company pension governed by a collective bargaining pension scheme. When the collective bargaining parties changed the adjustment rule effective 1 July 2024, his company pension turned out lower than he had expected under the old rule. The claimant sued at the Düsseldorf Labour Court, then appealed to the Higher Labour Court – and lost in both instances.

The Ruling at a Glance: What Was at Issue?

The case concerns a typical constellation in occupational pension provision: a collective bargaining pension scheme promises employees a company pension whose amount is linked to the development of collectively agreed basic pay. When active employees‘ salaries rise, the company pensions are meant to grow as well. This dynamic is a key reason for many employees to agree to occupational pension provision in the first place.

Precisely this linkage was changed selectively by the collective bargaining parties in the dispute. As of the reference date 1 July 2024, both basic pay and company pensions were increased by at least 1.5 per cent. Active employees received an additional increase of 3.0 per cent – but only because their weekly working hours were raised by 0.5 per cent, or 0.4 per cent adjusted for special factors. Pensioners were excluded from this additional increase.

The claimant saw this as unjustified disadvantage and demanded a higher company pension. The Düsseldorf Labour Court dismissed the action (Ref. 7 Ca 6042/25), and the Düsseldorf Higher Labour Court upheld this decision. However, leave to appeal to the Federal Labour Court was granted – the ruling is therefore not yet final.

What Does the Collective Bargaining Pension Scheme Provide?

Collective bargaining pension schemes regulate occupational pension provision for entire sectors or individual companies. They determine who receives a company pension, how it is calculated, and how it develops over time. In many cases they contain a so-called dynamic adjustment rule: the pensionable earnings – i.e. the earnings on which the pension calculation is based – change in the same proportion as the collectively agreed basic pay.

For example: if the pension scheme provides that pensionable earnings rise by the same percentage as basic pay at every collectively agreed increase, a pensioner automatically benefits from every pay rise of active employees. If the collective bargaining parties change this rule, the pension may in future lag behind salary development.

This linkage has a practical advantage: pensioners do not have to demand an adjustment review under Section 16 BetrAVG every three years, but benefit automatically from collectively agreed increases. It has a downside, though: when the collective bargaining parties make a company pension adjustment, the dynamic can weaken or disappear entirely. That is exactly what happened here – the adjustment rule was not abolished, but modified for a single reference date.

Why the Change Was Permissible: The Material Reason

The first guiding principle of the ruling sounds strict: even a minor change to such an adjustment rule requires a material reason. Collective bargaining parties cannot simply intervene in existing pension schemes at will. They must be able to explain convincingly why they are changing the rule.

The Higher Labour Court found such a material reason here. Decisive was the link between working hours and pay: active employees received the additional 3.0 per cent pay increase not as a gift, but as compensation for longer weekly working hours. Pensioners no longer work – they could therefore be excluded from this specific increase.

Also relevant was the selective nature of the change: it referred to a single reference date, 1 July 2024. It was not a permanent abolition of the dynamic, but a one-off modification. That too spoke in favour of permissibility in the court’s view.

Laypeople may ask why such a change needs justification at all if the collective bargaining parties created the rule themselves. The answer lies in protection of legitimate expectations: anyone who has paid into an occupational pension scheme for decades may trust that promised benefits will not be reduced without further ado. That is why courts require a material reason for every company pension adjustment – which existed in this dispute.

Legislative Freedom of Collective Bargaining Parties: Limits and Scope

The ruling simultaneously confirms the broad legislative freedom of collective bargaining parties. It is anchored in Article 9(3) of the Basic Law and includes the right to change existing rules. Courts intervene only if a rule is obviously unsachlich or arbitrary – for instance if it disadvantages certain groups without material reason.

The claimant made precisely this accusation: he argued that the working-hours increase and the additional pay increase were not equivalent. Active employees would therefore be better off than pensioners. The Higher Labour Court rejected this argument. Lack of equivalence alone does not make a rule arbitrary. Collective bargaining parties may strike compromises that do not add up mathematically in every respect.

Tariff arbitrariness exists only when a rule lacks any factual basis and can be explained solely as targeted discrimination against certain groups. Courts set high hurdles for this. As long as collective bargaining parties can plausibly explain why they adopted a rule, courts accept their decision.

This line of case law is sobering for employees but legally consistent: as long as a material reason is discernible and no group is arbitrarily disadvantaged, collective bargaining parties retain wide scope. A lawsuit therefore has prospects of success only if the change lacks any factual basis whatsoever.

What the Ruling Means for Your Company Pension Adjustment

Many factors interact here: the wording of the pension scheme, the collective bargaining history, the employer’s economic situation, and not least the case law. The Düsseldorf ruling shows that not every change to your disadvantage is automatically challengeable.

If you notice a company pension adjustment, you should first check whether the change is based on a collective agreement and whether a material reason is discernible. Ask your former employer in writing for the specific rule and its justification. Often the collective bargaining history alone reveals whether the change follows a factual logic or withdraws benefits from a specific group in a targeted manner.

A comparison with active employees can help: if they receive a significantly higher increase without their working hours changing, that argues against a material reason. If they receive the compensation for additional workload, however, the exclusion of pensioners may well be permissible – as in the present case.

Also important is the specific design: if it is a one-off, selective change for a specific reference date, the hurdle for permissibility is lower than if the dynamic is abolished permanently. A company pension adjustment that permanently decouples pensioners from collectively agreed increases would probably have to meet stricter standards in court.

Legal Advice: When Should You Instruct a Specialist Lawyer?

Company pension disputes are legally demanding. They involve collective agreements, pension schemes, equal treatment principles, and often substantial sums over many years. A wrong assessment can be costly – especially if you pursue a lawsuit without prospects of success.

You should instruct an independent specialist lawyer for employment law if:

  • your company pension is reduced or adjusted differently than the pension scheme provides,
  • you consider a change to the adjustment rule arbitrary,
  • the employer refuses a written justification, or
  • you are considering a lawsuit before the labour court.

Unlike a action for unfair dismissal, company pension disputes are not about keeping your job but about the level of your pension provision. Here too, however, deadlines are decisive. Claims from occupational pension provision can become time-barred. Seek advice early to safeguard your rights.

Since labour court proceedings involve costs for lawyers and court, litigation funding can be useful. A litigation funder like RechtStark assesses whether your case has sufficient prospects of success and, if successful, covers the costs of the proceedings. This lets you enforce your right without financial risk. Similar to a action for unfair dismissal without cost risk, the cost risk can also be limited in company pension disputes.

Whether a lawsuit has prospects of success depends on many factors – comparable to the prospects of success in an action for unfair dismissal. Always have your chances assessed by a specialist lawyer before suing.

Conclusion: Your Rights When Company Pensions Are Changed

The Düsseldorf Higher Labour Court ruling is an important guide for everyone receiving a company pension. It confirms that collective bargaining parties may change adjustment rules if a material reason exists. At the same time it makes clear that not every change must be accepted: if a material reason is lacking, the change can be invalid.

The company pension adjustment remains a complex field where those affected should not rely on gut feeling alone. Scrutinise every change to your company pension carefully, demand a written justification, and seek legal advice if in doubt. The ruling is not yet final – the claimant can still appeal. It remains to be seen how the Federal Labour Court will ultimately decide the question.

Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.

This article is general information and does not replace individual legal advice. RechtStark is a litigation funder, not a law firm; you are represented by an independent lawyer.