LAG Ruling: Company Car Entitlement for Works Council Members Must Be Precise

The company car entitlement works council members can claim is often unclear – the Higher Labor Court of Mecklenburg-Vorpommern has now clarified what is needed for a successful claim. The ruling of August 11, 2026 (Ref. 2 SLa 47/26) shows: Anyone demanding a specific company car must know exactly what they are asking for – and special rules apply to works council members regarding remuneration.
The Case: Company Car for a Director of Sales – What Was at Stake?
The plaintiff was employed as Director of Sales Port Machinery at a mechanical engineering company and was a member of the works council. His employment contract provided for an annual gross salary of 130,000 euros plus a net rent allowance of 400 euros. He also had an entitlement to a company car for private use, without a specific vehicle class being defined. He demanded a vehicle of the „upper middle class“ and claimed damages for defective performance because he had been provided with a car that was too small. The Labor Court of Rostock dismissed the action, and the Higher Labor Court upheld the decision.
The plaintiff relied on his employment contract, which merely provided for the provision of a company car without further specification. He argued that, as a manager and works council member, he was entitled to an upper-middle-class vehicle. However, the court found no basis for this demand, neither in the contract nor in any company regulation. The damages claim also failed because there was no concrete entitlement to a specific vehicle.
Why „Upper Middle Class“ as a Claim Is Not Sufficient
The Higher Labor Court made it clear: A claim for delivery must identify the items in question as precisely as possible so that they can be identified in enforcement proceedings. The term „upper middle class“ is not sufficiently specific. Without a concrete model designation, it cannot be determined which vehicle the bailiff should demand. Such a claim is therefore indefinite and leads to dismissal.
For practice, this means: Anyone who wants to enforce a specific company car in court must name a concrete model in the claim, for example „BMW 530i“ or „Mercedes E 220 d“. Alternatively, a specific equipment line or a list price can be stated. Only then is the claim sufficiently determined. An indefinite claim usually leads to dismissal without the merits being examined – this case demonstrates that clearly.
Company Car Entitlement Works Council: When Do Employees Have a Right to a Specific Vehicle Model?
A claim to a specific motor vehicle model requires a legal basis. This can be a concrete agreement between the parties in the employment contract or a company regulation, such as a works agreement or a collective commitment. Without such a basis, the employer generally has the right to determine the vehicle model and equipment at reasonable discretion – as long as the vehicle is appropriate.
In the decided case, the employment contract did not specify a concrete vehicle class. The plaintiff could therefore not rely on a specific model series. A mere practice in the company, such as managers always receiving a certain type of car, does not automatically create an entitlement. It depends on the agreement in the individual case.
Anyone who wants a specific company car should record this in the employment contract or in a supplementary agreement. Formulations such as „a vehicle of the luxury class“ or „an estate car with at least 200 hp“ are better than nothing, but still indefinite. The safest approach is to name a specific make and model series. Company guidelines can also help if they are unambiguous.
Works Council Members: Special Rules on Remuneration and the Prohibition of Discrimination
The plaintiff was a works council member and referred to Section 37(4) BetrVG (Works Constitution Act), according to which works council members must receive remuneration comparable to that of comparable employees with career advancement. The prohibition of discrimination under Section 78(2) BetrVG forbids putting works council members at a disadvantage because of their activity. The Higher Labor Court pointed out that Section 78(2) BetrVG in conjunction with Section 611a(2) BGB (Civil Code) can give rise to a direct claim to specific remuneration if the lower remuneration constitutes discrimination because of works council activity. However, the works council member must allege and prove the relevant facts.
In the specific case, the plaintiff could not prove that he was entitled to a larger company car because of his works council activity. There was no company regulation providing for a specific vehicle class for works council members. Comparison with other managers did not help either, because there were no concrete indications of discrimination. For works council members, this means: They have special rights, but must substantiate them concretely. A blanket reference to Section 37(4) BetrVG is not sufficient. Anyone demanding higher remuneration or a better company car should name comparable cases and explain why the discrimination is connected to the works council activity. In this context, trade union activity in the workplace is also a relevant topic, as similar principles apply.
Burden of Pleading and Proof: Who Must Prove What?
The Higher Labor Court emphasized the general principles: Anyone claiming a legal consequence for themselves must allege and, if necessary, prove the facts giving rise to the claim. The opponent must prove the facts that obstruct, extinguish, or suspend the claim. This distribution also applies in labor law and has been confirmed by the Federal Labor Court in constant case law.
In the company car case, the plaintiff had to prove that he was entitled to a specific vehicle – whether from the employment contract, a works agreement, or the prohibition of discrimination. Since he could not substantiate a concrete claim, the action failed. These principles also apply to other labor law disputes, for example in protection against dismissal for managing directors, where managers often face similar problems of proof.
For employees who want to enforce a company car or higher remuneration, this means: They must gather all relevant documents from the outset, such as the employment contract, supplementary agreements, company guidelines, or emails. A comparison with colleagues in similar positions can also be helpful. The more concrete the substantiation, the better the chances in court. A lawyer can help prepare the right arguments.
What Employees Can Learn from the Ruling for Their Own Practice
The ruling is also relevant for employees outside the works council. It shows how important precise formulations are for company car claims. Anyone who counts on a specific car should secure this claim contractually. A mere description such as „upper middle class“ is worthless if a dispute arises. A clearly formulated company car entitlement works council members can rely on creates legal certainty.
Furthermore, the decision illustrates that works council members enjoy special protection regarding remuneration, but also have special duties to substantiate claims. The prohibition of discrimination under Section 78 BetrVG is a strong instrument, but only applies if the discrimination actually occurs because of the works council activity. Anyone who wants to assert this should seek legal advice at an early stage.
For all employees: In case of doubt, one should not risk going to court with indefinite claims. An action for a company car or higher remuneration should be well prepared. If you are unsure whether your company car entitlement works council members can rely on is enforceable, independent legal advice can help. A litigation funder like RechtStark can also assess whether it will assume the cost risk of proceedings – this relieves you financially if the action fails.
Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.


