Return to Office Severance: What Employees Need to Know Now

Abfindung statt Präsenzpflicht: Was Arbeitnehmer jetzt wissen müssen – abfindung-statt-praesenzpflicht

Many employees currently face a return to office severance choice, including at the US company Skydance. The employer asks staff: return to the office or leave with a severance package. What does this mean legally, and what rights do you have in such a situation? This post covers the key points — from classification as a change-of-terms dismissal to a realistic severance benchmark.

What „Office Mandate or Severance“ Means for Employees

When an employer introduces a return-to-office mandate while simultaneously offering a severance package, it usually signals a reorganization of workflows. For the employee, the situation is doubly difficult: it concerns both your professional future and whether the offered severance truly compensates for losing your job. The crucial point: as long as no signed termination agreement exists, the employment relationship continues. Employees should not let themselves be pressured and should first have the legal classification of the offer reviewed.

The announcement „office or severance“ is often intended as leverage. The employer hopes as many staff as possible will leave voluntarily to avoid costly dismissal proceedings. For you as an employee, this means: you have negotiating power as long as you haven’t signed. Do not let yourself be rushed into an immediate decision. Take time to understand the terms and make an informed choice.

Change-of-Terms Dismissal or Termination Agreement: The Legal Classification

The combination of a return-to-office mandate and a severance offer can be structured in different ways. Frequently, the employee is presented with a termination agreement that ends the relationship by mutual consent. In this case there is no dismissal — the employee signs voluntarily. Such an agreement is binding and cannot simply be revoked. That is why every clause should be examined before signing, especially the severance amount and whether further entitlements such as paid-out vacation are included.

The situation differs with a change-of-terms dismissal: the employer terminates the employment relationship while offering to continue it under changed conditions — for example, with a full return-to-office mandate. If you reject the change, the dismissal stands. Here, dismissal protection applies: you can file a protection against dismissal lawsuit to either retain the original conditions or negotiate a higher severance. A certified employment law specialist can correctly classify the situation.

It is important to examine the exact structure of the offer. Sometimes a termination agreement is combined with a change-of-terms dismissal — then you must be especially vigilant. Only a specialist lawyer can tell you whether the offer is legally sound or whether you can challenge it. Do not let the prospect of a quick severance blind you; understand exactly what is being offered.

Must You Accept the Offer? Your Rights and Options

Fundamentally, no one can be forced to sign a termination agreement or accept changed working conditions. Employees have the right to refuse the offer and insist on their existing contract. However, the employer may then issue a redundancy dismissal if it wishes to restructure positions. Whether such a dismissal is socially justified depends, among other things, on the business decision and the social selection process.

Anyone who declines the offer should be aware that the employer generally has the right to change work organization. A general return-to-office mandate can qualify as a permissible exercise of the employer’s right of direction, provided it meets the standard of reasonable discretion. In repeated cases, a warning may follow, and in extreme cases a conduct-related dismissal. That is why advice from a certified employment law specialist is essential before any decision — only then can you assess whether the employer’s offer is legally watertight or whether resistance is worthwhile.

Also consider your personal situation: Do you already have a new job lined up? What is your current salary? How long have you been with the company? These factors influence whether a severance offer is attractive for you. A severance package can make sense if you want to leave anyway or if the office mandate is unreasonable for you — for instance due to a long commute or family obligations. If, however, you depend on the job and see no alternative, you should examine whether you can accept the changed conditions.

Return to Office Severance: What Is a Realistic Benchmark?

The severance amount is often used as bait. A flat statutory entitlement exists only under specific conditions, for example upon dismissal under Section 1a of the Protection Against Dismissal Act (KSchG), provided the employer explicitly references it in the dismissal letter. In practice, many employers use the rule of thumb of half a month’s salary per year of service — but this is only a benchmark for negotiations, not a guarantee. Anyone who accepts a return to office severance should compare the offer with what might be achievable through a protection against dismissal lawsuit. Often, renegotiation is possible.

To determine a realistic benchmark, you should factor in your individual data: length of service, salary, age, and the notice period. Our guide to severance after dismissal provides an overview of the key factors influencing the amount. Especially in a mutual separation, you can often obtain significantly more than the rule of thumb — but only if you are prepared to negotiate and know your position.

Also consider tax aspects: severance payments are subject to income tax and can be heavily taxed. The one-fifth rule can mitigate the tax burden but is not applied automatically. How to optimize your severance for tax purposes is explained in our article on the severance tax trap. A higher gross severance sounds tempting, but after taxes the difference may shrink. Always look at the net amount, not the gross figure.

Pitfalls: Loss of Dismissal Protection and Waiting Periods

A particularly treacherous aspect is the loss of dismissal protection: anyone who signs a termination agreement can no longer challenge the termination later. Financial security through the Federal Employment Agency is also at risk, because signing a termination agreement counts as resigning yourself. This can trigger a waiting period for unemployment benefits. The return to office severance may be tempting, but you should check whether it financially offsets the waiting period.

Another common mistake is overlooking taxes and social security contributions. Severance payments are subject to income tax and can be heavily taxed. The one-fifth rule can mitigate the tax burden but is not applied automatically. How to optimize your severance for tax purposes is explained in our article on the severance tax trap.

You should also check whether the offer includes a release from duties. Anyone released immediately may lose entitlements to pay, vacation, or special payments. Read the contract carefully and have it explained what happens to outstanding vacation days, overtime, and company pension schemes. Only then can you avoid the offer turning into a boomerang later.

When Is a Protection Against Dismissal Lawsuit Worthwhile?

If the employer issues a change-of-terms dismissal or threatens a redundancy dismissal, a protection against dismissal lawsuit can be worthwhile — particularly if the offered severance is significantly lower than what could be achieved in a court settlement. Formal errors such as a flawed social selection or the lack of a proper works council consultation can also render the dismissal invalid. The three-week deadline is critical: a protection against dismissal lawsuit must be filed with the labor court within three weeks of receiving the dismissal. Details on deadlines and procedure are in our guide to the protection against dismissal lawsuit.

Even if you already have a severance offer, a lawsuit can make sense. Pending proceedings often increase pressure on the employer to pay a higher severance. You must, however, weigh that a lawsuit costs time and nerves. A specialist lawyer can assess the prospects and help you decide whether the path is worth it.

Whoever wins a protection against dismissal lawsuit generally gets their job back — unless the employment relationship is ended by a settlement with severance. The settlement is the most common outcome: employers pay severance to avoid continued employment. This settlement payment can be substantially higher than the originally offered sum, because the employer wants to avoid litigation risk.

How to Secure Professional Support

The choice between a return-to-office mandate and severance is one of the most important career decisions you will make. A mistake can be costly — through loss of dismissal protection or unexpected tax liabilities. That is why obtaining an independent legal assessment is advisable. A certified employment law specialist reviews the situation, evaluates the prospects of a protection against dismissal lawsuit, and negotiates an appropriate severance for you.

If you decide to pursue a lawsuit, RechtStark as a litigation funder can cover the costs, provided your case has merit. This way you take no financial risk to enforce your rights. Take the time to weigh all options — and do not let short-term offers blind you. A well-founded decision pays off in the long run.

Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.

This article is general information and does not replace individual legal advice. RechtStark is a litigation funder, not a law firm; you are represented by an independent lawyer.