Settlement Agreement Dismissal Protection: What Porsche’s 2035 Guarantee Means for You

Aufhebungsvertrag und Kündigungsschutz: Was bedeutet der Schutz bis 2035 bei Porsche?

A settlement agreement dismissal protection scenario sounds contradictory at first. After all, dismissal protection is meant to shield employees from losing their jobs. Yet the reality is different: even with protection valid until 2035, as exists at Porsche, employers repeatedly try to persuade staff to leave via settlement agreements. This article explains what that means for affected employees and what to watch for.

Settlement Agreement Dismissal Protection: What Does Protection Until 2035 Mean at Porsche?

The dismissal protection valid until 2035 at Porsche is a collective bargaining or company-level agreement that shields many employees from ordinary dismissal. This means the employer cannot simply terminate the employment relationship for operational reasons while this protection agreement remains in force. For staff, this is a strong safety net – but it does not protect against every form of termination.

A settlement agreement is a mutual termination of the employment relationship. Both parties sign off that the employment ends on a specific date, often in exchange for a severance payment. Because it is a voluntary agreement, statutory dismissal protection does not apply. The employer can therefore offer a settlement agreement even while dismissal protection exists – and many do so to reduce headcount without lengthy unfair dismissal proceedings.

For Porsche employees, this means: the protection until 2035 is a valuable asset, but it is not inviolable. Anyone who signs a settlement agreement waives this protection – often without realizing the full implications. That is why it is crucial to assess your own situation carefully and not let yourself be pressured.

Why Do Employers Offer Settlement Agreements Despite Dismissal Protection?

Employers have various motives for offering settlement agreements even when dismissal protection exists. Cost reduction is a common driver: a settlement agreement allows headcount to be reduced faster and more flexibly than a dismissal that can be challenged in labor court. Restructuring, digitalization, or production relocation can also eliminate roles – and the employer tries to use severance packages to encourage voluntary departures.

Another reason is risk avoidance. A dismissal could trigger an unfair dismissal claim, leading to protracted litigation. A settlement agreement avoids that dispute – giving the employer planning certainty. Moreover, the employer can often set the severance lower than what a court might award in a settlement. Even though settlement agreement dismissal protection may seem contradictory at first glance, employers use this option deliberately to shed staff without exposing themselves to lengthy dismissal protection proceedings.

For the employee, a settlement agreement offer is tempting because it usually includes a severance payment. But caution: the severance amount is negotiable, and long-term consequences – such as a possible waiting period for unemployment benefits – are frequently underestimated. Before you sign, you should understand all consequences.

Settlement Agreement: Pros and Cons Compared to Dismissal

A settlement agreement does have advantages. You gain immediate certainty about the end of the employment relationship and an agreed severance payment. You avoid the uncertainty of an unfair dismissal case and can start looking for a new job early. Additionally, the reference letter often remains more positive because the termination is by mutual consent.

The disadvantages are significant, however. By signing, you lose your dismissal protection – including the protection valid until 2035. You no longer have any way to challenge the termination, even if it would have been socially unjustified. Moreover, a waiting period for unemployment benefits may apply if you accept a settlement agreement without good cause. That can hit you hard financially.

Another disadvantage: the severance payment is often lower than what you could achieve through an unfair dismissal case. Employers calculate with the employee’s fear of litigation and deliberately offer smaller sums. Anyone who signs hastily may be leaving money on the table.

Severance Payment: What Is Realistic?

In a settlement agreement dismissal protection context, the severance payment is a matter of negotiation – there is no statutory entitlement. A rule of thumb established in practice is half a gross monthly salary per year of service. However, this formula is only a guideline, not a guaranteed claim. Some employers offer less, some more – depending on negotiating skill and pressure.

Important to know: a statutory severance entitlement exists only in exceptional cases, for example when the employer offers a severance payment under § 1a KSchG (German Dismissal Protection Act) in the dismissal letter. In a settlement agreement, by contrast, the severance is the result of negotiations. You should not hesitate to demand a higher sum if your position is strong – for instance, after long service or at an advanced age.

Before entering negotiations, you should inform yourself about your rights and typical severance levels. A look at our severance after dismissal page can give you initial guidance. There you will also find information on calculation and negotiation strategies.

Waiting Period for Unemployment Benefits: The Risk of a Settlement Agreement

A common mistake with settlement agreements is assuming you will receive unemployment benefits without issue. But anyone who terminates the employment relationship themselves or signs a settlement agreement risks a waiting period of up to 12 weeks. During this time, no unemployment benefits are paid – which can cause substantial financial loss.

The waiting period applies when the employee intentionally or grossly negligently brings about their own unemployment. A settlement agreement is generally treated as such conduct, unless there is good cause – for example, a threatened dismissal with worse terms. The severance amount also plays a role: if it exceeds a certain threshold, unemployment benefits may be excluded entirely.

To minimize the risk, you should check before signing whether a waiting period looms and how long it might last. Learn more in our article waiting period and unemployment benefits. It explains when a waiting period can be avoided and what conditions must be met.

Should You Accept the Settlement Agreement? Decision Aids

The decision for or against a settlement agreement is always individual. It depends on your personal situation: How old are you? How long have you been with the company? What are your prospects on the job market? What severance is offered? And how high is the risk of a waiting period?

A key question is whether you would face dismissal at all without the settlement agreement. If dismissal protection is strong – as at Porsche until 2035 – you have a strong negotiating position. The employer wants you gone but cannot simply dismiss you. Use that strength to negotiate an appropriate severance package. Do not let yourself be fobbed off with a quick offer. Remember: a settlement agreement and dismissal protection are not opposites, but two paths with different consequences – your choice should be well considered.

If you are unsure whether to accept the agreement, seek professional advice. A specialist employment lawyer can review the contract, assess the severance level, and negotiate with the employer. Even if you cannot afford a lawyer, options exist: an unfair dismissal claim can be pursued without high cost risk, for example through legal aid or litigation funding.

How a Specialist Employment Lawyer Can Help

They know the legal pitfalls of settlement agreement dismissal protection cases, can realistically assess the severance, and negotiate with the employer on your behalf. They can also check whether the settlement agreement is legally sound and whether you might secure better terms.

The lawyer can also evaluate whether an unfair dismissal claim would make sense – even though dismissal protection until 2035 exists. Because even if the employer cannot dismiss, they may try to pressure you in other ways. An experienced lawyer recognizes such tactics and protects your rights.

RechtStark is not a law firm, but a litigation funder. We assess whether we can cover the costs of labor court proceedings if you wish to challenge a dismissal. This enables you to enforce your rights even if you cannot afford a lawyer. Our goal is to give you access to justice – without financial risk for you.

If you are faced with a settlement agreement, take your time. Do not let yourself be pressured; seek advice and negotiate carefully. Your dismissal protection is a valuable asset – do not give it up lightly.

Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.

This article is general information and does not replace individual legal advice. RechtStark is a litigation funder, not a law firm; you are represented by an independent lawyer.