Sick Leave Instead of Vacation: When It Can Lead to Dismissal

Employees who submit a sick note instead of taking approved vacation risk a conduct-related dismissal in the worst case — sick leave instead of vacation is a legal minefield. Many employees consider it harmless to replace vacation at short notice with a medical certificate in order to postpone their days off. Yet the employer may view this as a breach of trust with far-reaching consequences. This article explains the legal situation, when a dismissal may be justified, and how to act correctly if the worst happens.
Sick Leave Instead of Vacation: The Scenario and Its Pitfalls
Imagine this: you have requested vacation and your employer has agreed. The start of your vacation is imminent, but you do not feel well. Instead of going on your trip, you see a doctor and obtain a sick note. The vacation is not taken; the days of illness are treated as incapacity to work. This sounds practical at first, but it carries significant risks.
The employer has a legitimate interest in ensuring that approved vacation is actually used as recovery time. If you submit a sick note instead, the question arises: are you genuinely ill, or are you using the certificate merely to defer your vacation? In the latter case, it constitutes deception that can permanently damage the relationship of trust. Even a single incident can be regarded as a serious breach of duty, particularly if the employer has concrete indications that the illness is feigned.
Moreover, a sick note is not a free pass to pursue your own plans. While the employer may not inquire about your diagnosis under their duty of care, they may express doubts about your incapacity to work. If you are seen playing sports or on holiday during the period of sick leave, this can quickly become grounds for dismissal.
What the Law Says: Vacation Entitlement During Incapacity to Work (Section 9 BUrlG)
The statutory starting point is Section 9 of the Federal Vacation Act (BUrlG). This provision stipulates that vacation days interrupted by incapacity to work during the vacation are not counted against the vacation entitlement. Concretely, this means: if you fall ill during your vacation and prove it with a certificate, those days are not counted as vacation. You can take them later.
Crucially, however, Section 9 BUrlG applies only where the illness occurs during the vacation. If you are already incapable of work before the vacation begins, the rule does not apply automatically. In that case, you must inform the employer immediately and submit a sick note. The vacation is then deemed not to have commenced, and the sick days are treated separately. This sounds straightforward, yet disputes frequently arise in practice when the employer suspects the illness is merely a pretext.
Another point: the vacation entitlement does not generally lapse due to illness. If you are incapable of work, you can carry the vacation over to the following year. However, you must notify the employer of the impediment in good time. If you fail to do so, the employer may, under certain circumstances, claim damages — for example, if they had to plan for expensive replacement staff because of your absence.
When Dismissal for Feigned Illness May Be Justified
A dismissal for feigned illness is a conduct-related dismissal. It requires that the employee has committed a serious breach of duties arising from the employment relationship. Feigning an illness constitutes such a breach because it is based on deceiving the employer and destroys the relationship of trust. In particularly serious cases, even an extraordinary dismissal without notice may be considered.
However, case law generally requires the employer to have concrete evidence of the deception. Mere suspicion is not enough. The employer must prove that you were either not ill at all or that you engaged in impermissible conduct during the sick leave — such as taking up secondary employment or going on holiday. Without such proof, the dismissal is invalid.
The principle of proportionality must also be observed. For a first offence, a warning is usually issued first. A dismissal without a prior warning is justified only if the misconduct is so serious that continuing the employment relationship would be unreasonable. Feigning an illness can cross this threshold, especially when combined with deception about vacation planning.
For employees affected by such a dismissal, swift action is essential. An action for protection against dismissal must be filed with the labour court within three weeks of receiving the dismissal. Anyone who misses this deadline loses their protection against dismissal. More on the requirements and deadlines can be found in our guide to the action for protection against dismissal.
The Role of the Medical Certificate: Evidentiary Value and Employer Doubts
A medical certificate carries high evidentiary value. It documents that a doctor has established the incapacity to work. This means: as long as the employer has no concrete indications of forgery or malingering, they must generally accept the sick note. They cannot simply assume the certificate is false.
However, the evidentiary value is not absolute. The employer may demand a review, for instance by the Medical Service of the statutory health insurance funds or by an independent medical expert. In practice, this occurs mainly in cases of frequent short-term illnesses or conspicuous patterns — for example, when an employee is repeatedly certified sick precisely when vacation or overtime reduction is due.
If the employer has doubts, they may ask the employee to elaborate on the incapacity to work. The employee is not obliged to disclose the diagnosis. They need only submit the certificate. If the employee refuses to provide any information, this may reinforce the employer’s suspicion, but alone it is not sufficient for a dismissal.
A common mistake is submitting the certificate only after the vacation has begun. This quickly looks like a retroactive justification. It is better to inform the employer immediately after the doctor’s assessment and to submit the certificate promptly. This avoids the impression that the illness is merely a pretext.
Practical Recommendations: How to Act Correctly in an Emergency
If you are genuinely ill, you should observe the following: inform the employer immediately, submit the certificate, and document the time of notification. Avoid activities during the sick leave that contradict your illness — such as strenuous sports or long journeys. These can be used as evidence of malingering.
If you are not ill but wish to postpone your vacation, there is only one clean approach: talk to your employer. Ask whether a change to the vacation schedule is possible. Many employers are flexible if you give them early notice. Using sick leave instead of vacation as a substitute for unused leave is playing with fire — it can lead to summary dismissal.
In the event of a dismissal, do not panic, but do not hesitate either. Examine whether the dismissal is legally sustainable. Seek advice from an independent specialist lawyer for employment law. A lawyer can assess whether the dismissal is valid and whether a lawsuit is worthwhile. RechtStark is not a law firm, but we are happy to assess whether we can fund such proceedings as a litigation funder. This means you do not have to bear the cost risk alone.
If you are aiming for a severance payment after a dismissal, a lawsuit is often the best route. The amount of a severance payment cannot be stated as a flat rate; it depends on many factors. An overview of the rule of thumb and negotiation strategies can be found in our article on severance pay after dismissal.
Sick Leave Instead of Vacation: Clear Communication and Legal Advice Minimise Risks
Using sick leave instead of vacation is no minor offence. Anyone who abuses the certificate to defer their vacation risks not only a warning but, in extreme cases, their job. The legal position is clear: an illness must be genuine, and the employer has a legitimate interest in ensuring that vacation is used as recovery time.
The best strategy is honesty. If you are ill, notify your employer early and submit a certificate. If you want to postpone your vacation, negotiate with your employer. And if a dismissal looms, obtain professional help — a specialist lawyer for employment law can safeguard your rights and guide you through the proceedings. RechtStark helps you overcome the financial hurdle so that you do not have to forego your rights out of fear of costs.
Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.


