Works Council Candidate Dismissal: Free Speech Protected in Election Campaign

Meinungsfreiheit im Betriebsratswahlkampf: Fristlose Kündigung unwirksam – Meinungsfreiheit Betriebsratswahl

A works council candidate dismissal was ruled invalid by the Cologne Labor Court in a judgment dated November 11, 2026, strengthening freedom of speech in works council election campaigns. An employee who shouted „Nazis out!“ at a works meeting had been wrongfully dismissed without notice. The court declared the dismissal invalid because the statement was made during the works-public election campaign and touched the core area of freedom of speech. We explain the case, the legal reasoning, and your options for action.

The Case: Dismissal After „Nazis Out!“ Chant in Works Council Election Campaign

The claimant had been employed by the defendant employer for just over five years and was a candidate in the upcoming works council election at the time of the dismissal. Another candidate ran on a competing list who had been active in local politics for the Alternative for Germany party until at least 2023. At a works meeting with over 600 participants, the claimant allegedly shouted „Nazi(s) out!“ as the other candidate approached the microphone to present his list.

The employer responded by terminating the employment relationship without notice. The claimant fought back with an unfair dismissal claim before the Cologne Labor Court. The court upheld the claim and ruled that the summary dismissal was invalid. The decision is not yet final; the employer may appeal to the Higher Labor Court of Cologne.

Works Council Candidate Dismissal: Why the Court Ruled the Summary Dismissal Invalid

The Labor Court found no valid reason for extraordinary dismissal in the statement attributed to the claimant. The decisive factor was that the statement – if indeed made by the claimant – fell within the scope of the works-public election campaign for the works council. This engaged the core area of freedom of speech under Article 5(1)(1) of the Basic Law (German Constitution).

The chamber weighed the competing interests: on one side, the employee’s right to express political views during an election campaign, even in sharp terms; on the other, the employer’s interest in orderly operations and protecting the personal rights of other employees. In this specific case, freedom of speech prevailed because the statement was directly connected to the election campaign and did not occur in a private or non-work-related context.

The court emphasized that not every provocative or emotionally charged statement during an election campaign justifies dismissal. Rather, the circumstances of each individual case must be examined carefully. A summary dismissal is the employer’s sharpest weapon and requires that continuing the employment relationship until the end of the notice period would be unreasonable for the employer. That was not the case here.

Freedom of Speech in Works Council Election Campaigns: What Applies?

Freedom of speech in works council election campaigns enjoys special protection. The Federal Constitutional Court has repeatedly clarified that freedom of speech applies in the workplace and does not end at the factory gate. Especially in works council elections, which serve democratic co-determination, employees must be able to express their views freely – including on political topics affecting the operation.

However, freedom of speech is not unlimited. Insults, defamation, or incitement to criminal acts are not protected even during an election campaign. The decisive question is whether the statement can still be regarded as a contribution to public opinion-forming or whether it serves exclusively to disparage a person. In the present case, the court viewed the „Nazis out!“ chant as part of a political confrontation during the election campaign, not as a personal insult.

For employees, this means: you need not fear immediate dismissal for pointed political statements during a works council election campaign. The threshold for dismissal is significantly higher. However, anyone who resorts to insults or defamation can lose the protection of freedom of speech.

Works Council Election: Special Protection for Candidates?

Works council candidates enjoy special protection against dismissal. Under Section 15 of the Protection Against Dismissal Act (KSchG), the dismissal of works council members, electoral board members, and candidates is generally impermissible unless facts exist that entitle the employer to dismiss for good cause. This special protection aims to ensure that employees are not deterred from standing as candidates by fear of dismissal.

In the present case, the claimant was a candidate, so the summary dismissal would only have been permissible if good cause existed. The court found no such good cause. The statement fell within the protected sphere of the election campaign, so the candidate’s special dismissal protection applied.

This protection is important because works council elections are only democratically legitimate if candidates can stand freely and without pressure. Anyone dismissed for a political statement during an election campaign can fight back – and has good prospects, as this ruling shows.

What the Ruling Means for Your Dismissal

The Cologne Labor Court’s judgment is a strong signal for freedom of speech in employment relationships. If you were dismissed for a political statement – whether summarily or with notice – you should have the validity of the dismissal reviewed. The circumstances of the individual case are decisive: where was the statement made, in what context, and how serious was it?

A summary dismissal is only valid for good cause that makes continuing the employment relationship unreasonable for the employer. A notice dismissal must be socially justified, i.e., based on reasons relating to the person, conduct, or urgent operational requirements. Political statements alone generally do not justify dismissal, provided they do not violate criminal laws or seriously disrupt operational order.

If you are affected, you should act quickly: the deadline for filing an unfair dismissal claim is only three weeks after receipt of the dismissal. If you miss this deadline, the dismissal is generally effective even if it was unlawful. Expert advice from a specialist employment lawyer is therefore essential.

Your Rights After Summary Dismissal: Options for Action

In the event of a summary dismissal, you have several options: you can file an unfair dismissal claim within three weeks. If you win, the employment relationship continues. You then have a right to continued employment and payment of remuneration for the period of the unlawful dismissal.

Alternatively, you can agree with the employer to terminate the employment relationship in return for a severance package. A severance package is not a statutory entitlement but the result of negotiation. The amount depends on the circumstances of the individual case, such as length of service and income. A rule of thumb often used as a starting point is half a gross monthly salary per year of employment – more on this in our severance pay guide.

Before agreeing to a settlement, you should realistically assess the prospects of success of a claim. Not every dismissal is invalid, and a claim can also fail – for example, if the deadline was missed or the statement was so serious that it justified dismissal. Read also our article Why an Unfair Dismissal Claim Can Fail.

If you decide to pursue a claim but are concerned about the cost risk, you can use litigation funding. RechtStark assesses whether we can fund your proceedings – without you having to advance attorney and court costs. This allows you to enforce your rights without taking a financial risk.

Conclusion: Protecting Freedom of Speech in Employment

The Cologne Labor Court’s ruling shows: freedom of speech in works council election campaigns is a high-value asset that employers must not undermine through hasty dismissals. Whether as a works council candidate or a regular employee, anyone making a political statement need not fear immediately losing their job. The courts protect the core area of freedom of speech – even in the workplace.

If you have nevertheless been dismissed for a political statement, you should fight back. The chances of challenging the dismissal are good if the statement was made in connection with the works council election campaign. Seek advice from a specialist employment lawyer quickly and observe the three-week deadline. With the right support, you can enforce your rights – and, if necessary, have the proceedings funded as well.

Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.

This article is general information and does not replace individual legal advice. RechtStark is a litigation funder, not a law firm; you are represented by an independent lawyer.