Dismissal for AfD Candidacy: What Employees Need to Know Now

A dismissal for AfD candidacy is currently making headlines: a hospice employee is taking legal action against her termination after publicly announcing her candidacy for the AfD. The case raises the fundamental question of whether employers may sanction their employees‘ political engagement and what legal steps those affected can take. In this guide, you will learn what rights you have and how to defend yourself in an emergency.
The Case: Hospice Employee Sues Over Her Termination
According to media reports, an employee of a hospice received a dismissal after she publicly announced her candidacy for the AfD. The woman is now challenging the termination with a lawsuit. Details such as the competent court, the employer’s exact reasoning, or the hospice’s sponsoring organization are not yet known — nevertheless, the case illustrates how quickly political engagement can become an employment law problem.
Such constellations are not new: time and again, employees receive warnings or are even dismissed because of their political activities. The legal assessment depends heavily on the individual case — in particular, on whether the employee’s conduct actually impairs the employer’s operational interests.
Political Activity During Employment: What Is Permitted and Where the Limits Lie
In principle, employees enjoy the fundamental right to freedom of expression (Article 5 of the Basic Law) during the employment relationship as well. They may engage in political activity outside working hours, be members of parties, and even run for political office. However, this right is not without limits: in the employment relationship, the duty to take the employer’s interests into account applies (Section 241 BGB).
A dismissal on grounds of political activity is only effective if the employee thereby breaches their contractual duties. This is the case, for example, if they conduct political campaigning during working hours, put pressure on colleagues, or disturb the peace of the establishment. Even where the employer has a legitimate interest in political neutrality — for instance at religious institutions, political parties, or public-sector employers — limits may apply.
A hospice is frequently an institution under church sponsorship. Special loyalty obligations may exist there. However, church employers must also respect their employees‘ fundamental rights and may not sanction every political statement. A candidacy for a democratic party is generally not grounds for dismissal — even if the party is socially controversial.
When Is a Dismissal for AfD Candidacy Unlawful?
A dismissal for AfD candidacy may be invalid if it violates the prohibition on victimisation under Section 612a BGB. Under this provision, the employer must not disadvantage an employee because the employee exercises their rights in a permissible manner. Running for political office is such a right — provided it does not encroach on working hours or disrupt operational processes.
In addition, the dismissal must be socially justified (Section 1 KSchG). This means it must be based on personal, conduct-related, or operational reasons. A political expression of opinion alone is not a conduct-related ground for dismissal unless it causes concrete disruption in the workplace. An ordinary dismissal on the basis of a candidacy will therefore not stand up before the labour court in most cases.
Exceptions apply to managerial employees or employees in security-relevant areas, where special loyalty obligations exist. In the case of an extraordinary (summary) dismissal, serious breaches of duty must be present — a mere candidacy is generally not sufficient for this.
Action for Protection Against Dismissal: Observe the Deadline and Assess Prospects of Success
If you have received a dismissal, a deadline of three weeks applies from receipt of the letter to file an action for protection against dismissal with the labour court. If you miss this deadline, the dismissal is deemed effective from the outset — even if it was substantively unfounded. You can file a lawsuit without a lawyer, but legal advice is strongly recommended in order to realistically assess your chances.
The prospects of success of an action for protection against dismissal depend on many factors: size of the establishment, length of service, existence of a works council, possible severe disability, or other special protection rights. Especially in the case of a dismissal on grounds of political activity, you should have it examined whether the employer can prove a factual reason. Often the dismissal already fails because the employer cannot specify a concrete breach of duty.
A comprehensive overview of the requirements, procedure, and costs of an action for protection against dismissal can be found in our guide to the action for protection against dismissal. There you will also learn when special protection against dismissal applies and which deadlines you must absolutely observe.
Severance as an Option: What Employees Should Watch for in a Settlement
In many actions for protection against dismissal, the parties agree on a settlement that provides for a severance payment. A statutory severance payment exists only in certain cases — for example, in the case of an operational dismissal with a notice period (Section 1a KSchG) or if the employer expressly offers it in the dismissal letter. In practice, however, the severance payment is frequently negotiated as part of a settlement.
The amount of the severance payment is often oriented towards the rule of thumb: 0.5 gross monthly salaries per year of employment. This is, however, not a statutory entitlement, but only a reference point for negotiations. In a dismissal for political reasons, the employer may have an interest in ending the legal dispute quickly — which can strengthen your negotiating position.
Before agreeing to a settlement, you should examine carefully whether the offered severance payment is appropriate. Also consider tax aspects and possible effects on your unemployment benefit. If you are unsure, consult a specialist lawyer. A severance payment is always a negotiated solution — you have no automatic entitlement to it. Further information on severance payments and their calculation can be found in our guide to severance payments after dismissal.
Practical Steps for Those Affected: Documentation, Advice, Lawsuit
If you have received a dismissal on grounds of AfD candidacy or for other political reasons, you should act quickly and in a structured manner:
- Note the deadline: The action for protection against dismissal must be received by the labour court within three weeks. Count from the day you received the letter.
- Gather documents: Keep the dismissal letter, your employment contract, payslips, and all correspondence. Also document when and how you exercised your political activity.
- Obtain legal advice: Consult a specialist lawyer for employment law as soon as possible. Only they can realistically assess your prospects of success and file the lawsuit in time.
- Do not sign prematurely: Do not let your employer pressure you into a termination agreement before you have obtained legal advice. A termination agreement can jeopardise your claims to severance pay and unemployment benefit.
If you decide to pursue a lawsuit, the lawyer will usually represent you in court. You may initially have to bear the costs yourself — or you can examine whether litigation funding is an option.
Enforcing Your Rights: Independent Specialist Lawyer and Litigation Funding
A dismissal on grounds of political activity is an interference with your fundamental rights. Do not let yourself be intimidated — defend yourself with the legal means available to you. The first step is always consultation with an independent specialist lawyer for employment law. They will examine whether the dismissal is effective and represent your interests in court.
The costs of labour court proceedings can, however, be a hurdle — especially if you become unemployed. This is where litigation funding can help: RechtStark examines your prospects of success and, if it issues a commitment, assumes the costs for the lawyer and the court. You pay only a share of the severance payment or settlement obtained — and only if you win. This allows you to enforce your rights without financial risk.
If you have therefore received a dismissal for AfD candidacy, do not hesitate: secure your deadlines, obtain expert advice, and examine whether litigation funding is an option for you. Your political conviction is a valuable asset — it must not become a disadvantage in your career.
Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.


