Managing Director Liability in Insolvency: What the Iserlohn Labor Court Decided

Managing director liability insolvency is a topic that concerns many employees when their employer becomes insolvent. A recent ruling by the Iserlohn Labor Court shows under what conditions managing directors can be held personally liable for outstanding wages — and when they cannot. We explain the legal situation and your rights.
The Case: Lawsuit Against Managing Directors for Wage Payment in Insolvency
The Iserlohn Labor Court had to decide on a lawsuit brought by an employee against the managing directors of his insolvent employer. The claimant had been employed by a GmbH since August 1, 2010. Insolvency proceedings were opened over the company’s assets on July 1, 2024 — specifically as self-administration proceedings. This means the managing directors remained in office but had to act under the supervision of a custodian. Business operations continued, and the claimant remained employed.
In April and May 2025, the company was still negotiating with potential investors on an insolvency plan. The savings bank signaled willingness to restructure liabilities of around 3 million euros. But the talks failed. On June 6, 2025, the Hagen Local Court revoked self-administration and appointed an insolvency administrator. The administrator instructed the managing directors to make no further payments without his approval. The company account showed a credit balance at that time, which the administrator later withdrew. On June 18, 2025, he reported insufficient estate assets.
The claimant had earned a gross salary of 1,886.56 euros for May 2025. Short-time work allowance of 299.90 euros was paid to him later, and social security contributions were also paid — but the net wage difference remained outstanding. While other employees received their full wages, the claimant received nothing. He then sued the two managing directors personally for damages. The labor court dismissed the action. The value in dispute was set at 1,586.66 euros.
Managing Director Liability Insolvency: When Are Managing Directors Personally Liable?
As a rule, a managing director is not personally liable with his private assets for the GmbH’s liabilities. The company is a separate legal entity. Personal liability arises only in exceptional cases — for example, if the managing director grossly breaches his duties, such as:
- He fails to file for insolvency in time although the company is insolvent or over-indebted.
- He misuses or conceals company assets.
- He commits an unlawful act, for instance by withholding social security contributions.
In the present case, the judges saw no such breach of duty. The managing directors had made serious efforts to rescue the company within the framework of self-administration. They negotiated with investors and worked on an insolvency plan. The fact that these efforts failed does not automatically make them liable. The mere fact that wages were not paid in full does not necessarily lead to personal liability either — particularly not when the insolvency administrator had taken control and prohibited payments.
Managing director liability insolvency therefore applies only where fault can be established. The mere circumstance that a company is insolvent and can no longer pay wages is not sufficient. The ruling of the Iserlohn Labor Court confirms this strict line.
Self-Administration and Insolvency Administrator: Who Pays the Wages?
In self-administration, the managing director initially remains in office. He continues to run the company — but under the supervision of a custodian. The custodian monitors the management of the business and can prohibit payments. Wages for the period after the opening of insolvency proceedings are so-called estate liabilities. They must be serviced preferentially from the insolvency estate as long as the estate is sufficient.
If self-administration is revoked and an insolvency administrator is appointed, the power of administration and disposal passes to the administrator. From that point on, the managing director may no longer authorize payments alone. The administrator decides which liabilities to satisfy. If the estate is insufficient, he must report insufficient estate assets — exactly what happened here on June 18, 2025.
For employees, this means: your claim for wages is not directed against the managing directors personally, but against the insolvency estate. If the estate is insufficient, outstanding wages are paid only proportionally or not at all. Personal liability of the managing directors arises only if they acted in breach of duty before or during self-administration — for example by delaying the insolvency filing or by making unauthorized payments to other creditors.
What Does the Ruling Mean for Affected Employees?
The ruling makes one thing clear: the route via managing director liability is a dead end in most cases. Anyone hoping for outstanding wages should not rely on the personal liability of the managing directors. Instead, there are other, far more promising ways to get your money.
Managing director liability insolvency is therefore not a simple lever to enforce wage claims. You should inform yourself early about your rights as an employee in insolvency and take the right steps. Above all, this includes applying for insolvency benefit.
Your Rights in Employer Insolvency: Insolvency Benefit and Further Claims
If your employer becomes insolvent, you are entitled to insolvency benefit. This is paid by the Federal Employment Agency and covers the net wage for the last three months before the insolvency event. The insolvency event can be the opening of insolvency proceedings, the rejection of the application for lack of assets, or provisional insolvency administration. You must apply for insolvency benefit within two months of the insolvency event — otherwise the claim lapses.
In addition, you can register your outstanding wage claims as insolvency claims in the schedule of claims. If the estate is sufficient, you will be satisfied — at least partially. In the case of insufficient estate assets, all creditors are treated equally, and the quota is often low. Nevertheless, you should register the claim to avoid losing any rights.
If you are dismissed after the insolvency, you naturally also have the option of filing an unfair dismissal action. Insolvency does not shield the employer from the general protection against dismissal rules. A severance payment may also be possible within the framework of a settlement or a social plan — more on this in our article on insolvency benefit, dismissal and severance at AWO Bielefeld.
How a Specialist Lawyer for Labor Law Can Help — and How RechtStark Supports the Financing
The legal situation in insolvency is complex. A specialist lawyer for labor law can examine whether managing director liability might apply in your case after all — for example, if the managing director delayed the insolvency proceedings or withheld social security contributions. Legal assistance is also useful for enforcing insolvency benefit and registering claims.
However, many employees shy away from consulting a lawyer because they fear the costs. This is exactly where RechtStark comes in: we are a litigation funder and cover the costs of your labor law proceedings — from legal advice to court action. You only need to describe your case; we assess the prospects of success and finance the proceedings if they are promising. You pay only if you win. This allows you to enforce your rights without financial risk.
The ruling of the Iserlohn Labor Court shows that the personal liability of managing directors is rarely the right path. Seek professional advice and use the statutory instruments such as insolvency benefit and claim registration. Only in this way do you secure the best chances of receiving at least part of your wages.
Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.


