Unpaid Extra Break: What the Bielefeld Labor Court Decided

Unbezahlte Zusatzpause: Was das Arbeitsgericht Bielefeld entschieden hat – unbezahlte-zusatzpause

The Bielefeld Labor Court ruled on October 28, 2026 (Case No. 7 Ca 1367/26) that an unpaid extra break ordered by works agreement for certain employee groups must be compensated. The decision concerns Mohn Media Mohndruck GmbH and is significant beyond the individual case. It shows that employers cannot structure break regulations arbitrarily at the expense of individual employees.

What Happened? The Ruling at a Glance

In the legal dispute, an employee and his employer argued over the validity of a works agreement. The plaintiff belonged to a small group of employees who contractually work only 35 hours per week, while the majority of the workforce works 37.5 hours. The company operates a three-shift system. To align the start and end times of the different groups, the works agreement provided that the 35-hour employees must take an additional 30-minute break. They could schedule this extra break freely, but it was automatically deducted from working time and not paid.

The plaintiff considered this arrangement impermissible and demanded payment for the deducted time. The employer argued that aligning shift times was necessary for an orderly shift handover. Without the additional break, the 35-hour employees would leave earlier than the other shift workers, complicating the handover. The labor court nevertheless ruled in favor of the plaintiff: the additional half hour does not constitute a break within the meaning of the Working Hours Act, but rather compensable working time. An appeal can be lodged with the Higher Labor Court.

Why the Unpaid Extra Break Is Not a Real Break

The Working Hours Act defines a rest break as a predetermined interruption of work during which the employee neither has to perform work nor be on standby. Breaks serve recovery and are therefore generally not compensable. An extra break that does not fulfill this purpose is legally challengeable.

In the decided case, the unpaid extra break apparently served a different function: it was meant to align the different weekly working hours of employees in shift operation so that everyone starts and ends at the same time. The interest in the break therefore lay not with the employee, but with the employer, who wanted to ensure a smooth shift handover. But anyone who sits out time or stands by in the company’s interest performs working time – even if that time is labeled a break.

The court clarified that the designation as a break is not decisive. What matters is whether the time actually serves recovery and the employee is freed from all duties. If not, it must be compensated. This classification aligns with established case law holding that not the label, but the actual content of the activity determines its classification as working time.

Works Agreement: Where the Limits of Co-Determination Lie

Works agreements are an important instrument of workplace co-determination. The works council has a say in the scheduling of working time and breaks. But that does not mean employers and works councils may agree on any regulation. They must stay within the bounds of the law and may not unilaterally disadvantage employees.

A works agreement ordering an additional unpaid break only for a specific group of employees may violate the principle of equal treatment. In the case at hand, the group of 35-hour employees was particularly affected: they effectively had to stay at the company longer but received less pay. The employer could have achieved the alignment of working hours through other measures, such as a different distribution of working time or by ordering overtime with corresponding compensation. This is precisely the core of the problem: a regulation that unilaterally disadvantages a specific group is only effective if there is an objective reason for it and no milder means are available.

For employees, it is important to know: not every provision in a works agreement is automatically valid. If a provision violates mandatory statutory law or the principle of good faith, it may be invalid. This also applies to break regulations that in reality serve to create unpaid working time. Anyone who considers such a regulation invalid can have it reviewed through legal action.

Your Rights: When Must Break Times Be Compensated?

The principle is: genuine breaks are unpaid, working time is compensated. A break is only a genuine break if you are completely freed from work during that time and can use your time freely. If you must remain at the workplace, be on call, or perform certain tasks, it constitutes working time.

Particularly problematic are so-called standby periods declared as breaks. A break that the employer orders solely to align working times can also be compensable working time. The Bielefeld Labor Court has now confirmed this. Similar to overtime in part-time work, where the Nuremberg Higher Labor Court ruled that additional hours must not simply remain unpaid, this ruling also shows: the decisive factor is the actual character of the time, not its designation. Overtime in part-time work must be compensated just like disguised working time masked as a break.

If you are affected by an unpaid extra break, you should check whether the break actually serves recovery. Document your working hours precisely. Record when you work and when you are on break, and keep shift schedules and pay statements. These documents are important if you later assert claims. A working time account can also help prove the hours actually worked.

What Does the Ruling Mean for Your Employment? Practical Guidance

The ruling is initially binding only on the parties to the dispute. However, it can serve as guidance for similar cases. The unpaid extra break in the Bielefeld case was ordered only for the 35-hour employees. If you belong to a group subject to such a regulation, you should examine whether your situation is comparable to the Bielefeld case.

Ask yourself the following questions:

  • Is the break automatically deducted from your working time?
  • Must you remain at the workplace or be reachable during the break?
  • Does the break primarily serve operational interests, such as aligning shift times?
  • Can you really use the break freely, or must you expect interruptions?
  • Does the regulation affect only certain employee groups, such as part-time workers?

The more of these questions you answer with yes, the greater the likelihood that the break must be compensated. The time factor is also important. Compensation claims generally become time-barred after three years. However, collective bargaining or contractual exclusion periods may provide for shorter deadlines. Some exclusion periods require claims to be asserted in writing within two or three months. Do not let these deadlines expire, or your claim may be lost even before the statute of limitations runs out.

Is a Lawsuit Worth It? How to Assess Your Break Compensation Claims

Whether a lawsuit is worthwhile depends on the amount of potential claims and the prospects of success. With an unpaid extra break of 30 minutes per shift, considerable sums can accumulate over several years. Calculate how many hours you were not compensated for and present this calculation to your lawyer. The higher the value in dispute, the more weight your demand carries.

A lawsuit for break compensation is an action for performance. It is not directed against a dismissal but seeks payment of wages. Unlike an unfair dismissal protection lawsuit, where you have only three weeks after receipt of the dismissal, compensation claims are generally subject to the statute of limitations. Nevertheless, you should not wait too long, as the evidence situation becomes more difficult with each passing month. If you have received a dismissal, you can find all important information on deadlines and procedure in our overview of unfair dismissal protection.

Before suing, you should demand payment from your employer in writing and set a deadline. Employers often respond only to a concrete payment demand. If no agreement is reached, a specialist lawyer for labor law can assess the prospects of success. A lawsuit before the labor court involves costs that you must bear yourself if you lose. Legal expenses insurance may cover these costs if the case is insured. Alternatively, litigation funding can be examined to assume the cost risk. We explain how this works in our article on unfair dismissal protection without cost risk. RechtStark, as a litigation funder, examines whether financing your proceedings is an option – an independent specialist lawyer handles the legal representation.

Conclusion: How to Fight Back Against Unpaid Extra Breaks

The ruling of the Bielefeld Labor Court strengthens the rights of employees whose breaks are in reality working time. Breaks that do not serve recovery but operational purposes must be compensated. Employers cannot simply exempt themselves from this obligation through a works agreement.

If you are affected, take action: document your working hours, demand payment from your employer in writing, and seek legal advice. The sooner you assert your claims, the better your chances of obtaining compensation. The Bielefeld ruling shows that reviewing your own working hours can pay off.

Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.

This article is general information and does not replace individual legal advice. RechtStark is a litigation funder, not a law firm; you are represented by an independent lawyer.