Dismissal Without Warning: Cologne Labor Court Overturns Summary Dismissal of IT Manager

Dismissal without warning is a central issue in many dismissal protection proceedings. A recent ruling by the Regional Labor Court (LAG) Cologne shows how high the hurdles are for employers: An Application Manager, who acted as the approval authority for hours billed by IT service providers, was summarily dismissed because the employer suspected irregularities in the hour records. The LAG Cologne declared the dismissal invalid. We explain the case and what affected employees can learn from it.
The Starting Point: Hour Records and a Summary Dismissal
The plaintiff had been employed as an Application Manager since January 1, 2009, at a company that regularly employs more than ten full-time employees. His latest gross monthly salary amounted to 6,902.65 euros. The company sources IT services from third-party providers under framework agreements. One of the contracted firms was M GmbH, which worked at a net hourly rate of 166.40 euros. The dispute centered on the order „SAP DBM Developments after VSS Porting,“ which involved transferring functions from a legacy system to a new one.
The services of the external developers were documented in an electronic service recording system (LES). There, the service providers entered their surname, supplier, date, ticket number, hours worked, and a service description. These entries had to be reviewed and approved by so-called approval officers. The plaintiff was registered as one of these approval officers. On December 4, 2023, December 18, 2023, and January 2, 2024, he approved a total of 142 hours that the managing director of M GmbH and three other employees had recorded for programming services.
The Role of the Approval Officer: Mere Formal Check or Real Control?
The position of approval officer sounds responsible, but in practice it is often a mere formality. The Application Manager had no involvement whatsoever in the awarding of contracts or the substantive management of projects. He was merely responsible for checking the hours entered in the LES for obvious errors and approving them. A substantive review of the programming work or verification of whether the hours were actually worked was not part of his duties.
This division of tasks is common in large companies: External service providers record their own hours, and the clients rely on the accuracy of those entries. The approval officer typically only checks whether the entries are plausible — for example, whether the number of hours matches the stated period. A comprehensive review of the actual work performed rarely takes place. In the present case, however, the employer relied on an alleged contradiction between the developers‘ login data in the development system and the billed hours. The Application Manager could neither recognize nor prevent this contradiction, as he had no access to the technical background whatsoever.
Why the LAG Cologne Declared the Summary Dismissal Invalid
The employer gave the plaintiff extraordinary summary dismissal, alternatively ordinary dismissal. He accused him of having approved hours that had not been worked. As evidence, he cited the fact that the developers‘ last logins in the SDI system, the electronic development system, had occurred on earlier days — for example, on November 21, 2023, or December 12, 2023. This was intended to show that the programming work had not taken place on the days for which hours were billed.
The Regional Labor Court Cologne did not follow this argument. It amended the judgment of the Labor Court Siegburg and determined that the employment relationship had not been terminated by the dismissal of December 13, 2024. Leave to appeal was not granted. The court found that a material breach of duty had not been sufficiently proven. Apparently, a prior warning was missing, and the employer’s plausibility check was insufficient to justify such a drastic measure as summary dismissal. The consequence: The plaintiff remains employed and is entitled to his salary since the dismissal — a substantial financial advantage.
Dismissal Without Warning: When It Is Exceptionally Permissible
A conduct-related dismissal is only permissible under very narrow conditions. According to the consistent case law of the Federal Labor Court, such a dismissal — whether ordinary or extraordinary — is fundamentally only effective if the employee was previously warned. The warning serves a cautionary function: It shows the employee that the employer does not accept their conduct and gives them the chance to improve. Only if a repetition is not to be expected or the breach of duty is so serious that a warning would change nothing can it be dispensed with. A dismissal without warning presupposes that the employee is accused of a breach of duty so severe that even a prior warning would be unreasonable. Examples include theft, embezzlement, or intentional deception. In the case of less serious violations — such as the erroneous approval of hours — the employer must first issue a warning. A warning is also required if the employee acted only negligently. In the present case, the plaintiff was apparently not even negligent but relied on the service providers‘ entries. The dismissal was therefore unlawful. Also read how the Labor Court ruled in a similar case: Invalid Warning: DHL Delivery Driver Prevails.
Plausibility Check: What Employers Must Do Before a Dismissal
Before an employer issues a conduct-related dismissal, they must examine the allegations thoroughly. This means: They must hear the employee, review the relevant documents, and weigh whether the conduct truly justifies dismissal. In the present case, the employer should have examined whether the Application Manager could actually have recognized or had to recognize that the hours were incorrect. The mere fact that logins in the development system occurred on different days is no conclusive proof of incorrect hour records. There could be many reasons why a developer does not log in simultaneously — for example, because they are working on other projects or the time recording is corrected retroactively.
The case law requires that the employer fully clarify the circumstances of the individual case. A hasty dismissal based on mere suspicions is impermissible. If — as here — the breach of duty is not established beyond doubt, there is no good cause. The court recognized this and overturned the dismissal. Employers should therefore always conduct a careful plausibility check and hear the employee before a dismissal due to alleged irregularities. A dismissal without warning also demands a thorough examination of the allegations, because only then can it be avoided that a dismissal fails in court.
What Employees Can Do Now: Dismissal Protection Claim and Deadlines
Anyone who has received a dismissal must act quickly. Within three weeks of receipt of the dismissal, a dismissal protection claim must be filed with the Labor Court. This applies to both ordinary and extraordinary dismissals. If this deadline is missed, the dismissal is deemed effective from the outset under Section 7 KSchG (Protection Against Dismissal Act) — regardless of whether it would have been legally sustainable. A claim can also be useful if the employer offers a severance package, because without a claim there is often no negotiating pressure.
The claim must be filed with the Labor Court at the place of the establishment. A specialist lawyer for labor law can assess the prospects of success and substantiate the claim. The key is to meet the deadline without fail. If you are unsure whether your dismissal is effective, seek advice quickly. Further information on procedure and deadlines can be found in our guide to the Dismissal Protection Claim. The case of an invalid warning also shows how important formal correctness is — more on this in our report on the DHL Delivery Driver.
Litigation Funding: How RechtStark Removes the Financial Hurdle
A dismissal protection claim can involve considerable costs — for lawyers, court fees, and potentially multiple instances. Many employees forgo their rights for fear of the cost risk. That need not be the case: As a litigation funder, RechtStark assumes the costs of the proceedings if the claim has sufficient prospects of success. The employee bears no cost risk of their own — in the event of success, they receive their continued pay claim or a severance package, and the funding costs are settled from the proceeds. This protection is particularly valuable if you want to challenge a dismissal without warning, because success rates are often high in such cases.
This enables employees with low incomes to enforce their rights as well. Litigation funding is especially attractive for dismissal protection claims, as success rates are often high — particularly when, as here, a summary dismissal without warning has been issued. If you are affected, have your chances assessed. RechtStark is happy to assist you.
Conclusion
The ruling of the LAG Cologne makes clear that employers must overcome high hurdles in conduct-related dismissals. A dismissal without warning is only permissible in narrowly defined exceptional cases. Anyone dismissed as an employee should therefore not hesitate to take legal action. The dismissal protection claim can save the employment relationship or at least secure a severance package. More on the topic of severance can be found in our guide to Severance After Dismissal. Consult a specialist lawyer for labor law and explore the possibility of litigation funding.
Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.


