Works Council Hiring Co-Determination: Why Precise Applications Are Crucial

Mitbestimmung bei Einstellungen: Warum präzise Anträge entscheidend sind

Works council hiring co-determination is a core right of the works council. A recent ruling by the Hessian Labor Court shows, however, how quickly this right can be lost through procedural errors. We explain the case and give tips on how you as a works council can safeguard your rights.

Works Council Hiring Co-Determination: Basics of Section 99 BetrVG

Under Section 99 of the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG), the works council has a co-determination right in individual personnel measures. These include hiring, classification, reclassification, and transfers. The employer must obtain the works council’s consent before implementing such measures. If the works council withholds consent, the employer may appeal to the labor court.

The situation becomes particularly complex when external personnel are deployed – for example, temporary agency workers or employees of service companies. The question arises whether the deployment of external personnel constitutes a „hiring“ within the meaning of Section 99 BetrVG. The Federal Labor Court has clarified in several decisions that the deployment of external personnel can also be subject to co-determination if the workers are integrated into the operation and work under the employer’s instructions. The exact criteria, however, are often disputed and must be examined on a case-by-case basis.

For works councils, it is important to actively exercise co-determination in hiring. Only in this way can they influence the composition of the workforce and ensure that employees‘ interests are protected. A recent ruling by the Hessian LAG shows, however, how quickly this right can be lost through procedural errors.

The Case: External Personnel in the Construction Industry’s Joint Operation

In the case decided by the Hessian Labor Court (ruling of August 4, 2026 – 15 TaBV 76/25), the dispute concerned two joint institutions of the collective bargaining parties in the construction industry. These formed a joint operation and employed several hundred workers. The operation also deployed employees of external companies, including an agency for customer experience and dialog marketing (hereinafter: Company A).

The works council of the joint operation took the view that the deployment of the external employees was subject to co-determination under Section 99 BetrVG. It filed an application for a declaratory judgment with the Wiesbaden Labor Court. The labor court granted the application by ruling of July 7, 2025 (1 BV 4/24). The employers appealed.

During the appeal proceedings, the employers changed the contractual basis with Company A. They concluded a new cooperation agreement and a termination and transfer agreement, which was to take effect from October 1, 2025. This change was decisive for the outcome of the proceedings.

Why the Works Council’s Application Failed: The Cross-Appeal Deadline

The works council had originally based its declaratory application on the first service contract. After the employers changed the contractual basis, the works council should have adapted its application to the new situation. The labor court, however, had assessed the application on the basis of the old contract. In appeal proceedings, the parties must generally maintain their applications and adapt them if the factual circumstances change.

The works council failed to adapt its application within the cross-appeal deadline. The cross-appeal is a procedural tool that allows a party to join the opponent’s appeal, even if it has missed the appeal deadline itself. It must be filed within a specific period after service of the grounds of appeal. In this case, the works council missed this deadline, so the LAG dismissed the cross-appeal as inadmissible.

The Hessian LAG then amended the labor court’s ruling and dismissed the application. The reasoning: the works council’s application referred to the old contract, which was no longer the basis for the deployment of external personnel. Since the works council had not adapted its application, there was no legally relevant subject matter in dispute. The LAG did not grant leave to appeal on points of law.

How to Draft an Effective Declaratory Application

The case shows how important a precise formulation of the declaratory application is. An application for a declaratory judgment under Section 256 ZPO (Code of Civil Procedure) must be so specific that the court can clearly determine what it is to decide on. In works council hiring co-determination, the application should name the concrete measure, the affected persons, and the period.

It becomes problematic when the contractual basis changes, as in the present case. Works councils should therefore formulate their application so that it also covers later changes to the contractual basis. One option is to frame the application generally on the deployment of external personnel, without tying it to a specific contract. Alternatively, the application must be adapted promptly after a contractual change – and within the deadlines of the appeal proceedings.

An effective declaratory application could read, for example: „It is declared that the deployment of employees of Company X in the employer’s operation is subject to the works council’s co-determination under Section 99 BetrVG.“ In this way, the application is independent of the specific contractual structure.

Procedural Pitfalls: When Applications Must Be Adapted

The ruling of the Hessian LAG is a warning to all works councils to strictly observe procedural deadlines. The cross-appeal deadline is generally two weeks after service of the grounds of appeal. Anyone who misses this deadline loses the opportunity to defend their position in the appeal proceedings.

Moreover, the case shows that applications are not static. If the factual circumstances change, the application must be adapted accordingly. This applies particularly when the employer changes the contractual basis to evade co-determination. Works councils should therefore regularly check whether the facts underlying their application are still current.

Another stumbling block is the question of whether the deployment of external personnel qualifies as hiring at all. The LAG did not rule on this substantively in this case, but dismissed the application for formal reasons. This means: even if the works council had been right on the merits, it failed on procedure. This underscores the importance of careful conduct of proceedings.

What This Means for Works Councils and Employees

For works councils, the decision is an important signal: works council hiring co-determination is a sharp sword, but it only works if it is deployed procedurally cleanly. It is not enough to be convinced on the merits – you must also meet the formal requirements. In case of doubt, legal advice should be sought early to avoid mistakes.

For employees, the case is also relevant. If you have the impression that your employer is deploying external personnel without involving the works council, you can contact your works council. The works council can demand co-determination and, if necessary, enforce it in court. However, the case shows that such proceedings are complex and do not always succeed.

If you yourself are affected by a dismissal, you should know that the works council also has a say in dismissals. Further information on action for protection against dismissal can be found in our guide. The topic of company car entitlement for works council members also shows how important precise applications and deadlines are in labor law.

Conclusion: Maintain Precision and Deadlines

The ruling of the Hessian Labor Court makes clear that works council hiring co-determination is not only a question of substantive law, but also of procedural law. Works councils must formulate their applications precisely and react quickly to changes in the factual situation. Anyone who misses the deadlines loses their right – even if they are right on the merits.

For practice, this means: train your works council members in handling labor court proceedings, document all contractual changes carefully, and consult a specialist lawyer for labor law at an early stage if in doubt. Only in this way can you effectively enforce co-determination in hiring and protect the interests of the workforce.

Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.

This article is general information and does not replace individual legal advice. RechtStark is a litigation funder, not a law firm; you are represented by an independent lawyer.