Flexitime Time Tracking: What the Erfurt Labor Court Decided

Zeiterfassung in Gleitzeit: Was das Arbeitsgericht Erfurt entschieden hat – zeiterfassung-in-gleitzeit

The decision of the Erfurt Labor Court dated October 9, 2026 (case number 6 BV 23/26) deals with flexitime time tracking. The works council of an engine plant wanted to enforce that working hours before 6 a.m. are no longer accepted and all employees record their times via transponder. The court dismissed both applications. What does this mean for employees and works councils? This article explains the background and shows what rights you have.

The Case: Dispute Over Time Tracking and Flexitime at the Engine Plant

The respondent is a service company performing maintenance and repair work on the premises of an engine plant. Around 60 employees work there. Some work fixed shifts, others in flexitime. For flexitime, a works agreement provides for a framework working time from 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. Within this framework, employees can determine the start and end of their daily working time in consultation with their manager.

A works agreement also exists for time tracking: All employees receive a personal transponder with which they must book their working hours at terminals. The employer did not comply with this for two team leaders. These two employees had appeared regularly between 5 and 5:30 a.m. for many years. Their times were not recorded via the transponder but noted in an Excel spreadsheet. The employer had exempted them from the time tracking obligation.

The works council pointed out in writing in May 2025 that the works agreement was being violated. After no agreement was reached, the works council initiated a resolution proceeding before the labor court. It applied for the employer to be prohibited from accepting work performance before 6 a.m. and to be obliged to record the working hours of flexitime employees using the transponder system. The Erfurt Labor Court dismissed both applications.

Time Tracking Obligation: What Employers Must Observe Since 2022

In Germany, employers have been obliged since a landmark decision by the Federal Labor Court in 2022 to systematically record the working hours of their employees. The court derived this obligation from the Working Hours Act, which in turn is based on the EU Working Time Directive. The aim is to monitor compliance with maximum working hours and rest periods and to prevent overload.

The recording obligation applies in principle to all employees – regardless of whether they work shifts, part-time, or flexitime. Trust-based working time does not release the employer from the duty to document the hours actually worked. However, details such as the method of recording can be regulated in works agreements.

In the case before the Erfurt Labor Court, the employer had concluded such a works agreement on time tracking. The fact that he made an exception for two team leaders and recorded their times in an Excel spreadsheet contradicted the wording of the agreement. Nevertheless, the court apparently saw no enforceable claim of the works council for cessation. This shows: Not every violation of a works agreement can be enforced judicially by the works council. What matters is which right the works council invokes and whether the chosen type of application is admissible.

Works Council Co-Determination Rights on Working Time and Flexitime Time Tracking

The works council has a co-determination right when time tracking systems are introduced and applied. This arises from Section 87(1)(6) of the Works Constitution Act. Accordingly, the works council must co-determine when technical equipment is used that is suitable for monitoring the behavior or performance of employees. Time tracking terminals and transponders are such equipment because they make the start and end of each individual's working time visible.

The works council also has a co-determination right regarding the scheduling of working time (Section 87(1)(2) BetrVG). This concerns, for example, the question of when flexitime begins and ends or whether there is a core working time. In the Erfurt case, the works council had exercised these rights and concluded works agreements with the employer. It was precisely these agreements that the works council considered violated by the special treatment of the team leaders.

The works council's co-determination right is not unlimited, however. It relates to the regulation of working time, not to every single measure by the employer. Whether the employer violates a works agreement must be examined on a case-by-case basis. The Erfurt Labor Court saw no enforceable claim of the works council in the specific case. For practice, this means: Works councils should formulate their applications carefully and seek legal advice. How works agreements can be amended is shown in our article amending a works agreement.

Flexitime Time Tracking: What Applies to Employees?

Flexitime means: Employees can determine the start and end of their daily working time themselves within a fixed framework. This framework is often referred to as framework working time. In the Erfurt case, it lay between 6 a.m. and 6 p.m. Anyone working flexitime must therefore adhere to this framework unless another arrangement has been made.

For employees, this has concrete effects: Anyone who wants to start earlier in order to have the afternoon free may only do so if the framework working time permits it. If flexitime begins at 6 a.m., starting work at 5:30 a.m. is not covered by the flexitime regulation. If an employee nevertheless works before 6 a.m., the question arises whether this time counts as working time and how it is recorded. In principle, this time must also be recorded, because the recording obligation applies to every hour actually worked.

Time tracking in flexitime is not only a technical question but also one of co-determination rights. In practice, it happens again and again that superiors tacitly tolerate employees arriving earlier. This can lead to unequal treatment if other employees adhere to the times. Anyone working flexitime should therefore ensure that their own working hours correspond with the works agreement. If they deviate, they should clarify this with their manager and ideally record it in writing.

Exemption from Time Tracking: When Is It Permissible?

The recording obligation applies in principle to all employees. An exemption from time tracking is only permissible within narrow limits. The Working Hours Act itself provides for no exception. The Federal Labor Court has also emphasized that the recording obligation is not at the employer's disposal. However, works agreements can exempt certain groups of persons, for example executive employees, if they do not fall under the Works Constitution Act.

In the Erfurt case, the team leaders concerned were not executive employees within the meaning of the Works Constitution Act. They worked in the day shift and were subject to the flexitime regulation. The works agreement on time tracking expressly obliged all employees to use the transponder. No exception was provided. The employer nevertheless disregarded this.

The labor court dismissed the works council's applications. This does not necessarily mean that the exemption was lawful. It only means that the works council did not succeed with its specific application. Possibly another application, for example for a declaratory judgment on the violation, would have succeeded. For works councils, this is an important indication: The choice of the right type of application is decisive. An experienced specialist lawyer for labor law can help with this.

What Does the Ruling Mean for Employees and Works Councils?

For employees working flexitime, the decision is a reminder to keep an eye on their own working hours. Anyone who regularly works outside the framework working time should not simply accept this but seek a discussion with superiors. Flexitime time tracking is the most important instrument for documenting overtime and working time accounts verifiably. Without correct recording, proof of extra work is missing, which can backfire later during settlement or in a dispute.

For works councils, the case shows how important a precise works agreement is. Anyone who wants to ensure that working hours outside flexitime are not accepted should expressly stipulate this in the agreement. A mere framework working time alone is not sufficient to prohibit the employer from tolerating earlier work performance. The correct type of application is also crucial when enforcing co-determination rights. A resolution proceeding is complex and should be well prepared.

Conclusion: How to Secure Your Rights in Time Tracking Conflicts

The resolution of the Erfurt Labor Court makes clear: Time tracking is a complex field in which employees, works councils, and employers have different interests. Employees should ensure that their actually worked hours are recorded correctly. Only then can overtime and working time accounts be traced. Anyone working flexitime should know and observe the framework working time – or agree on deviations expressly with their manager.

Works councils should not only insist on their co-determination rights in the event of violations of works agreements but also choose the right legal steps. A resolution proceeding is often the last resort. All possibilities for clarification should be exhausted beforehand. And if proceedings do become necessary, legal advice is indispensable. If you as an employee or works council member want to enforce your rights, litigation funding for dismissal protection can help limit the cost risk – even though this is not about a dismissal, the example shows what financial support can look like.

Flexitime time tracking is not an end in itself. It protects employees against unpaid extra work and ensures transparency. Those who know their rights and actively assert them come out better in the end. Should you personally be affected by a time tracking conflict, seek legal advice early – a specialist lawyer for labor law can assess whether proceedings are worthwhile.

Note: This article is for general information purposes only and does not replace individual legal advice. For a free initial assessment of whether litigation funding may be an option for your case, you can contact RechtStark.

This article is general information and does not replace individual legal advice. RechtStark is a litigation funder, not a law firm; you are represented by an independent lawyer.